4 ms·
This isn't all that surprising. Although I didn't realize it was this bad. It's not just professors either. Look at any group where academic credentialing ma
by jedberg 5y ago
This isn't all that surprising. Although I didn't realize it was this bad.
It's not just professors either. Look at any group where academic credentialing matters (and even groups where it's not supposed to matter).
Most of the YC partners are from elite institutions. Many of the YC founders are too (to YCs credit this has gotten a lot better recently, but a while back it was either Ivy League or Berkeley/Stanford/Washington/CMU for the most part).
And I don't think YC does this intentionally nor many of the other groups where it happens. Academic signalling is just so ingrained that it happens subconsciously.
- nextos 5y agoIn fields like Biology or Medicine, where peer review is not double-blind, there's also what I would call a publication bias that perpetuates this elite cartel. If you submit an article to Nature or Science from, say, Oxbridge it has much higher chances to get in than if you submit from a good university like Southampton or Exeter. Professors from elite institutions are really well connected to editors and funders. Actually, many editors come from the same institutions. So while reviewers might treat you fairly if you submit from a less prestigious institution (I think this is also questionable), the editorial board will be less likely send you article for review.
- wolverine876 5y agoI would guess that YC founders typically come from a far more 'elite' subset of four-year colleges than the top 25%.