4 ms·
The really interesting thing about e-ink for me is having a low-power, high-resolution computer screen; an old Nokia 84×48 LCD uses about 3 mW, a megapixel-clas
by kragen 5y ago
The really interesting thing about e-ink for me is having a low-power, high-resolution computer screen; an old Nokia 84×48 LCD uses about 3 mW, a megapixel-class Amazon Swindle uses 100–300 mW during active use, and a modern megapixel-class cellphone screen uses about 1000 mW. Unfortunately, you just can't get high-resolution, low-power e-ink screens unless you're an ebook manufacturer; not only are the manufacturers uninterested in talking to hobbyists (or distributors like Digi-Key!) rumor has it they stop talking to you even about volume buys if they find out you're not making an e-book device.
So I thought this article was going to be about that!
Last year I learned that there's a kind of LCD that has even lower power consumption (during active use) by virtue of printing a whole flip-flop onto the glass at each pixel, called the "Sharp Memory LCD": https://www.adafruit.com/product/4694 https://www.adafruit.com/product/4694 not cheap at US$45 but available, and 400×240, a high enough resolution for everyday computing tasks. There are a variety of sizes available, but this particular display advertises “50 μW static, <175 μW dynamic”, that is, 0.05–0.175 mW, which is a really substantial improvement over 100–300 or even 3. And it's transflective so you can read it in the sunlight. At last, something you could plausibly build a battery-free portable computer with! And, as a bonus, it updates fast enough to play video games on.
Pulling once on a pullstring to wind up your computer yields potentially about 25 J. At 300 mW that yields a minute and a half of usage. At 3 mW, two and a half hours of usage. At 0.2 mW, 34 hours of usage. So below 1 mW you're into solar-calculator territory; I disassembled one of those solar garden lights with an LED and a rechargeable battery in it and measured its 38 mm square panel at 8 mW.
- dont__panic 5y agoI think those memory LCDs are what Pebble used to use for their watches. My Pebble Time Round still holds up to this day, shows me notifications promptly, lets me control music, and the hardware hasn't failed yet. Great screen and a great product.
- kragen 5y agoNice! It's really sad what happened to Pebble. Do you know how much power the watch uses?
- dont__panic 5y agoThe battery is 56mah, and the battery life is estimated at around 2 days. So just over 1mah per hour, I guess? Crazy to think that average current Android phones use batteries that are around 100 times the size of the battery on this watch!
- kragen 5y agoSo that's probably about 5 mW? It could probably achieve that power level with traditional passive-matrix LCDs like the Nokia LCD I mentioned. Hard for me to imagine it's using that much power on computation and Wi-Fi, but that's possible too.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThis functionality is part of some devices (or rather the softwre loaded on them), as with the Onyx BOOX Max Lumi series, which provides a 13.3" 220 dpi 1650x2200 16-shade greyscale display. I've not used it in that that mode, though I've certainly used it with Termux as a terminal driver. There are also freestanding displays sold. At larger sizes there is a considerable price premium. The Max Lumi runs $800--$900 itself.
- kragen 5y agoWhat's the power consumption of the Max Lumi? That's the crucial thing here! I'd be satisfied with 80×24 characters (400 × 192 pixels without grayscale). It's not optimal, but it's adequate for reading, including hypertext browsing of Kiwix, and writing, including text and code. The Nokia 84×48 pixel screen is inadequate.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI don't know, and the information's hard to come by --- I'm not finding a ready answer via search. There might be information from E-ink themselves (the display vendor), though they're also pretty tight-lipped. It's battery powered. Consumption depends on usage patterns. The battery on the Max Lumi 2 is 4300 mAh. Under my typical usage which includes much Web browsing, use of frontlights, and WiFi, 1--2 day battery life is typical. Optimized for e-book reading only (no radios or lights, periodic page turns), up to a week. If you're just looking at a static image ... forever. Running as an active display, I'd expect battery usage to the lower end of the range and for the display interface itself (HDMI) to account for a good chunk of that, though this is pretty uninformed speculation. Specs: https://onyxboox.com/boox_maxlumi2 https://onyxboox.com/boox_maxlumi2 Cutting out the middleman, if you're looking at e-ink monitors, there are the Mira and Mira Pro: https://onyxboox.com/boox_mira https://onyxboox.com/boox_mira https://onyxboox.com/boox_mirapro https://onyxboox.com/boox_mirapro Again, neither offer a specific power consumption rating. The Mira is effectively the Max Lumi display in a monitor package. No power draw spec that I see though it's drawn over USB-C. The Mira Pro is a 25.3" E Ink Carta display with a lower dot pitch (145 dpi) at 3200x1800.16 bit greyscale. I'd suspect that the major draw would be in the HDMI interface itself, as well as whatever the update frequency was. With e-ink itself, persistence is free, colours are few, paints are expensive. Pagination or cell updates (e.g., text terminals) probably fare better than raster graphics. Running additional processing (e.g., Web rendering, audiobook processing, frontlights, WiFi, Bluetooth) cut into battery life, though it remains excellent.