5 ms·
Does Boeing even make the radio altimeters?
by kube-system 5y ago
Does Boeing even make the radio altimeters?
- jandrese 5y agoThey certainly certified them on the aircraft. If it means putting pressure on the subcontractor that actually built them or finding a suitable replacement then so be it.
- gbear605 5y agoUnless the airlines are installing the altimeters themselves, it seems like Boeing is still the relevant company. If your car’s airbag has a malfunction, the car manufacturer does the recall even if the fault lies with the airbag manufacturer. Presumably Boeing would then go on to sue the altimeter manufacturer though.
- kube-system 5y agoYes, I am simply suggesting the accusations in the first two sentences are misplaced.
- theYipster 5y agoAviation doesn't work that way. Airlines have direct aftermarket relationships with all of the OEMs making the components on their airplanes. From a certification and warranty standpoint, Boeing is the design authority, and if there is an FAA mandated fix for 737 RAs, Boeing will have a role to play. Whether Boeing is responsible financially or logistically for the fix depends on the nature of the failure (is it limited to the component or is it a systems engineering issue) as well as the contracts Boeing has with their supply chain and their airline customers.
- manquer 5y agoThat doesn't seem to be practical. Maybe for some big parts like engine airlines have direct relationships but all parts including radar altimeters ? An modern commercial plane has tens of thousands of suppliers supplying millions of parts. No airline [1] could even imagine to have the staff to manage OEM relationships with that many indirect suppliers. That is what you pay Boeing for. If that was the case no airline could afford to buy more than 1 type of plane or certainly not more than one manufacturer, you would need to handle all the suppliers in the industry?! it would be incredibly inefficient to do this for them individually . --- [1] Maybe United , American or Delta could have that kind of staff, but given the airlines operating margins in the last 2-3 decades even that seems unlikely
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- theYipster 5y agoCommercial aviation works the way it works regardless of whether you think its practical. And you're grossly overstating how many suppliers are on a commercial aircraft. There are in total an average of 30 tier-1s on a modern airframe, and yes, airlines are expected to work with all of them. Radio Altimeters are typically made by avionics suppliers i.e. Collins, Thales, or Honeywell for Part-25 commercial airliners.
- p_l 5y agoEven a private owner can effectively have (if not direct, then through agents) connections straight to OEMs, bypassing original airplane vendor. There's a reason why the only time two airplanes are identical is when they roll from assembly line as part of the very same order with same spec, and never again.
- vkou 5y agoIt's Boeing's job to make sure that the altimeters they put into planes are fit for use. It doesn't matter if those altimeters are sourced from Boeing, General Electric, Uzbekistan, or the Moon - Boeing is the one who has to make sure they work. It's why they make the big bucks. Boeing can argue with and sue their suppliers, but that's not a problem for anyone but them and their supplier.
- mulmen 5y agoThe altimeters are fit for use.
- vkou 5y agoThey aren't, because they are not operating within their mandated frequency bands. If I made routers that flood the EM spectrum with random crap, even if their wifi 'worked' they wouldn't be fit for use, either.
- mulmen 5y agoThe altimeters are operating within their frequency bands. They are operating as designed and certified. The 5G towers are the ones doing the flooding.