12 ms·
> It could be bypassed by modifying the file slightly, but the hashing could also get more sophisticated. Which is the same thing as saying "have a higher fals
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> It could be bypassed by modifying the file slightly, but the hashing could also get more sophisticated.
Which is the same thing as saying "have a higher false positive rate," and then we have the problem.
This is exacerbated by the same kind of system having the same application for copyright infringement, which means there will be a large community of people dedicated to defeating it. Every time they find another workaround, you have to increase the false positive rate. It only ever goes up.
This is why everyone hates Content ID. The pirates know how to defeat it, meanwhile it regularly flags public domain works and recordings of randomly generated white noise to say nothing of fair use etc.
The solution to revenge porn isn't platforms, it's why isn't the ex getting called "defendant" by a judge for making the recording without permission?
- ppeetteerr 5y agoIsn't a high false positivity rate favorable to revenge porn being uploaded? Shouldn't it be on the uploader to prove that a scene depicting sex is legally filmed rather than assuming that it is?
- samhw 5y ago> Shouldn't it... Yes. Will it? No.
- rectang 5y ago> The solution to revenge porn isn't platforms, it's why isn't the ex getting called "defendant" by a judge for making the recording without permission? The court system's responsiveness to sex crimes could be greatly improved if we had the collective will to do so. But the problem is both in the courts specifically (because of who the judges are, and who the legislators who write our laws are), and also the wider world. Victim blaming and dismissal/minimizing of the harm inflicted are par for the course everywhere, in the justice system, in the general population, and in many subgroups. (You'll see them here on HN all the time.)
- tharne 5y ago> But the problem is both in the courts specifically (because of who the judges are, and who the legislators who write our laws are), and also the wider world. I don't think this is it. It's a matter of resources. Police and courts are already so overburdened that it's hard to get enforcement on anything that isn't practically life or death. Have you or a friend ever had your apartment burglarized or a vehicle stolen? The police will show up, usually after several hours, take a statement, after which you'll never hear from them again. In fact I don't know a single person in real life who was a victim of a burglary or auto theft where the perpetrator was caught, save for those cases like a car jacking where significant violence was involved. When the police and district attorney in any given city in the U.S. are looking at double-digit unsolved homicides and God knows how many unsolved rape cases, I don't think they're going to put a high priority on the fact that there's a naughty movie out there that someone willing filmed themselves in and is now regretful about. This does not mean folks don't believe these things matter, because they do. It's that relative to what the justice system is already dealing with, these things are much less important.
- iudqnolq 5y agoWhen the NYPD have a guess at who did around 30% of murders, compared to the London police at 90% - and despite more funding than a small army - you have to wonder if the problem is purely resources. In fact, the vast majority of police are assigned to tasks like traffic enforcement, in part because that brings in more reliable revenue. (I'm using "guess at" to refer to clearance rate because if the cops tell a prosecutor they think you murdered someone and the prosecutor says it was obviously someone else so they're not charging you that's generally counted as cleared.)
- volkl48 5y ago> When the NYPD have a guess at who did around 30% of murders This is false. NYC homicide clearance rates for 2021 look to be over 70% for the year, with Q4 2021 at 78%. (worst quarter - 55%, best - 86%). https://www1.nyc.gov/site/nypd/stats/reports-analysis/clearance.page https://www1.nyc.gov/site/nypd/stats/reports-analysis/cleara... > In fact, the vast majority of police are assigned to tasks like traffic enforcement NYPD is not known exactly known for a particularly large amount of traffic enforcement, to the point that I think you'd find most residents wish they did more of it.
- tshaddox 5y agoI don't follow the argument that the false positive rate necessarily goes up if you notice some successful attempts to defeat your system and update your system to detect some attempts. Is this some statistical law you're referencing, or do you just mean that people tend to do naive updates to these detection systems to make them more sensitive (not necessarily "more sophisticated")?
- Spooky23 5y agoIt’s just a convenient and lame excuse. Slippery slope stuff is the worst/laziest argument.
- armchairhacker 5y agoYouTube has definitely been flagging more false positives over the years, as pirates have gotten smarter. When you broaden the algorithm to flag more bad content, you also end up flagging more good content unless you narrow it in some other way. But the issue with YouTube etc. isn't flagging innocent people, it's flagging innocent people and then rejecting their appeals. It should be pretty easy for PornHub etc. to get videos "verified" by getting explicit consent from all parties filmed, so that they cannot be flagged and removed from the system. In fact, I really don't see any reason against a law requiring all porn sites to require verification for all videos (w/ retroactive revoke on the hosts). Nobody's being censored, and if you agree to be in a porn video you kind of waive your right to anonymity.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Nobody's being censored, and if you agree to be in a porn video you kind of waive your right to anonymity. Then the host gets hacked and your government ID gets published as a creator of amateur pornography. The risk of that is de facto censorship by chilling effect.
- pjc50 5y agoThe thing is, this was technically required in the US under USC 2257 for the past two decades: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2257 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2257 Although I think that says "produces" rather than "publishes" or "distributes", so pornhub themselves aren't liable but the boyfriend "producing" the film has committed an offence. Not that there's any will to enforce this. Closer to home, Scotland explicitly banned revenge porn, and has actually achieved some prosecutions.
- Permit 5y ago> The pirates know how to defeat it, Is this true? I never see feature-length movies on YouTube for example.
- mcbutterbunz 5y agoThey're out there for sure. The problem is, entities that own feature length films usually have more pull (money and lawyers) to get it removed. Furthermore, other easier avenues exist for sharing movies.
- teawrecks 5y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/fullmoviesonyoutube/ https://www.reddit.com/r/fullmoviesonyoutube/
- samhw 5y agoWhat about this: Take their IP. Make sure that, to them, it displays as uploaded. They can watch it. It registers natural-looking traffic. It does whatever else is necessary to satisfy them that it's on the internet (besides Google SEO; I'm not sure if that's expected). Otherwise, it doesn't exist and doesn't show for anyone else. In other words: blackhole it, shadow-block it. I feel like that has a chance of working.
- itake 5y agoIP addresses can be obscured. This inhibits journalists or activists that may want to obscure their identity. In the context of porn, perhaps the person uploading the video is the performer and does not want to attached their real ID to the performance.
- cgriswald 5y agoWe had a problem with anonymous trolls on a message board I managed decades ago. We created a simple profiling system and combined it with shadow-banning. It was highly effective. Surely in the decades since and with the profitability of profiling, this could be done here too. In the case of trying to block a specific video, it could be even more effective, because as soon as that video gets uploaded, you can assume the 'new' person is the same person as the existing profile—it doesn't really matter if you're wrong because even if it's two people, you're trying to stop them both. I'm not sure how this would in any way inhibit journalists or activists except that, they too, would not be able to upload the disallowed video to your site.
- itake 5y agoI don't think there are perfect answers here. Someone might use the same IP address of a bad actor (e.g. they share a VPN provider). One person may use the provider to watch Netflix, another person may use it to hide their identity to do bad things. From my limited experience in this space (I moderate a tiny social app that has problems with bad actors), IP address blocking had high false positives and low false negatives.
- ketralnis 5y ago> The solution to revenge porn isn't platforms, it's why isn't the ex getting called "defendant" by a judge for making the recording without permission? I imagine the repeated uploads aren't by the ex, after the first one
- mannykannot 5y ago> The solution to revenge porn isn't platforms, it's why isn't the ex getting called "defendant" by a judge for making the recording without permission? I would be happy to see more of that (expanding 'recording' with 'posting'), but the law itself has certain protections against false positives, that we need to be careful about.
- teawrecks 5y agoYeah, I pity the poor soul who has to ID content for takedown and goes into it thinking "This seems to be such a simple problem to solve: record a hash of the video file".
- irrational 5y agoThere are regularly stories in the news about judges giving slaps on the wrist for full on sexual assault. In comparison to that, what would a punishment for this kind of thing be? Absolutely nothing.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoI would do something like this, should work for any type of image. Original -> Upscale and Downscale. Alter the frame sizes ie 4:3, 1080p, 4K Encode all video formats in all video codex's. Make stills for timelines which are likely to be interesting. Use a variety of background filters like those seen in Zoom calls to obscure backgrounds and then use all the stills with and without backgrounds, and also alter the colouring/whitebalance. Hash Stills and you will have loads of stills! Train an AI to look for the stills allowing for colour changes like a slight filter to alter the colouring, or maybe do it in black and white. When still is suspected, hash the AI found stills against known stills Obviously different websites allow uploading of different formats/codexes which is a filter in itself and frame sizes Because of editing, an AI needs to scan the film, when a still is found, make a copy and hash it to see if there is a match. At least thats how I would do it. I think you can spend too much time looking at other stuff AI & training data and sometimes its the background objects which are more important, like clothing, jewellery & furniture, but these new background filters seen on Zoom calls also makes it harder for the AI stills recognition. Expensive in terms of cpu processing, but probably a better way to spend money than on human wages going through stuff/moderating.
- dehrmann 5y agoYou should look into Scale-invariant feature transform.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoIts beyond me now, I'm on a different more explosive short lived path, but the idea is out there for someone else to have a stab at.
- brokenodometer 5y agoHow many GPUs do you have for all of this?
- Terry_Roll 5y ago> At least thats how I would do it.
- romwell 5y agoWhat's the problem exactly with a higher false positive rate there? We're not talking about a crime enforcement unit here. We're talking about access to a platform, which doesn't owe it to anyone to provide it in the first place. You can take down 90% of content on Pornhub without any loss to anyone; adult models would gladly take a 1% false positive rate on new uploads vs. content getting rampantly stolen and shared without consent. The solution to revenge porn might not be platforms, but platforms can easily make this problem an order of magnitude smaller. That's to say, platforms can be the most significant part of the solution.