3 ms·
the problem with memetics is that genetics is a scientific area of study describing how genes replicate and memetics is trying to seem like a scientific area of
by bryanrasmussen 5y ago
the problem with memetics is that genetics is a scientific area of study describing how genes replicate and memetics is trying to seem like a scientific area of study by using genetics as analogy.
That is to say while genes can be studied and tested and predicted about, memes can be described by analogy - this is what genes do and this is how a meme is like a gene.
And this is why you get statements like 'memes, like genes, are "selfish" - their sole goal is to replicate'. Genes are this way because they have been tested and observed to be that way and there are good scientific reasons and theories explaining why they are this way, memes are that way because genes are that way and without genes as the guiding analogical relation then memes as a description for how knowledge and ideas are transmitted fall apart and are rendered unnecessary.
on edit: I should say this is written as someone who believe there could be a real scientific field born out of memetics and who has written hundreds if not thousands of pages as to how memetic transmission and evolution happen, but still, it is currently just a fancy analogy and nothing more than that.