2 ms·
Systems were simpler, This is a HN trope that gets trotted out every time a subject like this comes up. It's gone from amusing cliché to just boring and false
by reaperducer 5y ago
Systems were simpler,
This is a HN trope that gets trotted out every time a subject like this comes up. It's gone from amusing cliché to just boring and false.
Yes, the hardware was simpler. But the knowledge wasn't.
For example, when I first started with ray tracing in the 1990's, you used something like Turbo Pascal and had to actually know and understand all of the math behind what you were doing. Today it's just #include some random other person's library and you're off to the races.
Today if a developer wants to display a new font, they just add it to the massive tire fire pile of other abstractions they've copied from the internet. Back in the supposedly "simpler" days, you plotted out a font on graph paper, then actually did the math of converting those pixels into bytes for storage and display. And did the extra math to find ways to do it in the most efficient way possible.
The knowledge has changed, but the amount of knowledge hasn't.
Things are much simpler now than they were then. That's why programmers today think it's OK to waste so much of their computing resources. With the supercomputer power we have in our pockets, this should be a golden age of computing, but instead we use that power to feed people's vanity and addictions.
side-effects were better understood and contained.
If that was true, then retro computer enthusiasts wouldn't still be discovering features and capabilities today.
- Mezzie 5y agoThe first web pages I made I had to type into the OG Notepad. And there were no tools to help, and you had to support 3 resolutions + at least 2 browsers. This was before responsive design (or indeed any kind of HTML/CSS design practices) or media queries, so for each page of content I had to write six different pages. There were no guides to help with understanding Netscape vs. IE, no 24-hr tech updates/phones (so you'd take a vacation for a week, IE would update, and you'd come back to sad emails about how the site is broken), etc. Maintenance and upgrading was a nightmare. Luckily, we quickly stopped doing that, but the idea that things were easier back then is because people learned from what we were doing. In 20 years, people will talk about how easy it was to make things in 2022.
- ajmurmann 5y agoI think what you say is true in a way but also gets to the difference between simple and easy. Pulling in a library that does a lot of heavy lifting is definitely easier. The resulting system most likely isn't gonna be simpler though. You are now trying on a lot of code you don't understand and there is probably also lots of code that you aren't even using. This has very little downside to it till something goes wrong. Is it going wrong because you are using the library wrong or because the library has a bug? This isn't gonna be a big deal and gonna be obvious for the majority of cases, but the weird edge cases are gonna be what wakes you up at night.
- hnlmorg 5y agoYou're arguing different points on the same broader topic. The GP was talking about how much of the stack we don't know. Ie if something fails in an abstraction underneath what we develop in, then we're often fscked. And there are so many layers to the stack now that the simplicity of debugging the entire stack has gotten harder -- this is a true statement. However you are talking about the barrier for entry in software development. It has gotten easy. This is also a true statement but it doesn't make the former statement untrue either. By making it easier to write higher level code we end up obfuscating the lower layers. Which makes it harder to inspect the lower layers of the stack. So it's literally both simpler and more complex, depending on the problem. > > side-effects were better understood and contained. > If that was true, then retro computer enthusiasts wouldn't still be discovering features and capabilities today. This is a grossly unfair statement because you make a claim for one side of the argument and, without comparing it to the other side (ie are we still discovering features and capabilities of modern systems?) draw a conclusion that the original statement is false. So lets look at the other side of argument: in fact the reality is people are routinely finding optimizations in modern systems. For example you often see submissions on HN where hashing algorithms, JSON serialization, and such like have been sped up using ASM tricks on newer processors. Another example is some of the recent Rust code released that outperforms their GNU counterparts. It is also worth noting that modern hardware is fast so people generally optimize code for developer efficiency (a point you made yourself) rather than CPU efficiency. So fewer people are inclined to look for optimizations in the capabilities of the hardware. However once current gen becomes "retro", you might start seeing a shift were people are trying to squeeze more out of less.