3 ms·
There's no way their proprietary codec is less black magic than Opus is. I've rarely if ever seen a closed source codec designed by people who really know what
by astrange 5y ago
There's no way their proprietary codec is less black magic than Opus is. I've rarely if ever seen a closed source codec designed by people who really know what they're doing; they're usually just whatever the cowboy they hired thought would be cool. It's not like management is going to be able to tell if it's state of the art or not.
- dale_glass 5y agoWell, I say "black magic" because at least to me it's a quite mysterious creation. But I'm no audio engineer. It's a lossy codec that's for some reason fixed rate, and shrinks audio by exactly 1/4th. The resulting quality is very good (works perfectly fine for music), and it's much faster than Opus. It retains stereo and high frequencies and sounds just fine. I'm sure there's a tradeoff somewhere, but it's certainly good enough to hold music events without people complaining. I think it might be possibly related to codecs like AptX. So far I've not found anything competitive that we could use -- stuff is either closed, or far more CPU intensive.
- astrange 5y agoYeah, it sounds like ADPCM with a fixed ratio like that. It's extremely simple and adds no latency, which are both good for streaming. Usually a fixed compression ratio is a terrible tradeoff, but for streaming it kind-of makes sense.
- dale_glass 5y agoI don't think it's ADPCM since it sounds really good. I'm not an audiophile or have done any comprehensive testing, but it' the kind of quality a normal person would use for music without complaining.
- astrange 5y agoThat was meant to agree with you - AptX is a kind of ADPCM with some other filters added on, so this could be the same thing. That's how it gets low latency.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]