5 ms·
Something being normal in a bunch of places, especially places low on the HDI, democracy, press freedom, Gini etc. indexes and coefficients doesn't make it non-
by sofixa 5y ago
Something being normal in a bunch of places, especially places low on the HDI, democracy, press freedom, Gini etc. indexes and coefficients doesn't make it non-extremist from GP's ( and arguably "western" point of view).
Cutting arms for thievery, or jailing converts/gays/whatever or forcing raped women to marry their rapists or go to jail/get lashed for having sex outside of marriage are "normal" things in many theocracies. Are those things not extremist, abhorrent and abnormal for your average Westerner?
- rayiner 5y agoAh yes, the “those backwards brown and yellow people” argument. Also, the things you mention aren’t common in Asia, the Middle East, and Africa. They’re not cutting off people’s hands for stealing in Bangladesh. But western countries are in the distinct minority in believing that marriage can encompass gay relationships.
- jgwil2 5y agoAh yes, the "bad faith accusation of racism to score rhetorical points" retort. You're apparently a lawyer, so you're obviously willfully misreading the comment you're replying to.
- azth 5y agoIt's not accusation of racism, but it's quite clear that OP thinks lower of those places because they're not "democracies" or have "free press". As if those things are causal reasons of prosperity or something. Not to mention false accusations of people being forced to marry their rapists or something. Rape and sexual harassment are much much more prevalent in the decadent sexually immoral West that's a fact. We're proud of our "barbaric" laws that punish the thieves and rapists and murderers and fornicators. Don't force your "enlightenment" on us, we saw where it got your culture OP.
- sofixa 5y agoYou're conviniently missing two of my four arguments - HDI and Gini coefficient. Yes, democracy and free press are very nice to have, but you can't argue with low HDI. > Rape and sexual harassment are much much more prevalent in the decadent sexually immoral West that's a fact. That's just absolute bullshit. Yes, women are forced to be married to their rapists, and do get punished getting raped. Not everywhere, but it happens. Sexual assault and the like are underreported in the West, let alone countries like Pakistan and India where femicides and brutality against women are close to being normal and usually go without any consequences ( point in case, a brutal case in Pakistan made the international news because the perpetrator got punished after sustained media and public outcry).
- azth 5y agoAnd I don't suppose HDI and Gini have anything to do with the history of continuous colonialism and occupation by the West that continues to this day, do they? Just look at how the US is stealing $7Billion of Afghanistan's money today under Biden, so don't tell me about some wealth inequality when the West continues to siphon the wealth of countries it occupied in West and South Eastern Asia. > Yes, women are forced to be married to their rapists Maybe in some fringe cases or countries like India which already have a huge problem due to many factors, including a religion that does not seem to prohibit such actions. Now compare to when we had actual enforcement of Shariah and the evil doers were punished, before the West occupied us and forced their "tolerant and liberal" policies under the guise of "human rights", suspending the death penalty for criminals like murderers and those who spread corruption in the land, and it's no wonder these things are happening.
- sofixa 5y agoOf course colonialism and neocolonialism contribute a lot to the explanation behind HDI and Gini results, but the vast disparity between different ex-colonies shows it isn't that simple. Oh. I bid you good day sir ( i highly doubt a woman would speak the bullshit you've said about sexual assault and champion Sharia law), because the mere notion that laws based on a religion, especially one of those that treats half of the people as second class, and forbids conversions/atheism/agnosticism is anything but literally one of the worst possible ways to govern a country, is ludicrous and doesn't deserve engaging. There's nothing good to be said about a religious legal system. You can have tough punishments if the people so want based on actual legal principles, not because an old book people consider sacred said so.
- azth 5y agoBecause democracy and press freedom are the be all end all right? That being said, we're proud of our "barbaric" laws that punish the evil doers like thieves and rapists and murderers and fornicators. We saw what "enlightenment" has done to your culture. You can also stop making lies like forcing women to marry their rapists. What a straw man.
- sofixa 5y agoNope, but they are important for the functioning of a society. Not every country can just become a democracy ( there need to be significant civic and educational basics otherwise it probably won't work), but even the flawed ones are better to live in. At the very least because there you could criticise the people in power if you dislike their policies or want change, which are useful things to be able to do. There's nothing wrong with punishing murderers or rapists, but if the punishments are very severe ( chopping up heads or hands) the downsides for a wrong court decision become enormous. I'm not sure what the crime of fornication is supposed to be though. For mary your rapist laws: https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2021/apr/14/marry-your-rapist-laws-in-20-countries-still-allow-perpetrators-to-escape-justice https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2021/apr/14/m... I never said they are everywhere, but they tend to be more present in religious countries that put importance on the "purity" and "virginity" of a woman. Like with "honour killings", which are also a thing only in that type of country. And for the "the woman had sex outside of marriage because she was raped", there were a few recent cases in countries as supposedly developed as Qatar and UAE of foreign women being convicted of it.
- azth 5y ago> Nope, but they are important for the functioning of a society. > but even the flawed ones are better to live in Easily disproven by contradiction, specifically if by democracy you mean today's Western definition of it where anything is up for voting by any fool from the street. The Islamic Golden Age is a shining example of a prosperous nation that did not abide by today's Western definition of democracy. We have something called "Shurah" in Islam, which is a restricted form of opinion seeking and consultation of experts on the subject matter, a much more superior approach. What's ironic is that today the West doesn't even follow its fabled democracy and freedom of expression. We've literally just witnessed the double standards in what happened in Canada in the past few weeks. Rules for thee but not for me as they say. > the downsides for a wrong court decision become enormous That is why in Islamic Law, punishments are fended off with any ounce of doubt. Today, the West threw out the baby with the bath water, where even in clear cut cases like the Boston Marathon bomber, or the countless other cases where confessions were had not under duress, the killers and serial rapists are left to live. Fornication is having sex outside of marriage. Normalizing this behavior, as we see in the West today, leads to many casualties like the spread of STD's, teen pregnancies, destruction of families, call for so called "abortion rights", mixing of lineages, even siblings who don't know they're siblings grow up separate from each other and get attracted to each other, and countless other messes that are causing a decline in morality and dragging down society with it. It's known that sexual immorality produces new diseases that did not exist in previous nations, HIV being one clear example. We don't have marry your rapist laws in Islam, so it's a non issue for us. As a matter of fact, a rapist is severely punished, and can be executed depending on the situation. Yes, we value purity and virginity, not just for women, but for men as well. Honor killings are not part of Islam, and in fact, the punishment for and honor killing is to execute the killer. > there were a few recent cases in countries as supposedly developed as Qatar and UAE of foreign women being convicted of it. I heard about some of those cases, and they were not clear cut. e.g. the woman was drunk (another thing that should be prohibited and punished), so the testimony is difficult to prove. Ideally in such a scenario, both parties involved are to be punished.