4 ms·
Kissing in the Middle Ages
- cantrememberpw8 5y agoThe article's claim about the Council of Vienne is incorrect: the Council was condemning the errors of the Beghards and Beguines, one of which errors was the claim that a woman's kiss was sinful [1]. Thus, the Council was in fact saying it was not sinful to kiss romantically. [1] https://sensusfidelium.com/the-sources-of-catholic-dogma-the-denzinger/clement-v-1305-1314-council-of-vienne-1311-1312/ https://sensusfidelium.com/the-sources-of-catholic-dogma-the...
- throwaway5486nv 5y agoPeople not kissing often would have been a black mirror story back then. High tech low touch
- loa_in_ 5y agoI made it halfway through the article but I couldn't stand it interpreting all instances of "kiss" as kiss on the mouth. Kisses on the cheek would just as well be written down as simply kisses.
- scintill76 5y agoDo you have specific linguistic and cultural knowledge of that? It doesn’t seem so obvious to me (a layman).
- loa_in_ 5y agoNo
- ksdale 5y agoOr perhaps a kiss on the cheek wouldn't even register as a kiss and would be recorded as a greeting instead?
- quantified 5y agoIt would be worth another 300 or so words to clarify how good the medievalist knowledge is of kiss targets.
- black-tusk 5y ago
- ggm 5y agoI'm reading the Cambridge history of medieval europe and it observes quite frequently that people had literal real fears of the afterlife, and that the word-is-my-bond thing had some immediate currency. Popes were able to issue directions to kings and dukes, which required them to do things, and without Stalin's "where is the pope's army" reality, they accepted the direction. [I personally suspect that the ability of the pope to use religious fervour to call on OTHER kings and dukes for an army probably heavily influenced things, but it would be wrong to deny the religious aspect. Life was short and brutal, and there was no evident tolerance for athiesm, at least as recorded in this kind of history. It took the later rennaisance and reformation for aspects of roman/greek atheism to enter the conversation, and christians were just as likely as any other faith to deny truths in other written works and destroy them] A belief that a kiss represented a bond, a contract, that the kiss itself was bound into the agreement, and represented a material part of the agreement does not surprise me. Nor, that it forms a bond of fealty, and to disrupt the ceremony required acceptance of a change in law. Remember this is a time where at least for the nobility, to swear on oath you didn't do something was in some circumstances sufficient to be found not guilty. High status people did embarrasingly public penance to get out of excommunication.
- irrational 5y agoIt is interesting to look at ancient history and realize that "your word is your bond" was a real thing. Even "bad" people would, usually, not be willing to break oaths that they had made. It is shocking, in today's world, to imagine people actually taking a promise or oath that seriously. If a politician breaks their word, we don't think anything of it since it is so commonplace. I can't even imagine a society where once someone had given their word about something you would completely trust them on that issue since breaking your word would be unthinkable. Can you imagine drawing a box on the ground and having a person give their word that they will not leave it and then they would literally die before leaving the box? I can't even imagine living in that sort of society. I mistrust every single person I meet on a daily basis. I simply can't fathom having trust in anyone's word.
- fumar 5y agoWe have control over the human culture right? In unison we can make a difference?
- janmarsal 5y agoI guess the osculum infame now makes slightly more sense to me.
- BrissyCoder 5y agoEwww yuck dude.