3 ms·
Why is having a central authentication system a bad idea? Because you give central control to a central authority. How many security breaches are caused becau
by Terretta 15y ago
Why is having a central authentication system a bad idea?
Because you give central control to a central authority.
How many security breaches are caused because people use the same password across many sites?
Note that a single login to all sites is the same problem as a single password to all the sites. If the password is compromised, all the sites are compromised.
Facebook Connect is a good thing.
That conclusion doesn't follow from your remarks.
You choose to focus on two objections that are both false objections: that we have a choice between only a central auth system or many weak auth systems, and that we've lost all privacy anyway.
I believe the cost of central control over all online activity is higher than the cost of developers learning and implementing strong personally controlled authentication and the cost of educating users what history shows us about ceding too much privacy and autonomy.
I worry that Facebook Connect is an actively "bad" thing. I think a good thing would be for OS X Keychain or 1Password style tools to be built into browsers or operating systems to give master key + random auth key functionality to every user with users controlling their own online credentials.
It bears repeating:
Why is having a central authentication system a bad idea?
Because you give central control to a central authority.