4 ms·
If you're living in a very densely populated area and you "never have a place to park", you're doing it wrong. (To be clear: what are you parking? The whole po
by barrkel 15y ago
If you're living in a very densely populated area and you "never have a place to park", you're doing it wrong.
(To be clear: what are you parking? The whole point of a densely populated area is that you don't need a vehicle.)
- ars 15y agoBut I do need a vehicle - you try going grocery shopping with a bunch of kids and bringing back 10 or more bags without a car. I do know there are people who manage it, mainly by shopping almost every day, or by buying from stores very close to the house (and paying extra and dealing with a low selection). But, mass transit is not a complete solution. There are other use cases which you are not taking into account. I find very spaced out living, with a car, to be best. Ideally you have a centralized shopping area, so you only need to make one trip and get everything. (And of course no houses anywhere near it - keep all the stores together instead.) Even better is if the store area is right off the freeway so most of the time it's on the way to/from the commute. And if not, it's quick to get to.
- Goladus 15y agoSprawl does not mean a spread-out, rural area. Rural areas don't really have traffic problems in the way that metro areas do. Even suburbs of small cities don't have traffic problems on the same scale as major cities like NY, Atlanta, DC, LA, and Chicago. Traffic problems happen in dense, economically active areas. You have hundreds of thousands of people trying to move through the region every single day and that is what leads to the traffic jams. Sure, Kansas City is pleasantly spread out. Driving and parking there is very easy. But KC is also very small compared to most of the metro areas with serious traffic problems. Incidentally, food and grocery selection in the city where I live is vastly superior. Within a half-mile I have Trader Joes, Whole Foods and a standard supermarket (which caters to a much more diverse population to begin with) in addition to a number of specialty and ethnic markets. There's a farmer's market every Saturday right down the street. Also in close walking distance: Best Buy, REI, Bed Bath & Beyond, Blick Art Supplies, several bicycle shops. There's even a store that sells vinyl records. I walk to work. I have a car. I use it for groceries sometimes but not often. I never have a problem finding parking at the supermarket or at home. (parking anywhere else is dicey, though)
- ars 15y agoWere you arguing with me, or helping me make my point? Because I agree with what you wrote - that's my experience as well. (And where you live sounds just like where I live.)
- Goladus 15y agoNeither, really. Though I might not have been clear-- I live in a densely populated area where there's public transit and I don't use a car much. I grew up in rural areas where the spread-out method works better. What doesn't work is trying to solve traffic problems by spreading everything out. In places that already are spread out, there really isn't a traffic problem to solve and communities can decide whether they want mixed-use environments or segregated environments based on other factors. In places where you already have a critical density (like Eastern MA where I live), spreading things out is no more feasible than a subway in rural Ohio. Right now, trying to drive from Cambridge to Waltham at 6:00pm will probably take 45-60 minutes due to traffic congestion. That's because of all the people trying to leave Boston for the suburbs.
- barrkel 15y agoIf I need a car for a short time period like shopping, I can rent one short-term - there's a car club parking spot about 2 minutes walk from my house, and costs about 5.50 GBP per hour, including fuel - or I could take a taxi. Of the people (i.e. mothers) I know who have done this, they've always taken taxis, to and from the supermarket, once a week. If shopping is the primary justification for having a car, the cost doesn't outweigh the alternatives. I find spaced out living not conducive to walking from one shop to another, to a cafe to meet with friends, to a theatre or cinema, to a restaurant, to a pub; without limitation on alcohol consumption etc. A centralized shopping centre already exists - it's called the town centre. I personally prefer to keep well away from freeways, motorways and their ilk. They're loud, ugly and mind-crushingly boring to drive on. I also think they scar the social landscape in a particularly unpleasant way - they tend to separate communities on either side, almost like rivers. It's clear that our preference functions are very different. Mine is probably largely coloured by having grown up in a very walkable town in the west of Ireland (Galway), and now living in London; and having been horrified by the way most US cities are put together (i.e. apart from places like NYC and SF). Driving around the upstate NY / PA area very clearly brought home to me how much I'd hate to live there, and driving around silicon valley on the 101, 280, 85 etc. was much worse, reminiscent mostly of a massive industrial estate. The only two places I've seen that I'd seriously consider in the US would be the aforementioned SF and NYC, and perhaps Boston. But I do however have a vehicle - two actually: a scooter and a motorbike. In London, I enjoy negotiating (i.e. filtering or lane-spltting) the traffic - I rather prefer busy streets to empty ones, and anything is better than a motorway.
- ars 15y ago> It's clear that our preference functions are very different. No kidding. I can't think of a place I'd rather not live in more than NY, with Boston taking second place. A town center is not a replacement for a centralized shopping area. Town centers usually have high rents, so the stores are small and/or overpriced. They have their purpose, but they are not a replacement. > having been horrified by the way most US cities are put together And I like it, and am horrified by places like London and NY. I'm glad the US is big enough that there is room for all types.