9 ms·
Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations
- relix 15y agoPerfect way to breed resistant mosquitos.
- krosaen 15y agohopefully they'll become resistant by not being attracted to the bait, and as a side effect, no longer attracted to humans?
- TeMPOraL 15y agoThe bait has nothing to do with the need for blood. It's a food source they need.
- narag 15y agoIIRC, only females are parasitic. If you poison males, the population will be reduced for the next generation... or the surviving males will have extra work :-)
- krosaen 15y agoright but they're presumably attracted to humans via some mechanism, just saying I hope it's the same mechanism for which they're attracted to the nectar so that if the population becomes resistant to the poison by no longer being drawn in by the nectar, they are also no longer drawn to humans.
- clarkevans 15y agoThe article says boric acid (used for cockroach as well as ant control) is relatively safe for humans, cheap, effective, and “it kills in so many ways that there’s never been resistance to it."
- relix 15y agoNext line "Some authorities think there never will be." It's still possible they'll get resistant one way or another. The article claims 10% survived. This doesn't mean they're resistant to the dye/boric acid, it probably just means they never tried the bait. It's possible they'll become resistant to the bait (i.e. the bait won't attract them anymore).
- jws 15y agoThey used different toxins in different tests, a modern bacterial toxin targeting mosquitos, and then simply boric acid, about which they say: … and it kills in so many ways that there’s never been resistance to it. Some authorities think there never will be. Maybe it will select for mosquitos that will avoid the fake nectar, but that can be rotated and the mosquitos need to feed on nectar. They inadvertently tested the boric acid on the local human population when they used fermented juice in the bait pitchers. It proved largely harmless to humans who drink jugs of random, poisoned alcohol they find laying around.
- relix 15y agoThat's true. I think they'll much faster start smelling and becoming repulsed by boric acid, however, than they will start avoiding fake nectar. Which is practically the same as being resistant.
- burgerbrain 15y agoSo we'll have created an effective insect repellant. Awesome.
- pinko 15y agoI'm not qualified to judge whether or not it's true, but if you actually read the article, they address this concern directly: Boric acid is much less expensive than Spinosad. It is also about as harmless to humans as table salt is. It is a chief ingredient in Silly Putty. Dr. Schlein said he had heard that some Malians sampled the alcoholic bait brew, with no ill effects. But it kills insects that eat it. It is common in cockroach control; when a thin layer is spread on floors, cockroaches take it in when they preen their feet. “You can buy it by the truckload,” Dr. Christensen said. “And it kills in so many ways that there’s never been resistance to it. Some authorities think there never will be.”
- mun2mun 15y agoYou are absolutely right. Every test results like this don't focus on other 10% that survived the test. Same is true for cockroaches, rats too. Animals with high breeding rate can be controlled but not eradicated that easily.
- IanDrake 15y agoThis could really have a positive effect on world wide health and I applaud the Gates foundation for taking on such lofty goals. Question though, despite absolutely loving the idea of a mosquito free world, is there a consequence to eliminating mosquitoes from the food chain?
- cryptoz 15y agoIt seems as though we expect no adverse consequences to their total elimination: http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100721/full/466432a.html http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100721/full/466432a.html
- sliverstorm 15y agoI don't understand the conclusions that article draws. It spends 90% of it's time talking about how important mosquitos are, and then says "but that doesn't matter". I also think it's pretty ridiculous to assume some other insect will just fill in the gap before we wipe out untold numbers of plants and animals.
- Terretta 15y agoThis link was cited twice here, both times using the conclusion from the article's subhead: "Eradicating any organism would have serious consequences for ecosystems — wouldn't it? Not when it comes to mosquitoes, finds Janet Fang." But I agree with you -- careful reading of the article itself suggests otherwise. For example, "Taken all together, then, mosquitoes would be missed in the Arctic — but is the same true elsewhere?" or "the loss of these or other fish could have major effects up and down the food chain" or "without mosquitoes, thousands of plant species would lose a group of pollinators." Any "but that doesn't matter" commentary is couched in weasel words like "unlikely", and the concluding quote is from a mosquito control association. Finally, article makes this remark, "Ultimately, there seem to be few things that mosquitoes do that other organisms can't do just as well — except perhaps for one. They are lethally efficient at sucking blood from one individual and mainlining it into another, providing an ideal route for the spread of pathogenic microbes." We don't know the long term effects to evolutionary processes of losing that inter-species blood to blood route, and I for one would like to see a citation saying such a mechanism, existing since the Cambrian era 79 million years ago, is irrelevant at large time scales. // Disclaimer: Almost everyone in my family contracted malaria while living in Africa.
- simonsarris 15y agoThat's pretty neat. I use boric acid for restoring rotted wood in my old 1800's house. It's been well known for a long time to stop insects. You can actually buy rods of the stuff to insert into rotting (or in danger of rotting) wooden beams (such as a beam in the foundation of an old house that gets too wet). When the wood gets wet the beam spreads and stops any further mold rot or insects (roaches, ants) from harming it. It's amazing stuff really. For other rotting pieces of wood you can create better mixtures with other easily available ingredients and sort of "paint" with the stuff.
- TeMPOraL 15y agoIANABiologist, so I wonder, what's the chance that this nectar will also kill 'friendly' bugs, like bees?
- cpfohl 15y agoThe article said that they used, "[...]Spinosad, a bacterial insecticide considered harmless to humans and most beneficial insects." Boric acid kills bugs. All of them (as far as I understand). Based on this incomplete data it looks like if Boric acid were used it would have to be baited with something that would not attract friendly bugs. Perhaps a vat of pig's blood laced with Boric acid or something similar would only kill of blood sucking insects. That'd be kind of nice...
- civilian 15y agoWondering about the same thing. I'd be worried about bees also going for the poison sugar.
- 0x12 15y agohttp://www.nature.com/news/2010/100721/full/466432a.html http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100721/full/466432a.html Makes a good case for why eradicating mosquitoes will not be problematic. But every time there is a large scale intervention like this the side effects only become apparent decades after the fact. You mess with ecosystems at this scale at your peril. Even if we can't see any downside to this today that doesn't mean there isn't a downside. DDT looked pretty good once upon a time. Another problem is that we simply have not mapped all the interactions between species within an ecosystem and eradicating one species might upset the balance in a hard to predict way. Introduction of a new species can be problematic: http://www.animalcontrol.com.au/rabbit.htm http://www.animalcontrol.com.au/rabbit.htm We have some solid proof for that. Maybe 40 years from now we will know why eradicating something as obviously harmful as a mosquito can be problematic too. That's the only way to learn, it would be nice if this research was proven correct.
- gerggerg 15y agoI think the major difference between this attempt at species destruction and other previous attempts is the massive amount of human disease and death already perpetrated by the clumsy little biters. It comes down to determining whats better: not messing with the environment and continuing to allow hundreds of thousands of human deaths a year. or trying to kill off mosquitoes. Wikipedia claims that malaria alone causes 2.23% of yearly human death world wide. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaria http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaria Thats a pretty ridiculous number if you think about it.
- nate_meurer 15y agoHuh? What previous attempts at species destruction are you referring to?
- paganel 15y ago> Huh? What previous attempts at species destruction are you referring to? This one, maybe: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Pests_Campaign http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Pests_Campaign ?
- wwwwrrrr 15y ago> And that, according to scientists from Hebrew University in Jerusalem, is an Achilles’ heel — or Achilles’ proboscis — through which the pests can also be poisoned. This thread presents a great opportunity to discuss the Arab-Israeli conflict. Who wants to start?
- 0x12 15y agoWrong forum.
- wwwwrrrr 15y agoYeah, you're new here, aren't you? Just today there was a thread about the Dead Sea scrolls being put online thanks to the Israel museum. One of the prominent comments there is about how Israel "stole" the scrolls. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3041572 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3041572
- Ryan_Shmotkin 15y agoAnd all it took is a $1M grant ?
- cpeterso 15y agoThe insects will win in the end. They are too numerous and reproduce so rapidly that they can out-evolve humans. Well, it's a fun though experiment, at least. :) In the The Hellstrom Chronicle, a 1971 Academy Award winning quasi-documentary/science fiction/horror film, a fictitious scientist called Dr. Nils Hellstrom presents scientific-sounding theories that insects will ultimately win the fight for survival on planet Earth because of their adaptability and ability to reproduce rapidly. The human race will lose this fight largely because of excessive individualism. The film provided the inspiration for Frank Herbert's science fiction novel Hellstrom's Hive. https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/The_Hellstrom_Chronicle https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/The_Hellstrom...
- jalanco 15y agoI welcome the death of all mosquitoes. But correct me if I'm wrong: 1. Mosquitoes are the greatest killer of people in Africa. 2. When mosquitoes stop killing people, the population will increase. 3. There will be less food to go around, and starvation will increase. 4. Therefore, food must be increased as mosquitoes are eradicated to prevent this consequence.
- mhb 15y agoWhen their children have a higher probability of living, parents will have fewer since it is more likely that the ones they have will be alive to support the parents.
- ars 15y agoYou are wrong. They don't kill as much as they cause malaise (from anemia), so people have low energy and grow less food. So mosquitoes cause starvation. Get rid of them and people will grow more food without prompting. You won't have less food to go around - you'll have more!
- jalanco 15y agoYour certainty is impressive. If only the natural world were so.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- polynomial 15y agoFun fact: The word nectar comes from a Sanskrit root meaning death. (ca. necropolis)
- robchez 15y agoDamn I should of applied for the grant. I use a similar system to kill fruit flys around my various fruit trees. Quick How-to 1. Cut 600ml bottle. 2. Invert top into opening (see pic). 3. Tape with red and yellow (i read somewhere that fruit flys are attracted to it) 4. Fill with something 'sweet', some honey or even apple cider vinegar. 5. Add a dash of detergent. (maybe some white oil) 6. Hang on fruit tree near fruit. The flys go in, they land on the mixture, detergent sticks to them and they drown. I have never seen a bee in there. http://imgur.com/EcyZM http://imgur.com/EcyZM