15 ms·
Of the four necessary conditions for defamation, they'd likely have the most trouble showing the "damages" condition (since both the journalist and the newspape
by woodruffw 5y ago
Of the four necessary conditions for defamation, they'd likely have the most trouble showing the "damages" condition (since both the journalist and the newspaper have been thoroughly repudiated throughout the entire affair).
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe bigger issue is probably the "actual malice" requirement as both the Governor and the reporter are public figures; it'd depend on what you could find in the Governor's emails etc. It's unfortunate that a public figure - and that's a fairly loosely defined status - can be defamed pretty much at will.
- woodruffw 5y agoThis would need to be decided by an actual court, but I'm not sure if the reporter would qualify as a "public figure" for the purposes of an "actual malice" test, since a "public figure" is generally either (1) an elected official, or (2) the unelected public representative of an elected official. There is additional lower court jurisprudence for "involuntary public figures" (the canonical example being a private citizen who receives public attention for an act of heroism), but that test hasn't been developed fully and it's unclear if it would even apply here (since the name of the reporter hasn't featured prominently in other reporting). (The "public figure" nature of the Governor or his office also doesn't apply here, since he's the accused defamer and not the defamee.)
- ceejayoz 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_figure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_figure > A person can become an "involuntary public figure" as the result of publicity, even though that person did not want or invite the public attention. A person can also become a "limited public figure" by engaging in actions which generate publicity within a narrow area of interest. For example, [jokes about] ... Terry Rakolta [an activist who spearheaded a boycott of the show Married ... with Children] were fair comments ... within the confines of her public conduct [and] protected by Ms. Rakolta's status as a "limited public figure". Celebrites have a hard time suing for defamation due to their status as public figures. The reporter in this case likely qualifies as an "involuntary public figure" due to the coverage of all this, and might be a public figure just by being a reporter.
- woodruffw 5y ago> The reporter in this case likely qualifies as an "involuntary public figure" due to the coverage of all this, and might be a public figure just by being a reporter. Maybe. I actually can't find a ton of case law on print reporters as public figures: there's a great deal of case law for television journalists (nearly universally in their favor), but comparatively little for newspaper journalists.
- tenuousemphasis 5y agoSeems pretty clear to me... > “We are grateful to the member of the media who brought this to the state’s attention,” was the proposed quote attributed to the state’s education commissioner before Parson began shooting the messenger.
- jrochkind1 5y agoRepudiated? 1. refuse to accept or be associated with. "she has repudiated policies associated with previous party leaders" 2. deny the truth or validity of. "the minister repudiated allegations of human rights abuses" 3. refuse to fulfill or discharge (an agreement, obligation, or debt). "breach of a condition gives the other party the right to repudiate a contract" Did you mean this word?
- giaour 5y agoAny attorneys' fees and court costs incurred as a result of the governor launching a retaliatory investigation seem like they would be concrete damages.