3 ms·
Since we already had the discussion about FCC regulations, society's downfall from phones, and advice on traumatizing your kids can I ask for an aside on the th
by Spivak 5y ago
Since we already had the discussion about FCC regulations, society's downfall from phones, and advice on traumatizing your kids can I ask for an aside on the theory of justice?
What is even the point of jailing him? This dude is an idiot, like beyond ignorance of the law. Society gains nothing buy jailing a man who is clearly not a danger to anyone, didn't even realize his mistake, and has no chance whatsoever of re-offending. And if you're gonna jail someone to make an example / as a deterrent you could at least wait until you find someone who actually did it with the intent to harm.
- tehlike 5y agoPersonal opinion without knowledge of the specific law: i hope he is fined reasonably(enough to inflict pain but not too much to put his family in hunger) on the condition that the next offense is jail. 34k is quite a lot even for a well of tech employee :/
- Spivak 5y agoThat's pretty much where I'm at, this guy basically deserves the adult equivalent of writing "I'm sorry for taking down my city's cell service" 1000 times on a blackboard.
- humanistbot 5y agoHe was negligent with a dangerous technology. The device is illegal to operate and sell, for obvious pro-society reasons. Ignorance of the law is no excuse, because then anyone can feign ignorance, making all laws contingent on one's ability to pass as ignorant. Or the laws become contingent on how likely prosecutors, judges, and juries are willing to extend the benefit of the doubt to the defendant, and people have all kinds of conscious and unconscious biases about who "seems trustworthy."
- Spivak 5y ago> making all laws contingent on one's ability to pass as ignorant Courts already have to evaluate mens rea and judges who make sentencing decisions take ignorance into account. > likely prosecutors, judges, and juries are willing to extend the benefit of the doubt to the defendant This is already how the law works.
- humanistbot 5y ago> This is already how the law works. You say that like it is a good thing.
- tenebrisalietum 5y agoPeople can fake being idiots, or aren't idiots but do overreaction-idiotic stuff for group-dynamics reasons so that's why the sentence should be possible. Is this guy really an idiot? That's a job for a judge to determine - which is the human element that is supposed to be a counterpart to the code in a system of law.
- dntrkv 5y agoHow do you know that was really his intent? There are many other avenues for parental controls in iOS and Android, and many providers also offer this service. He chose the options that was not only illegal but one that would prevent his neighbors from using their phones, possibly during an emergency. He’s either dumb or he had other intentions in mind. But this is why we have the courts to decide these matters.
- josephcsible 5y agoHow is blocking everyone's 911 calls "clearly not a danger to anyone"? How is putting him in jail different from putting people who drive drunk in jail?
- Bancakes 5y agoHow is he an idiot when he just ran a signal jammer non maliciously? He had no schemes. Just because you don't care about the law bogeyman doesn't mean you're an idiot.