8 ms·
East Coast vs. West Coast Butter – What Is the Difference? (2019)
- OJFord 5y agoRest of world enters the chat, and furrows its brow at 'butter stick' entirely! It's more of a pain than cups (which have numerous standards but they're basically close enough not to matter - especially if you assume it's one of the US sizes) when '1 stick butter' pops up in a recipe.
- refurb 5y agoBut a stick is a half-cup
- katbyte 5y agoI live in Canada, cook a lot, and didn’t know that till today.
- refurb 5y agoYour sticks of butter don't have these markings on the wrapper? https://www.dreamstime.com/stick-butter-measurement-markings-stick-butter-tablespoon-cup-markings-horizontal-image193633272 https://www.dreamstime.com/stick-butter-measurement-markings...
- EdwardDiego 5y agoKiwi here, nope. We do have a grams marking on some brands' blocks of butter. But it's far simpler looking, it's just a "cut here for 50g, 100g..." series of lines.
- pjc50 5y agoBrit here: no markings on block butter wrappers at all..
- bregma 5y ago"Sticks" of butter are something a Canadian only sees when they travel to the USA or watches American television. Butter is just not obtainable that way here.
- pantalaimon 5y agoBut what’s a cup?
- rawling 5y agoTwo sticks.
- meepmorp 5y ago236.6 ml
- refurb 5y ago250 mL
- EdwardDiego 5y ago2 gills, obviously.
- bregma 5y agoIt's a letter index for the difference between the fullest part of the chest and the lower part of the chest, measured in inches.
- ThePadawan 5y agoI've gotten pretty used to non-metric measurements being weird, so I don't mind when I see "1 stick of butter" used as a measurement. What it still is, though, is visually hilarious. When I think of "stick", I think of something you hold in your hand, wave around, or throw far away for a dog to fetch. Now imagine that, but with butter!
- thaumasiotes 5y ago"Stick" means something very similar to "baguette". Do you also find it hilarious to refer to bread as a "baguette"? For that matter, do you find "breadsticks" hilarious too?
- EdwardDiego 5y agoDid you really need to be offended by that?
- thaumasiotes 5y agoWho's offended?
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoYou are assuming a stick of butter doesn't have a standard amount, which simply isn't true. Each stick is a half of a cup and is a quarter of a pound even if the dimensions of the stick are different. If you need less, there are marking to cut it, much like the markings for grams on the butter in Norway. If I'm converting from sticks to grams, I use the above information as a guide or simply weigh it. The information to covert it is easily found online, I've done it many times - mostly, I've not lived in the US for many years yet I still want to make familiar foods.
- EdwardDiego 5y agoTo be fair, if you don't live in the US, how would you know that a stick is a standardized measure? ...is it a standardized measure? (Out of curiosity, is it a regulated measure? Would I be prosecuted for selling a stick of butter that doesn't weigh 1/4 of a pound?) In my country we wouldn't describe a solid in cups, just grams.
- pueblito 5y agoIt’s not a regulated measure, just traditional that each stick is half a cup and the wrapper has 8 marks so you can slice off a tablespoon easily. Each stick is 113g
- DiabloD3 5y agoSticks are marked with tablespoon markings on their wrappers.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> if you don't live in the US, how would you know that a stick is a standardized measure? Because you ran into it in the first place. You think cookbooks are giving out subjective instructions? "You said stick, but I don't know what that means" is a pretty reasonable conclusion to draw when you encounter the usage. "You said stick; you must not believe that words have meanings" is something else again.
- 5y ago
- paranoidrobot 5y agoWe have (metric) sticks of butter in Australia. They look like the West Coast shape, and is usually available as either 250g or 500g (17.6oz) sticks. Though when checking just now I see Lurpack are the odd ones out offering 400g sticks in a different shape. We do have tubs, but it's usually a blended variety of some kind.
- pjc50 5y agoGod, this went round on twitter about a month ago with "cup". Europeans: "how much is a cup?? Why can't I just use grams like I do with everything else?" Americans: "? It's a cup, just use a measuring cup?" E: "I tried that and my recipe came out wrong!" Me: "I regret to inform you that US cups, UK Imperial Cups, and metric cups are different sizes..." (If you're a non-American making US recipes, the easiest improvement you can make is buying a set of US measuring cups, which also cover things like tablespoon. These days they may be available from Alibaba or your local Amazon so you don't actually have to source them from the US)
- refurb 5y agoA UK and metric cup are both 250 mL and a US cup is 240mL and nobody cooking is getting an accuracy better than 10mL so they are all effectively the same.
- OJFord 5y agoNo, a UK/Imperial cup is half a pint - 568/2 = 284ml. It's the most outlying cup afaik. A traditional US cup ('US customary') is also half a pint - but that's of course a US pint, which makes it about 237ml. A 'US legal' cup (e.g. for FDA and nutritional labelling purposes) is 240ml. I don't know why that's shifted somewhat to metric when the US is otherwise so resistant! Most people cooking in Europe routinely get accuracy better than 10ml, because they're using scales rather than volumetric measures in many cases that Americans do. I agree it's unlikely to matter though, unless compounded out to many cups of something. If the water content is high, it's going to matter more (and be harder to control/write in a recipe) how much boils off for example.
- OJFord 5y ago> Me: "I regret to inform you that US cups, UK Imperial Cups, and metric cups are different sizes..." And I regret to inform you that that should read 'each of the US cups'! ('US legal' & 'US customary' iirc.) In practice though, sod it, it's 250ml (or maybe Imperial if that's the measuring glass I'm using anyway.. but it also has ml on) near enough, how long I let it boil's going to affect it more anyway.
- chuckSu 5y ago
- dvh 5y agoIn Slovakia standard size butter is 250g and dimensions are 40mm 75mm 100mm. Fat must be min. 82%
- mantas 5y agoI remember when butter standard in Lithuania was 200g, period. Now we got weird sizes of 190g or 175g.. And dimensions are smaller accordingly. Always gets me mad. Just increase damn price. Luckily few manufacturers still stick to old good 200g.
- lostmsu 5y agoJust FYI this dark pattern is called Shrinkflation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shrinkflation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shrinkflation
- ncmncm 5y agoAll that matters is, imported from Ireland, or not. More particularly: American dairies have to feed their cows subsidized corn (maize) or be uncompetitive, which makes the butter markedly lower quality. Some American dairies actually dye their butter yellow. (Note that "Amish Roll" butter is the same, just sold in a different shape.) Certain boutique dairies do pasture their cows, and charge a premium price, but supermarkets mostly don't stock that. In Ireland, cows eat grass. The US also gets butter imported from Poland, which is probably OK too. Neither government massively subsidizes maize. To get a tolerable price in the US for Irish butter, you have to buy it from Trader Joe's, which is sort of like Aldi's in Europe. (Complicated story there.) [Edit: Or Costco, looks like.] Likewise, Parmesan cheese from Parma, Italy. For many decades, the US government was telling Americans that saturated fat, as in butter and lard, was bad for their health, causing circulatory system disease. This, it turns out, was never true, and has long been known within the US Food and Drug Administration to be untrue. The diseases were, it turns out, caused by trans fats and sugar, both of which have been massively promoted. Trans fats were mostly banned in 2017, although certain companies get waivers to continue poisoning people. Tl;dr: eliminate unnecessary sugar, add butter and lard from Ireland or other non-US sources.
- Dwolb 5y agoFWIW pretty much all high volume food products in the US have some sort of similar “gotcha”.
- Cerium 5y agoDo you have some others in mind? I have one for rice: buy California produced rice. Other rice producing parts of the country were historic cotton farming regions, which continue to have significant pesticide residue. California rice will prominently mention the location on the bag. Edit: a quick search shows that it is arsenic contamination in question. On average California rice has about 35 percent less.
- ncmncm 5y agoAlso: short-grain rice is better than long-grain. And, if you must buy white rice, basmati is better for you. It is true that many foods in the US have badly distorted value perceptions. Probably worst, today, from a public health standpoint, is that sugar is crammed into everything. It is a public-health disaster that absolutely dwarfs COVID-19, but gets no attention. Probably listing "Fructose: 23g" on labels is the first step to fixing that.