3 ms·

Now take the charged sphere and connect it to ground with a wire. At the moment you connect it, what happens to the unbound charges that are on the surface of t

• CamperBob2 5y ago
  what happens to the unbound charges that are on the surface of the sphere? That's what I'm asking. Are you're saying that yes, I can draw a spark from the exterior of a perfect, unbroken, hollow metal sphere containing a van de Graaff generator and some batteries, or otherwise detect that there's any electrostatic activity inside the sphere whatsoever? (Actually I don't even see how a net charge can be produced inside such an unbroken conductor, thinking about it further. The VDG can only move charge around, it can't create a net imbalance inside the sphere. So the question becomes, what could? I have a feeling that while the corrected version of Feynman's statement is right in principle, it presumes a condition that can't actually exist in nature, like a magnetic monopole.)
  • alecst 5y ago
    > Are you're saying that yes, I can draw a spark from the exterior of a perfect, unbroken, hollow metal sphere containing a van de Graaff generator and some batteries, or otherwise detect that there's any electrostatic activity inside the sphere whatsoever? I prefer to reason about the simplest cases but since you asked again: if the total charge inside an unbroken ungrounded conducting sphere is zero the field outside it will always be zero, no matter how many VdGs are inside it.