6 ms·
Very interesting point. I think the difference is apparent, but how to define it? First, while he was very confident, I don't know that I'd call him a megaloma
by wolverine876 5y ago
Very interesting point. I think the difference is apparent, but how to define it?
First, while he was very confident, I don't know that I'd call him a megalomaniac. Second, he didn't encourage a cult of personality or manipulate it - he didn't spend his time inflaming it, encouraging it, toying with it; and he didn't use his power to troll and disrupt society.
- stickfigure 5y agoI'm confused by the categorical distinction you are trying to make between Jobs and Musk. What's the problem with electric cars that (almost) drive themselves, rockets that land themselves, and broadband internet in remote places?
- headass 5y agohe calls people pedos for no reason and then bitched about being sued
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vecinu 5y agoElon is manipulating markets with his tweets (See the 420 debacle), insulting random people and lying about how advanced FSD is. Please look at all the crazy tweets he posted [1] in the last few years, he is a manipulator and a liar. [1] https://elonmusk.today/ https://elonmusk.today/
- Negitivefrags 5y agoI’m not sure I would agree that this is lying or manipulation in the way that you would normally define those things. I do think Elon is a bit of a troll, and also that he is prone to saying things that he thinks are probably true without really verifying them fully. I think that he says things on social media with approximately the same level of internal surety that you might apply to talking to a friend in a casual situation. You might be quite willing to say to a friend “we are going to finish the X project in 6 months” without really calculating the odds of that actually happening, and without your friend calling you a liar in 6 months when that doesn’t happen. Now you can argue that he should apply a larger degree of rigor when positing on social media because he is a famous person running a big company, and maybe so. But he might also argue that why should he be held to a higher standard on Twitter than any random joe posting garbage to thier feed for friends to read?
- Cthulhu_ 5y ago> why should he be held to a higher standard on Twitter than any random joe posting garbage to thier feed for friends to read? Because he is an influential spokesman for one of the highest valued stock market traded companies in the world, and a throwaway comment can cost billions. I mean sure, if you're cynical enough you can pooh-pooh it as monopoly money for the 0.01%, but this same monopoly money fuckery caused the 2008 financial crisis. If he 'accidentally' crashes Tesla, that's hundreds of billions disappearing into thin air. Monopoly money, sure, but it'll drag down a lot of others - including things like pension funds.
- pksebben 5y agoMusk's financial trolling harms the same people who caused the 2008 crisis. Securitized mortgage debt and a desire to have what is essentially roulette-at-scale be predictable both come out of the same greedy hubris - that you should be able to move beans and become extraordinarily wealthy for it.
- wolverine876 5y agoConsider, for example, Musk's personal attacks on people like Elizabeth Warren. IIRC, Jobs did nothing like it. Jobs also didn't compare the Canadian Prime Minister to Hitler, and much of the other endless attention-grabbing, disruptive behavior of Musk.
- stickfigure 5y agoWho cares? Why do you take anything posted to twitter seriously? "Evil genius dominates world economy through twitter messages" is just not a thing. Musk is relevant because of Tesla, SpaceX, Starlink, and possibly a few other companies in the works. Maybe he gets some credit for PayPal too. Any one of those things would be sufficient to make his twitter personality a minor footnote in history.
- IntelMiner 5y agoHe's the villain from Atlas Shrugged. Siphoning tax payer money to fund his bathtub fart bubble 'ideas' He also calls people he disagrees with "pedos" and posts Hitler memes on twitter about vaccinations
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoThe MIC siphons off way more money. He is saving taxpayers tons of money.
- niek_pas 5y ago> electric cars that (almost) drive themselves Vast overstatement.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoSo much of an overstatement that Musk has to compensate by calling it FULL self driving, and then break it down into levels of not full-ness.
- wolverine876 5y agoThe question seems disingenous, as I wasn't talking about their products. What about the things I was talking about?
- lazide 5y agoJobs definitely did all those things, he was just edgy in a (now) more socially respected way, but he definitely wasn’t at the time.
- urthor 5y agoPretty much. The only difference between Jobs and the others is that Jobs made more stuff that consumers like, and was more successful. Humanity loves a successful megalomaniac. They just despise the also-rans.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThat's probably it. Jobs was a prick but not like Trump in many ways. I mean he was actually rich instead of just playing the part for one, lol.
- nicoburns 5y agoI think the closest contemporary equivalent of Steve Jobs is Elon Musk. Clearly egotistically and self-obsessed, but never-the-less a very impressive person who is deeply involved in the details of the everyday running of their company, and is creating things that nobody else could in quite the same way.
- urthor 5y agoElon is just strange. He... does not seem like he would be as successful as he has been, to hear him talk. I haven't researched him much if at all. But I genuinely wonder how much of his success is simply the fact he had the seed capital and was utterly fearless. What important lesson do you learn about from following Elon Musk, other than "just keep going."
- nicoburns 5y agoI think the seed capital and fearlessness is part of it, but I think he's also a damn smart engineer and by all accounts he gets down into the details of projects his companies are working on at times.
- dustymcp 5y agoHe wouldnt recognize his own family for years he was in every sense a psychopath..
- hericium 5y ago> he was in every sense a psychopath Not every person struggling with mental issues has psychopathy.
- zabzonk 5y agoHe certainly recognized and loved his adoptive parents (from whom he took his name). I am not a great Jobs or Apple fan, but "psychopath" is way over the limit.
- dustymcp 5y agoThat was not the family i was talking about see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisa_Brennan-Jobs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisa_Brennan-Jobs
- mcv 5y agoMany CEOs are apparently psychopaths. A psychopath doesn't have to be a remorseless killer. In fact, years ago I read an article about a psychiatrist or research who accidentally discovered that he was a psychopath himself, despite being a loving family man. Psychopathy is more subtle than just the extremes that are popular in media. I'm far from the biggest Apple or Jobs hater, but I think there's a good chance that he'd fit the criteria for psychopathy. The big question I haven't seen a good answer to yet is: why are CEOs so much more likely to be psychopaths? Does the power make them psychopaths? Are they attracted to the power of a CEO? Or do psychopaths actually make very effective CEOs? I have no idea.
- throwaway17_17 5y agoI am on mobile at the moment so I don’t have easy cites, but most of the research on ‘high-functioning’ psychopathy tends to lend credence to the thought that in the Western market CEO’s job requirements make it much easier for psychopaths to excel. I know there is a book on the topic and it strongly suggests this is the case, just can’t remember what it is. Edit: spelling
- jraby3 5y agoHe probably would have had social media been more prevalent. It’s hard to say.