4 ms·
This is our industry now. Look at it in the face. We went from Steve Jobs, GNU, Linus Torvalds, Tim Berners-Lee, etc. to megalomaniacs, cults of personality, po
by wolverine876 5y ago
This is our industry now. Look at it in the face. We went from Steve Jobs, GNU, Linus Torvalds, Tim Berners-Lee, etc. to megalomaniacs, cults of personality, post-truth, frauds, and mass maniplation. Compare how the first iPhone was marketed to cryptocurrencies and Musk's products.
That's what many people think IT and our industry and our work is about, including the scammers, the cult-of-personality members, and much of the public.
- nerdponx 5y agoWas Steve Jobs not a megalomaniac surrounded by a cult of personality?
- odiroot 5y agoI guess the difference is, there was still a lot of substance behind Jobs. And delivering (mostly) good products. Now we're dealing with Elizabeth Holmes et al, who just cargo cult off Jobs' legend.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoNow we're dealing with Elizabeth Holmes et al, who just cargo cult off Jobs' legend Frauds have always been with us - charismatic frauds, even. That's generally how they defraud. How many times have people sold things like the Eiffel tower or various bridges around the world? How else did we get to Ponzi schemes and the MLMs that are the fallout (and technically totally not pyramid schemes)?
- wolverine876 5y ago> Frauds have always been with us ... This is the excuse of frauds - to try to normalize it. The amount of fraud is something we can have a large impact on, just like other diseases, and the frauds are responsible for their behavior - there is no fate or destiny that makes them do it. They have free will and make choices to hurt others. Currently, we aren't doing enough about fraud, and it's Orwellian to see people making efforts to normalize it.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoIt isn't that folks normalize fraud, but rather that fraud has been a thread in humanity for, well, a very very long time indeed, probably before we wrote this stuff down. In other words, it is normal for societies to have some fraud - though, it isn't a "normal" behavior since most folks aren't out defrauding folks on a large scale. People act like fraud is a modern thing, and it isn't - and definitely isn't a sign that we are just doing worse now than in some romanticized past. If we don't acknowledge that it is a thing humans do and have done for a long time, our solutions will never be adequate (if that is possible). We really should be learning from the past and applying some of those lessons to the modern ways folks do fraud. Charisma has been intertwined with fraud for eons as well. If something is fairly common among fraudsters, then it benefits us to point this out.
- wolverine876 5y agoThat's quite a strawperson - I haven't seen anyone say anything like that. Can you give some examples? The issue is the amount of fraud, obviously. My point is that people keep trying to downplay it and normalize it, including, IMHO, the comments in this thread. My perception is that the amount is much higher now than even the recent past, and that it's normalized and even celebrated by some.
- wolverine876 5y agoVery interesting point. I think the difference is apparent, but how to define it? First, while he was very confident, I don't know that I'd call him a megalomaniac. Second, he didn't encourage a cult of personality or manipulate it - he didn't spend his time inflaming it, encouraging it, toying with it; and he didn't use his power to troll and disrupt society.
- stickfigure 5y agoI'm confused by the categorical distinction you are trying to make between Jobs and Musk. What's the problem with electric cars that (almost) drive themselves, rockets that land themselves, and broadband internet in remote places?
- headass 5y agohe calls people pedos for no reason and then bitched about being sued
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vecinu 5y agoElon is manipulating markets with his tweets (See the 420 debacle), insulting random people and lying about how advanced FSD is. Please look at all the crazy tweets he posted [1] in the last few years, he is a manipulator and a liar. [1] https://elonmusk.today/ https://elonmusk.today/
- Negitivefrags 5y agoI’m not sure I would agree that this is lying or manipulation in the way that you would normally define those things. I do think Elon is a bit of a troll, and also that he is prone to saying things that he thinks are probably true without really verifying them fully. I think that he says things on social media with approximately the same level of internal surety that you might apply to talking to a friend in a casual situation. You might be quite willing to say to a friend “we are going to finish the X project in 6 months” without really calculating the odds of that actually happening, and without your friend calling you a liar in 6 months when that doesn’t happen. Now you can argue that he should apply a larger degree of rigor when positing on social media because he is a famous person running a big company, and maybe so. But he might also argue that why should he be held to a higher standard on Twitter than any random joe posting garbage to thier feed for friends to read?
- AdieuToLogic 5y ago> This is our industry now. No, this is human nature. There have always been liars, cheats, and a conman ready to take advantage of others. What gives hope is that this kind of deception can now be found out quicker and made known to all almost instantaneously. What gives dismay is that the same speed applies to disinformation as well.
- wolverine876 5y ago> No, this is human nature. There have always been liars, cheats, and a conman ready to take advantage of others. I think it's odd to try to normalize evil. There have always been been wars and starvation, so what? Do you mean that we have no power over our own society? That it's ok because it's happened before? Either seems bizarre to me - obviously false and why would someone want to normalize it? Also, the IT industry wasn't like this 10 years ago. > What gives hope is that this kind of deception can now be found out quicker and made known to all almost instantaneously. What gives dismay is that the same speed applies to disinformation as well. The latter smees to be far ahead of the former. As people who study disinformation point out: You can post a lie much faster than someone can post the truth.
- jimbob45 5y agoNo, those are just the most outspoken members of the tech community. You’re ignoring the CEOs of IBM, Garmin, Cisco, and a whole host of other tech company CEOs that keep quiet but get the job done. And who’s to say keeping quiet even correlates with high performance? Intel’s CEO seems to stay out of the news but is otherwise a denthead. NVidia’s CEO is well-spoken and still beats predictions every year. It seems like we’re judging books by their covers here.
- wolverine876 5y ago> No, those are just the most outspoken members of the tech community. You’re ignoring the CEOs of IBM, Garmin, Cisco, and a whole host of other tech company CEOs that keep quiet but get the job done. Good point about the many who are not insane. I mean that the prevelance of the fraud is very high. I was not at all talking about the financial performance of their companies.
- pjc50 5y agoBeing a megalomaniac with a cult of personality can help you get a lot done. It's practically a leadership technique of its own. Of course, it also enables you to override concerns for safety and side effects ... > post-truth, frauds, and mass manipulation Some of this is new and some of it isn't. The internet wrecked traditional news and helped replace it with clickbait propaganda, but papers have always been happy to participate in propaganda they liked (Daily Mail "hurrah for the blackshirts" passim). It does feel that since about 2010 it's really escalated and everyone is joining some sort of cult now.
- Hokusai 5y ago> can help you get a lot done That is survivor bias. I have worked with such people and they destroy companies and make employee life miserable. It is impossible to get anything done in the company that does not help the megalomaniac ego. And they usually sabotage efforts that benefit the company but not themselves. It looks cool in movies and from far away, up close it is a train wreck.
- mcv 5y agoIsn't that narcissism? That's all about ego. I thought megalomania was more about results.
- Hokusai 5y agoMy understanding fits with the dictionary definition. megalomania /ˌmɛɡ(ə)lə(ʊ)ˈmeɪnɪə/ noun: megalomania. obsession with the exercise of power. delusion about one's own power or importance (typically as a symptom of manic or paranoid disorder)
- wolverine876 5y ago> Isn't that narcissism? Excellent point in itself - I should have used that word, maybe in addition to megalomania, in the comment that started this subthread.
- mcv 5y ago
- 3pt14159 5y agoI think the rough difference is that the psychopaths understand the internet now. Don't get me wrong, there were always some techies with software skills that made fake pharmacies and such, but the giant pool of lower intelligence psychopaths are now able to grind out scamming people. As for me, I write software that keeps people's data safe and software that fights human traffickers and terrorists. I'm feeling good about what I do for a living. Our industry may broadly be far more scummy, but there are points of light still and I try my best to work for people that make the world better.
- timoth3y 5y ago> Compare how the first iPhone was marketed to cryptocurrencies and Musk's products. This does not get talked about enough, and it encapsulates much of what's gone wrong inn SV over the past 20 years. More precisely, it's how products are announced rather than how they are marketed. After developing it in secret and making the industry partnerships required to make it a success, Jobs came on stage with a prototype iPhone, ran it trough its paces, said "This will be on sale nationwide in six months." and he delivered. No one really doubted that Apple would deliver. Compare that to Elon Musk's announcement of the Tesla Robot. He announced the specs and literally had some guy in spandex dance around dressed up like a robot. (I'm not hating on Musk here, just using him to illustrate a larger trend) I think the media became so enthralled with Apple's big spectacle announcements that they (or perhaps all of us) forgot that the spectacle is supposed to be about something. Whether we are talking about EVs, tech, ICOs, or DAOs, we've somehow reached a point where the attention is received and the money is made by announcing rather than delivering. And if that's the case, why do all the hard work required to actually deliver?