16 ms·
Given Thomas Jefferson's aversion to the supernatural (https://www.amazon.com/Jefferson-Bible-Smithsonian-Morals-Nazareth/dp/158834312X/ref=sr_1_2?crid=1ACNX2PG
by bediger4000 5y ago
Given Thomas Jefferson's aversion to the supernatural (https://www.amazon.com/Jefferson-Bible-Smithsonian-Morals-Nazareth/dp/158834312X/ref=sr_1_2?crid=1ACNX2PGSGI4S&keywords=jefferson+bible&qid=1645498378&sprefix=jefferson+bible%2Caps%2C161&sr=8-2 https://www.amazon.com/Jefferson-Bible-Smithsonian-Morals-Na...), and our worship of The Founding Fathers, then yes, atheism should be protected.
Also, there's 2 clauses to that part of the US 1st Amendment: establishment clause and freedom of clause. Clearly atheism falls under the establishment clause.
- ggm 5y agoshould is such a delicious word to use in connection with the constitution, "black letter law", originalism, the current SCOTUS. now, thats a bit flame-batey, but the point I wanted to make is that what we think we want, what we think it "should" mean isn't always easy to deliver, given the range of conditions which apply. I certainly agree you would think Jefferson was trying to ensure it was. But you would also think he could have tried harder, with a sentence like ...or NOT believing... judiciously added. The same logic would permit donkey-sex. After all, its not explicitly forbidden and at least ONE of the drafters probably thought about it?
- bediger4000 5y agoDecent criticism, thanks. Given the old-timey wording of the US constitution, and how old-timey phrases like "well regulated" mean something, I think we have to go on extra-constitutional evidence. More practically, given that around 30% of the US population is un-churched, is it at all wise to have policies that only protect religious forms of expression? As a society, we'd leave out a third of the populous, more some places, and less others. And let's face it, this is leading up to forbidding criticism of religious organizations. Policies like that would have exceptionally harmful effects to society as a whole.
- ggm 5y agoObviously I believe it shouldn't. I think it is extremely unwise, extremely dispiriting that the 'under god' thing wasn't stamped out early. The pledge of allegiance is evil. wiring it to christianity just compounded the evil. (evil here, does not imply anything other than its colloquial 'wrong' meaning.) I do not think the current courts have a mind to deal with this, to the contrary I think they are on hair trigger to enshrine laws regarding christianity. My only hope is that they fall into some error like believing "faith" means christianity and die on the bonfire of the satanists and others approaching the desk for their mandated rights. I think all US courts should have a Zoroastrian fire ceremony...