3 ms·
In the UK in the 70s, "top stream" math students started studying the basics of calculus in what the US would call 8th grade. We did the foundations, and by the
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
In the UK in the 70s, "top stream" math students started studying the basics of calculus in what the US would call 8th grade. We did the foundations, and by the time I was in college occasionally using calculus, I didn't have to trust it blindly - we had studied it enough for me to understand how it works (to a point). The same was true of basic electricity, basic mechanics and lots more.
The US educational system seems to regard some of the foundational elements of STEM will enormous trepidation (I've known US high school students headed for STEM majors at quality universities who haven't studied calculus for more than a year (typically just covering differentiation, not integration)). Combined with it's greater breadth of educational goals, both in grade school and even for a bachelors, it's not really surprising that there will be students (in the US at least) who begin college level physics without fully understanding the tools (or history) of the subject.
- selimthegrim 5y agoI am trying to use an 80s sophomore level UK linear algebra text in a course for predominantly engineers and nonmajors. Imagine my surprise when I discovered some of the material is covered in US beginning graduate (in the math dept) algebra!
- foldr 5y agoI’m also British, for what it’s worth. Of course anyone can study the foundations of calculus. The question is whether it’s reasonable for someone to choose not to and trust that it works. I think it surely is reasonable for someone to do so, unless they have a particular need for a deep understanding of calculus. You always have to stop somewhere. Any given one of your assumptions may be verifiable in principle, but you won’t have the time and wherewithal to verify all of them. Science as it’s actually practiced is a huge pyramid of trust.