3 ms·
I mean, you can, but then you should probably tell Cindy Rahman, their SVP and Chief Marketing Officer, that her job title makes no sense. And the IRS that the
by shadowgovt 5y ago
I mean, you can, but then you should probably tell Cindy Rahman, their SVP and Chief Marketing Officer, that her job title makes no sense. And the IRS that the 4.9 million-odd they claimed they spent on advertising on their Federal 990 form in 2020 was mis-labeled.
The March of Dimes is and was in the marketing business.
> actually they have to reach back decades
March of Dimes is still here. It's a modern example as well as a decades-old one. Their primary purpose all but accomplished, they've re-targeted their efforts into information, support of families in NICU, and general patient advocacy.
I could have pulled a more recent example, but the polio campaign has the advantages of lack of ambiguity, common understanding, and the historical perspective to come to general agreement that it was an more-or-less un-alloyed good thing that we can avoid getting bogged down in those dimensions.
Nowadays, I'd point to the billions spent on COVID-19 vaccination advocacy and messaging as the good marketing can do, but I didn't really want to drag the modern-era anti-vaxxers out of the woodwork.
- jacquesm 5y agoBut: you are still stuck on the same theme: health related, charities and so on. The fact that charities have marketing is by itself a negative, often enough this translates into them spending a very large fraction of their donation on soliciting more donations. And there are quite a few examples of that being the larger part of the total collected, which shouldn't really happen. We did not start the discussion about the march of dimes or any such project, that's just a convenient fig leaf, what matters here is companies selling commercial products and services that people don't need while using armies of psychologists and a continuous barrage of media expressions to battle down the natural defenses to get people to act against their own interest. If you want to have a side discussion that there are some applications of those same techniques that may have positive effect then you're free to do so but preferably not with me.
- shadowgovt 5y agoLike I said, you don't hate marketing; you hate that most of what is marketed sucks. Take away the marketing and we have a world where most products still suck, and when we seek one out at random we'd be statistically likely to lay hands on something we don't need.
- jacquesm 5y ago'You don't hate guns, you just hate what they are used for' -> No, sorry, I really do hate guns and I have a very low opinion of everything related to marketing.