14 ms·
While I agree with a lot of the sentiment in this blog post, it certainly didn't age well. I don't see "developer love" making a lick of difference for how succ
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
While I agree with a lot of the sentiment in this blog post, it certainly didn't age well. I don't see "developer love" making a lick of difference for how successful the App Store has been (which is, phenomenally). At this point the only thing I see reigning in the power of the App Store (and Play Store, a point pg also got wrong in this post, but I think that was understandable in 2009) is regulation.
- Apocryphon 5y ago> I don't see "developer love" making a lick of difference for how successful the App Store has been Therein we see the commodificafion or the mass consumerization or appification or whatever neologism of software, at least for smartphones.
- webmobdev 5y ago> I don't see "developer love" making a lick of difference for how successful the App Store has been Business history is replete with those whose products were once at the top and / or dominated the industry and yet are now irrelevant.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThis blog post is 13 years old, and was written before App Store had its meteoric rise. A successful "cautionary tale of premature hubris" it ain't.
- btown 5y agoThere's an old diagram (now a meme) of the points where WWII bombers were hit and survived to have those hits recorded; the underlying theme is that it's the places where hits weren't recorded that were actually fatal. Looking at whether the App Store was sufficient in its "developer love," and looking at what applications were rejected... paints over what applications might have surfaced if its policies were different, but instead were discouraged before they even began. One of the worst things about the App Store is that there are very few "labors of love" there - very few (if any) quality free-to-play games that don't try to aggressively monetize in-app transactions, very few "shareware" style apps that rival paid subscription apps in quality. There's no real way to quantify what might have existed, but we do know that there were many shareware developers in the early 2000s that wouldn't touch microtransactions with a ten foot pole - where did they go? I think, in part, all this is due to the App Store process being so wildly unpredictable and exhausting. If you develop something useful, it may be rejected on a whim; the only developers who aren't discouraged after that, are the ones whose investors pay them to not be discouraged, may reach out via backchannels to ensure that rejections are escalated, can fund a pivot if necessary, and in turn expect outsized returns. And so every app becomes optimized for monetary return - which, of course, makes Apple extremely profitable. It's a really sad situation.
- collaborative 5y agoIndeed. Myself as an example. I give stuff away for free on the Play Store, but charge to breathe on the App Store. And the only reason I do it is to offset the mental drag it takes to bear with Apple. Else I would just leave
- kobalsky 5y agoI think apple is right now where amazon was before everyone started hating on bezos. amazon still reigns, but ppl got the see the pipes pumping biomass from the poor souls that have to deal with their ugly end. IMHO, this marked their high point, and the same will happen to apple.