3 ms·
If the infamous HN Dropbox comment didn't exist, this post would serve well as the canonical "facile dismissal". Reminded me of PG's essay about the "blub" pro
by coldtea 5y ago
If the infamous HN Dropbox comment didn't exist, this post would serve well as the canonical "facile dismissal".
Reminded me of PG's essay about the "blub" programming language.
But, in this case, I'd like to reverse the use of the concept: it's not that Java is a blub programming language, but that the OP has only reached a blub-state of understanding it and its potential, and produced a blub (generic and derivative) argument against it.
- the_af 5y agoI don't think Mark Dominus has a "blub level understanding". This is the author of the hilarious "monads are like burritos" and many others, and it's quite clear that he is very opinionated but also very knowledgeable about programming languages. Having programmed in Java for... what, 15+ years? I do agree with him about his assessment. Trying to solve an interview challenge in Java is to handicap yourself, unless it's the only language you know.
- coldtea 5y agoYeah, I'm not really talking about the OP per se, to be frank (didn't check who he was, and I don't know his story). So, my assessement wasn't about the OP in general, but the OP as revealed by this particular post. The post is based on the cliche early/mid-00s J2EE style of coding, that hasn't been in fashion for 15 years, and has been derided widely for at least 12. There are amazing apps and libs written in Java, and Java as a language was not a problem for their development and design (even when it was far more restricting and ceremonious). Lucene for one. Vert.x. Jetty. XOM, ...
- throwaway2037 5y agoIf people are unfamiliar with the "blub" programming language, you can read more here: https://wiki.c2.com/?BlubParadox https://wiki.c2.com/?BlubParadox Here is Paul Graham's original essay: http://www.paulgraham.com/avg.html http://www.paulgraham.com/avg.html To quote Wiki (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Graham_(programmer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Graham_(programmer)): << Graham considers a hypothetical Blub programmer. When the programmer looks down the "power continuum", they consider the lower languages to be less powerful because they miss some feature that a Blub programmer is used to. But when they look up, they fail to realise that they are looking up: they merely see "weird languages" with unnecessary features and assumes they are equivalent in power, but with "other hairy stuff thrown in as well". When Graham considers the point of view of a programmer using a language higher than Blub, he describes that programmer as looking down on Blub and noting its "missing" features from the point of view of the higher language. >> In my experience, it sounds like a very cool idea, until the first time you see someone programming DirectX using Excel/VBA. (Yes, it can be done.) My point: When you see someone using a "dumb" language (in your humble view), first ask if you are ignoring a Chesterson's Fence! For the avoidance of doubt, no, I am not seriously suggesting it is a good idea to program DirectX using Excel/VBA in 2022.
- chakkepolja 5y agoThe mistake is thinking that blub paradox is one dimensional.