5 ms·
... we need crypto Did someone say otherwise? Crypto is an attempt to fulfill a broad yearning for financial freedom. The problem is, as it currently exists
by jqpabc123 5y ago
... we need crypto
Did someone say otherwise?
Crypto is an attempt to fulfill a broad yearning for financial freedom. The problem is, as it currently exists --- it just doesn't deliver.
Crypto doesn't displace trust, it misplaces it.
Instead of trusting government and regulated banks, you end up trusting the unregulated gatekeepers to the block chain --- the exchanges.
Who is making sure these gatekeepers are not self serving scammers and con artists? Why no one really.
In other words, block chain automates the accounting but it does nothing to eliminate *trust* as a central aspect of the monetary system. So the question simply becomes, who are you going to trust?
If government suddenly ceased to exist, the first thing people would do is re-invent it. Because left to their own devices, people are not trustworthy.
- dylkil 5y ago>you end up trusting the unregulated gatekeepers to the block chain --- the exchanges. how exactly are exchanges gatekeepers? blockchains would function completely fine without exchanges. In fact, on chain exchanges like uniswap and 0x require zero trust whatsoever.
- jqpabc123 5y agoIn fact, on chain exchanges like uniswap and 0x require zero trust whatsoever. Who determines how much your crypto is worth? Does uniswap do this? No, not on their own. They can't --- their daily trading volume is too small. They are literally forced to follow the "marketplace". The 800lb gorillas that make up the crypto "marketplace" are the centralized exchanges --- Binance and others. They set the price using whatever method they choose. And they can easily influence the price by buying and selling themselves. Binance has access to unlimited funds to do so --- by simply minting more Tethers --- which they have done repeatedly --- and the price remains pegged at $1USD (wink, wink, nod, nod). With unlimited funds, effective control over the pricing mechanism and no regulation --- the centralized exchanges have all the ingredients for the ultimate form of insider trading fraud. If you trade crypto as it exists today, you are *trusting* the centralized exchanges who have overwhelming influence over the "marketplace". You have no other option.
- rosndo 5y agoExchanges decentralize trust, you don’t have to work with any specific exchange.
- jqpabc123 5y agoLOL! Sure, pick any exchange you want and I'll bet you a BTC that the price of USDT is effectively $1 USD. USDT remains pegged at $1 USD regardless of how many new Tethers are minted. Have you ever thought about why or how this happens? Once you do, your *trust* in the crypto exchanges/marketplace will start to unravel.
- rosndo 5y agoTether/Bitfinex has more than enough funds to back USDT, especially after the recent DOJ seizure. Would I hold funds in USDT myself? No, I learned my lesson after losing 50k with Liberty Reserve.
- jqpabc123 5y agoTether/Bitfinex has more than enough funds to back USDT And you know this how? Trust? Be honest. If the people running things used all the funds to buy a private island in the South Pacific, you wouldn't have any way to know.
- rosndo 5y agoI’m not sure what you are getting at. Who gives a shit about tether?
- jqpabc123 5y agoThis is the attitude that makes fraud so easy. This is like saying, who gives a shit if the NYSE is minting and selling stocks? Anyone with an IRA or a 401K should. Who gives a shit if Liberty Reserve was a money laundering operation? Maybe you should have. More than half of all crypto trades involve tether. The market prices of most crypto is being influenced by it whether you use it personally or not. If/when the price of Tether crumbles, most crypto will have no choice but to follow. https://www.forbes.com/sites/francescoppola/2019/03/14/tethers-u-s-dollar-peg-is-no-longer-credible/?sh=50d5b9aa451b https://www.forbes.com/sites/francescoppola/2019/03/14/tethe...
- jjtheblunt 5y ago> blockchains would function completely fine without exchanges. I must be misunderstanding, but don't blockchains track references, through sequences of indirection (i.e., encrypted on the chain), to what is ultimately fiat currency?
- arcticbull 5y ago> Did someone say otherwise? I will say otherwise. We do not need crypto.
- invalidname 5y ago+1. We "might" need what crypto was supposed to do (and even then arguably not). But we don't need what it is: a bloated worthless commodities ponzi scheme. Furthermore, its been shown governments can track all transactions. Without warrants (since it isn't money). Even for privacy focused funds. I doubt it would be hard for them to freeze account withdrawal and seriously hurt people trying to circumvent the law with crypto.
- jqpabc123 5y agoThe only reason crypto exists is because others needs don't match yours. The desire and *idea* behind crypto is reasonable. It's just that the implementation falls way short of the idea.
- arcticbull 5y agoThe whole idea behind a public ledger of transactions and balances when you're trying to push back against a totalitarian government is nonsense. If you're putting criminal or fringe transactions on the ledger, then handing the ledger to the government saying "I bet you can't figure this out!" You're not making transactions, you're making prosecution futures. If someone tried to use Bitcoin to evade the PRC I'd say they had a death wish. Remember, you're not leveraging crypto promises against current deanonymization software, you're using it against all future deanonymization software. That's such a bad idea I can't even. The only reason it's at all worked in Western democracies is because the anarchocapitalists are "pushing back" against a government that either tolerates or supports them. Worse, when they use the technology against Western democracies their actions are anti-Democratic. They're hoping the minority can overturn the lawful actions of the majority instead of using the courts or electoral processes. [edit] The folks who truly advocate crypto as a tool to push back against a totalitarian government are the kind of people who read 75% of 1984, closed the book, and assume Winston went home to have a sip of Victory Gin and lived happily ever after.
- koonsolo 5y ago> trusting the unregulated gatekeepers. Mine your own coins, and buy stuff with crypto. I don't see why you need to pass through gatekeepers. And when you can buy things with crypto, there is also another end that sells things for crypto. Ok, maybe it's a minority, but it serves the niche pretty well.
- jqpabc123 5y agoThe people who sell you stuff usually need guidance on pricing and they will usually want to quickly move the money to a more stable currency once the sale is made. For all this, they go to the gatekeepers. And likewise, you need to decide if the price you're about to pay is reasonable and fair. And for this, you go to the gatekeepers --- because there is no reasonable alternative. Crypto can't escape the influence of the exchanges in the same way fiat can't escape the influence of government.
- koonsolo 5y agoCrypto can work perfectly fine without a link to fiat. Funnily even stablecoins don't need fiat (see Terra's UST).
- jqpabc123 5y agoAnd yet, more than half of all crypto trades are linked directly to fiat by way of Tether, USDT. https://coingeek.com/terra-ust-is-now-the-biggest-decentralized-stablecoin-and-it-is-no-better-than-tether/ https://coingeek.com/terra-ust-is-now-the-biggest-decentrali...
- koonsolo 5y agoWhy are you still talking about trades? I just argued they are not relevant.