4 ms·
Lecture 6 starting at about 22:00 is the Chinese room argument. https://youtu.be/zLQjbACTaZM?t=1322 https://youtu.be/zLQjbACTaZM?t=1322 Systems reply starts at
by bondarchuk 5y ago
Lecture 6 starting at about 22:00 is the Chinese room argument. https://youtu.be/zLQjbACTaZM?t=1322 https://youtu.be/zLQjbACTaZM?t=1322 Systems reply starts at 34:00. To be honest, I haven't found the detailed treatment of the counterarguments that you promised in another comment. His counterargument to the systems reply is that he's flabbergasted, and "it's not gonna work if you think about it". Then, of course, he gives the "what if I memorize the rulebook and do it all in my head" spiel. If you're committed to the systems reply, the man and the stuff in his head etc. is still a system and the systems reply holds just as much as before. It's fun indeed to hear it from the man himself, but from his tone it's abundantly clear that he is just not willing, or perhaps able, to give it serious consideration.