3 ms·
Look at what outsourcing to China has done. Rich get richer, poor got poorer, then the economy tanked because consumers don't have money to spend on the product
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
Look at what outsourcing to China has done. Rich get richer, poor got poorer, then the economy tanked because consumers don't have money to spend on the products the rich make.
The poor in China have gotten considerably richer. India also.
http://www.un.org/esa/desa/papers/2010/wp92_2010.pdf http://www.un.org/esa/desa/papers/2010/wp92_2010.pdf
We've also gotten richer in the US, even while "the Chinese/Indians stole our jobs". The only reason we believe the US has stagnated is because immigration lowers our cross-sectional averages (but not our longitudinal averages).
http://crazybear.posterous.com/did-immigrants-and-simpsons-paradox-cause-the http://crazybear.posterous.com/did-immigrants-and-simpsons-p...
- lawtguy 15y agoThat study that CrazyBear linked to definitely shows that when you removed immigrants and retired people, income growth looks much better: median income grew by 29% instead of 9%. So the fact that we have more immigrants and and retirees live longer definitely has a negative impact on median income growth number without really impacting the average American. The bad news however is that most of the growth in family median income is not because wages are going up: it's because there are more two income families. I don't think it's bad that more women are working now and that they're making more money but I'm not sure it's really making us richer. What's missing from this study is any attempt to quantify the "free" labor that women were doing by being home for the kids and taking care of the house. If the extra money being brought in is simply going out to pay for childcare and a maid, we're really running in place, just faster.
- ChrisNorstrom 15y agoHmmm, well said. Now that I take the time to think about it. I'm wondering what our environment, highways, air, and rivers would look like if all those factories came to the US...
- intended 15y agoI've always thought of it as a global adjustment to the levels of poverty - maybe America is worse off, but humanity as a whole is better off.