8 ms·
Zynga's Profits Down by 95%
- dan_manges 15y agoSince their revenue was up, this doesn't mean much without knowing more about "higher than normal spend on hiring, acquisitions and international growth."
- robryan 15y agoYeah, if anything it says they are confident enough in their business to reinvest nearly all of their revenue and not just go for a quick win.
- scottkduncan 15y agoWell their daily active users were down despite hiring and acquisitions. Pre-IPO, I would say that a declining user-base is not a selling point for a social company.
- robryan 15y agoCould this just be a gap in between new games? Zynga games do seem to be sticky and addictive but there is going to be a lot of attrition the longer a game is around.
- scottkduncan 15y agoYes, I imagine that could definitely have something to do with it. I also think part of it is that others (Sims Social) have shown they can build sticky and addictive games as well and Zynga is no longer the sole owner of the space.
- whopa 15y agoMost of Zynga's games differ only very superficially though. It's weird that they can't launch games fast enough to stave off attrition.
- schraeds 15y agoLet's be clear, active users were down only 4%.
- jstanderfer 15y agoIf they were already public, this would likely cause a huge drop in the stock price. Similar to what happened to Netflix when they guided down on number of subscribers.
- Joakal 15y agoNetflix had bad publicity surrounding price increases. Did Zynga do anything to cause the user base to decline?
- jstanderfer 15y agoWhen you've sold yourself as a growth story, the reasons for the decline don't matter to Wall Street. Sell side analysts build complex earnings projections models based on estimated compounding growth rates. Even a slight reduction in the growth rate has a large impact on projected earnings a few years out and a negative growth rate blows up the entire model.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- SwellJoe 15y agoDid Zynga do anything to cause the user base to decline? You mean, other than being evil incarnate?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- analyst74 15y agojudging a gaming company by quarter?? ok, zynga is not exactly a traditional gaming company, but can you even imagine if we judged blizzard or bioware (when they were independant) by quaterly figures?
- Impossible 15y agoPublicly traded game companies are judged by quarterly figures... In the case of Blizzard and Bioware, Activision and EA stock are hugely affected by their revenues. Its not right, and it leads to games being shipped too early to attempt to improve quarterly revenues (I worked on a THQ project where this happened), but it happens all the time.
- palish 15y agoThere's no reason we should tolerate that. (I'm a gamedev, not a player.)
- ido 15y agoWhat can you do about it?
- jarek 15y agoNot go public. But good luck convincing C-suite of that.
- palish 15y agoNothing. The world is as it is. I've come to accept that. But -- here's the thing -- your moral/ethical compass shouldn't be influenced on account of the world. Think back through history, and at every point, people have been essentially crazy. So the only thing we can do is to have the confidence to know "what's good", and then strive to make our personal lives reflect that. (Without becoming judgmental of others. </irony>) If you're asking what I'm going to do about it, well... I'm just like everyone else. I train myself for years in every aspect of game development, am building an entire multiplayer game from start to finish without relying on anything except my creativity and capabilities, and will be done around age 39. :) Then I'll use the proceeds to form a company and hire a few likeminded people.
- nhangen 15y agoI'm not a fan of their games, but I do want them to do well....not sure why. Maybe it's because I feel that out of all the latest IPO's and IPO rumors, they have the closest to an actual business, or because I want a gaming company to do well since I make games. Either way, 95% is a lot, and this doesn't bode well at all for anyone lower in the food chain.
- truthout 15y agoTheir business model is people sitting on the computer nurturing virtual farms and buying cows. Are you serious? Their business targets the least productive segment of humanity and leeches off of their stupidity. The fast that they have negative q/q userbase growth and q/q profits is pretty serious. Their market is ripe for competition and their userbase will continue to be cannibalized.
- Zak 15y agoFrom what I've read, it's my impression that their games aren't actually fun and they get pretty much all their popularity through manipulative social incentives to play. I want that model to lose. More generally, I'm not thrilled by things that try to monetize my relationships with friends and family, which includes, to a degree Facebook itself.
- zemo 15y agoHave you played a Zynga game? In Zynga games, you cannot complete the core objectives without recruiting other people to play the game or by paying money. Zynga's products are pyramid schemes masquerading as games.
- nhangen 15y agoI don't doubt that, but they seem to make people happy judging from my FB feed. I think they found a way to make non-gamers feel good about gaming, which I'm for. Maybe Zynga can be a gateway drug?
- bluedanieru 15y ago
- taylorbuley 15y agoIf Facebook was banking on expectations that they'd see a 30% cut of Zynga's revenue this does not bode well for a Facebook IPO.
- sirclueless 15y agoSure it does, Zynga's revenue increased over the same period.
- taylorbuley 15y agoShort term, yeah. But Facebook needs its ecosystem to be healthy too. That said, you're correct -- I conflated "profits" and "revenue" and shouldn't have.
- EponymousCoward 15y agoWhich do you suppose is bigger, 30% of Zynga's FB credits, or 100% of their FB ad spend?
- diziet 15y ago30% of their FB credits AND 100% of their FB ad spend, why of course.
- teej 15y agoDisclaimer: I was previously a Zynga employee and I am presently a holder of Zynga stock. I have no knowledge of Zynga's current internal state - the following is entirely speculation. ================================= There are many forces at work here that need to be brought to light. * Macro Trend #1 - Facebook's web traffic is in decline[1]. These users are shifting to mobile as their primary consumption channel for Facebook. No facebook app developer has presence on the mobile app. * Macro Trend #2 - Zynga's game launches are smaller than ever. For many reasons, it's getting harder to launch a 5M+ DAU game. Zynga is responding to these trends in several ways. * Leverage their warchest[2] to make acquisitions. This lets them launch a higher volume of games and help them get a foothold in mobile. Zynga has made a LOT of acquisitions this year[3]. * Further monetize their existing base. They've been pushing partner deals really hard recently, doing deals with Lady Gaga[4], Amex[5], and Capital One[6] Zynga's games are more high quality than ever. Gone are the days of "fuck innovation", two of Zynga's most recent releases are the best they've ever built. The issue is that the market for FB games is in decline - the next big wave is mobile. If Zynga can become a player by launching a hit or acquiring a large chunk of the space, they'll be doing better than ever. But so far, Zynga's mobile releases have flopped. TL;DR - Zynga's profits are a sign that they have doubled down on acquisitions to counter-balance a market shift from web to mobile. Their future prospects lie in their ability to generate hits on the iPhone. ===== [1] - http://www.insidefacebook.com/2011/06/12/facebook-sees-big-traffic-drops-in-us-and-canada-as-it-nears-700-million-users-worldwide/ http://www.insidefacebook.com/2011/06/12/facebook-sees-big-t... [2] - http://www.insidemobileapps.com/2011/08/11/zynga-credit-1-billion-acquisitions/ http://www.insidemobileapps.com/2011/08/11/zynga-credit-1-bi... [3] - http://mashable.com/2011/05/18/zynga-dna-games/ http://mashable.com/2011/05/18/zynga-dna-games/ [4] - http://mashable.com/2011/05/10/zynga-gaga-gagaville/ http://mashable.com/2011/05/10/zynga-gaga-gagaville/ [5] - http://www.zynga.com/about/article.php?a=20101130 http://www.zynga.com/about/article.php?a=20101130 [6] - http://blog.games.com/2011/09/19/farmville-cityville-pioneer-trail-capital-one/ http://blog.games.com/2011/09/19/farmville-cityville-pioneer...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Impossible 15y ago
- EponymousCoward 15y agoGood. Suck it. This company is pure slime. I pity their acquirees. And it's totally worth my karma hit to just get this off my chest.
- suking 15y agoCan you expand on why you feel that way?
- RobPfeifer 15y agoProbably something similar to what's described here: http://bit.ly/qAb7nM http://bit.ly/qAb7nM Perhaps they've changed their tune, but early on Zynga had a questionable ethical reputation
- salemh 15y agoShortened URL = http://www.sfweekly.com/2010-09-08/news/farmvillains/ http://www.sfweekly.com/2010-09-08/news/farmvillains/ Try not to do so (HN rules and all that)
- zitterbewegung 15y agoI guess the real question is this indicative of a general trend or is this only a one time event? Does this bode well for people who want to write apps for Facebook?
- michaelochurch 15y agoThe electronic games field is currently flooded with a bunch of one-trick pranksters and bike-shedding assclowns and "gameification experts" who haven't designed a game and flat-out have no clue what they're talking about. I thought the domination of Corporate (post-3D) was the death of decency in electronic gaming, but this "social" dreck makes EArts at its worst look saintly. If Zynga can reinvent itself as a company that gives a shit about game quality, then I'll cheer for their success. What they represent now is something of which I can whole-heartedly say that I'm glad to see any signs that it's starting to die. In 1995, Chrono Trigger (a game built by a team of leading artists and designers, not based on "analytics" regarding how to sap the energy and attention of half-bored people) came out. It had a story, there was a sense of progress because the game kept evolving and the challenges got harder (imagine this!) and after 50 hours or so, the game was completed and you went the fuck outside and rode your bike or went swimming. You could New Game+ to beat Lavos at different points in the story and level up to 99 if you really cared, but that was pretty rare and even then, the game came to a close. Also, the game involved a lot more thought than the mindless click-here-click-there of these Games For Idiots like Shartville and Mafia Whores.
- malkia 15y agoAmen to that!
- estel 15y agoIs there a problem with having diversity in the market? Whilst I can always wish that every development studio were developing games to suit my needs and tastes; obviously it's far better that there are a range of studios producing a range of titles, a large number of which I won't like. I might not enjoy the games that Zynga produce, but it seems pretty clear that there are plenty of people out there that do enjoy them very much; and I'm not sure that more people "playing" generally is a bad thing. More people playing more games from more companies is only ever going to be a good thing for the industry.
- tatsuke95 15y agoRight on. I'm no fan of Zynga and their work (as a gamer), but they have many, many (many!) people who enjoy playing their games. That alone is reason enough that should exist. Zynga have been a massive factor in the evolution of video games, for better or worse.
- loevborg 15y agoIs it just me or is it meaningless that profits are down by a certain percentage? Suppose a company is just about breaking even. Last quarter it made $1,000,000 (of a revenue of $100M). This quarter it makes $1,000. Profits fell 99.9%. So what?
- jarek 15y agoIt no longer made as much money to be redistributed to shareholders or invested in future growth. To be sure, it depends on why the difference between expenses and revenue rose by $999k.
- c_raig 15y ago"Zynga has reported year on year profits that were down by approximately 95%" "Zynga's total revenues for the quarter were up by 15%, though this was slower growth than the previous quarter, which jumped up by 24%" Perhaps it's just a little too early to handle basic concepts, but if revenues are up, but profits are down, doesn't that just mean costs are significantly greater? Isn't THAT the big headline here?
- SJDave 15y agoZynga's having a hard time getting new players, according to this - http://blogs.reuters.com/mediafile/2011/09/27/zynga-herding-its-users-like-sheep-from-game-to-game-data/ http://blogs.reuters.com/mediafile/2011/09/27/zynga-herding-...
- joshuaelu 15y agoDoes anyone know what Zynga did Q3 2010? Doesn't really make sense to measure profitability in succeeding quarters as it does to look at the YoY, right?