5 ms·
DSL has a speed limit on the DSLAM side, but cable has to deal with a shared medium and for some god forsaken reason the DOCSIS people decided that ISPs should
by jeroenhd 5y ago
DSL has a speed limit on the DSLAM side, but cable has to deal with a shared medium and for some god forsaken reason the DOCSIS people decided that ISPs should trust the devices placed into people's homes to do rate limiting.
In the same vein it's also trivial to hack many IPTV boxes used by fiber/DSL providers to give you free shows and channels because they essentially filter out the options you can click on on the client side rather than do any server side validation. There was a somewhat prolific subforum on a Dutch tech forum that tried to get into customising ISP IPTV boxes (didn't even need to alter the firmware, just needed to mess around with some JSON in transit) but that got cease-and-desisted because the method people used to alter themes could just as easily unlock most paid content.
Sometimes it really does look like TV related ISPs are still living in the 90s when it comes to security boundaries.
- butlerm 5y agoWith a shared medium trusting customer premise equipment to do proper, compatible media access control is pretty much inevitable. A device could just as easily transmit noise all day long, ruining service for everyone on the same cable segment. The only way to make that impossible would require rewiring everything as a switched network, which would generally mean running a fiber to every home.
- jeroenhd 5y agoWhen it comes to submitting well-formed streams, I agree. With DOCSIS, though, there's frequency/time block negotiation going on that a central node needs to confirm. A modem getting 1000mbps down on a 100mbps subscription should not be possible by simply flashing the modem with different firmware. This problem has been solved for LTE and other wireless standards, there's no reason why DOCSIS should stick to this old design in their new iterations.
- sidewndr46 5y agoIt's cheap to implement. Why would anyone bother trying to secure it? It's just going to cost a bunch of money for very little gain. If someone gets free bandwidth or free TV shows, nothing is really lost in the process. It isn't like having your car stolen.