3 ms·
The Dignity of the Body: Why Medical Rights Are Fundamental Now More Than Ever
- woodruffw 5y agoThe title set off my crank meter, and sure enough: > The vaccine mandates are a terrible human rights abuse worse than the Holocaust. There it is!
- ReactiveJelly 5y agoYeah, oof. I'm more concerned about my medical right to not have germ droplets sneezed onto me in public.
- jtbayly 5y agoIf you think that’s a right, I don’t know what to say. Somewhere between there and biological warfare, there’s a pretty major line crossed. If you truly want to be free from other people’s germs you literally need to go to Mars alone or something. The world is full of germs. Sorry.
- WalterGR 5y agoMMR, DTaP, whatever else they’re doing now?
- jtbayly 5y agoThe author actually makes an argument for why that is his belief. And it is cogent and worth interacting with rather than just dismissing. In fact the whole first part is about how just dismissing people is problematic.
- woodruffw 5y agoThe author can write massive volumes intended to prove that he is a Serious Person Worth Listening To. But that does not in fact make him a Serious Person Worth Listening To. Not unlike wearing a Mickey Mouse hat to a Senate committee meeting, comparing a vaccine mandate to the Holocaust is a signal that the author is not capable of engaging seriously with the topic. People who behave that way do not get a free pass from me just because they also happen to have mastered basic prose.
- tehjoker 5y agoI just skimmed the concluding paragraph to see what this is about but this is patently false: "I recall a conversation with a family member some months ago, when Omicron was a big thing in the media. My family member, a retired boomer and avid consumer of CNN and Fox News and MSNBC was entirely unaware that exposure to covid itself was bound to confer natural immunity with equal or better protective effects than any vaccine." Yea, post-infection immunity can generate all kinds of results, some better than the vaccine and some worse. Up to a third do not generate usable antibodies post-infection. Most importantly, to gain this protection, you must survive infection which may win you a ticket to being disabled with Long COVID or a ferry ride across the river Styx. Of course, at this point it should be pointed out that the vaccine gives good results against hospitalization, but if you want ~70% protection from infection from Omicron for 10 weeks (declines after that, probably not to zero though), you need to be boosted.
- jtbayly 5y ago> Up to a third do not generate usable antibodies post-infection. Citation? I’ve never seen any study saying anything like this.
- tehjoker 5y agohttps://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/27/9/21-1042_article https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/27/9/21-1042_article "In summary, we show that patients with low SARS-CoV-2 viral loads in their respiratory tract are less likely to mount a systemic antibody response. Although we cannot formally exclude false-positive RT-PCR results in some participants, PCR contamination is highly unlikely as an explanation for our findings (Appendix). We also show that clinical illness does not guarantee seroconversion and that laboratories with highly sensitive RT-PCR assays are more likely to detect serologic nonresponders. These results provide an explanation for the puzzling variability of seroconversion in different cohorts." Also: https://www.nebraskamed.com/COVID/covid-19-studies-natural-immunity-versus-vaccination https://www.nebraskamed.com/COVID/covid-19-studies-natural-i...
- walterbell 5y agohttps://www.tabletmag.com/sections/science/articles/how-the-cdc-abandoned-science https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/science/articles/how-the-... > the CDC’s near-total dismissal of natural immunity. Many other countries consider recovery from prior infection as a vaccination equivalent or better, an assumption that makes both medical and intuitive sense, but the CDC has steadfastly maintained that everyone needs the same number of vaccinations whether they have recovered from a COVID infection or not. This view is countered by data showing that vaccinating people who have recovered from COVID results in more severe adverse events than vaccinating people who have not had COVID. > .. Months later, the CDC published a stronger, cohort study showing clearly that natural immunity was more robust than vaccine-induced immunity in preventing future COVID hospitalizations, and moreover, that people who survived infection were massively protected whether vaccinated or not. > This is a precarious situation, as it undermines trust in federal agencies and naturally leads to a trust vacuum, in which Americans feel forced to cast about in a confused search for alternative sources of information. Once that trust is broken, it’s not easily regained... Science itself is transcendent, and will outlast our current challenges no matter what we choose to believe. But the more it becomes subordinate to politics—the more it becomes a slogan rather than a method of discovery and understanding—the more impoverished we all become. The next decade will be critical as we face an increasingly existential question: Is science autonomous and sacred, or a branch of politics?
- tehjoker 5y agoPart of the reason they don't really consider natural immunity is because everyone and their uncle will just say "oh yea, I think I already had it". Validating that with a blood draw and neutralizing titre measurement is too expensive across the population vs a quick and nearly painless needle stick mass produced economically. A subset of kinds of people that refuse to get vaccinated are the kind of people that would just make up stories in their own head about how they already got it because they had the sniffles in January 2020 and that mild case means they're alpha. I know at least one person that is precisely this stereotype, and probably two, but the second one got vaccinated.
- walterbell 5y ago
- pensatoio 5y agoThe core argument of this article is one I agree with. If you give government the ability to do whatever they want, eventually power will change hands and act against you. It’s a cycle of progressively more wild pendulum swings. Good times create weak men. I fear what comes next.
- ReactiveJelly 5y agoBut it's not a cycle. Governments have been trending towards policies I like since long before I was born. And the people who want to hold back the progress I want, don't seem to respect precedent any more than I do. Why should I be faithful in this game theory when they seem to have already betrayed?
- cato_the_elder 5y ago> Governments have been trending towards policies I like since long before I was born. Assuming you aren't too young, were you in favour of going to war in Iraq and Afghanistan? The Patriot Act? Trump's travel ban? The the long arc of the moral universe doesn't always bend towards our understanding of justice.
- woodruffw 5y agoTo point out the exceedingly obvious: vaccine mandates are not carte blanche. They aren't even new, and the government did not have to pass any legislation to require vaccination in many domains because we already had a (century old!) body of law dedicated to vaccination.
- walterbell 5y agoExcept that the CDC changed the definition of "vaccine", hence the century-old body of law is describing a different set of nouns, outcomes and policy choices. The WHO also changed the definition of "pandemic" about a decade ago.
- woodruffw 5y ago