4 ms·
Their defence doesn't hold much water. But then, I can't imagine any excuse that would satisfy me. They say “The onus is on us is to take all the data and scru
by tripzilch 15y ago
Their defence doesn't hold much water. But then, I can't imagine any excuse that would satisfy me.
They say “The onus is on us is to take all the data and scrub it,” said Arturo Bejar, a Facebook director of engineering. “What really matters is what we say as a company and back it up.”, except their track record on that matter isn't exactly stellar.
We know they don't actually delete messages or things you delete on FB, they just mark them "deleted". With that attitude to "deleting" things, what does it even matter?
And I don't care if they promise the data is not used for targeting ads, that is just one of the many ways this type of data can be abused.
The argument they use it to prevent "spam and phishing attacks" also seems dubious to me. How does that work? And the cookie that's kept contains just your facebook ID, so wouldn't that be trivial for spammers and phishers to work around?
And the most important thing is, they might act all innocent about it now, that they did it with the best intentions and not to continue tracking people after they log out. Let's believe that and lets assume this behaviour doesn't involve any other privacy implications: Facebook is by now well known for their feature-creep, if we hadn't caught them red-handed now, what's to say they wouldn't be using this data in a few months from now?
Sorry but it's all bullshit. Facebook doesn't care one bit about their user's privacy, they've made that perfectly clear by now, and them pretending to do otherwise in this article is absolutely laughable.
- mikeryan 15y agoWe know they don't actually delete messages or things you delete on FB, they just mark them "deleted". With that attitude to "deleting" things, what does it even matter? I've never written a web app that actually deletes data. The argument they use it to prevent "spam and phishing attacks" also seems dubious to me. How does that work? And the cookie that's kept contains just your facebook ID, so wouldn't that be trivial for spammers and phishers to work around? Actually its an attempt to make life easier on users. When you log in from another machine they sometimes use enhanced measures to confirm your identity. By keeping the cookie they get more confirmation that you are you. I'm not justifying it. There's ways to prevent this that weren't taken. But I can see what they're trying to do.
- rhizome 15y agoI've never written a web app that actually deletes data. Sure, but that's just a business decision, right?
- jquery 15y agoIt's often a performance, scalability, and safety decision as well. The optimal way for a web app to truly delete data is during an asynchronous garbage collection process. It's a lot easier to just mark the object as deleted.
- rhizome 15y agoI don't think the poster was allowing for GC, either.
- pilif 15y agoThe big webapp I'm working on moved from deleting data to adding delete flags over the 7 years of its existence. There are two reasons for this, none of it involves tracking users. For one, a lot of the data is synchronized to offline applications. If you just delete the data on the server, it's gone and it becomes impossible to tell clients that they have to remove their copy. In this case, I could keep a second list of deleted items around and synch only that of course, but that would mean additional work and it wouldn't help for the other case: Many times, end users wanted us to restore some data for them that they accidentally deleted. Back in the days that meant restoring the backup, and merging the backup with the current live data. A risky, complicated and thus expensive process. Nowadays, I just set the delete flag to false and the problem is solved. On the other hand, the data we are dealing with isn't nearly as sensitive as Facebooks and it's never shared between users.
- fl3tch 15y agoWhat if you delete your account entirely? Do they delete your data then?
- bokonon 15y agoThis is what really matters to me. If they don't delete messages or posts while I still have an account, than who cares. But if I decide to close my account permently, which I did yesterday, then why should they keep all the data they have for me. It's no help for me, it's not convientent in any way. It seems like the only reason they would keep it would be for their own use.
- lbrandy 15y agoThere is another reason that is stated and restated, including elsewhere in this thread: it's not trivial to (actually) erase anything.
- CGamesPlay 15y agoFacebook does delete all data associated with an account after it is deleted. An account is deleted after you indicate that you want to delete it (via a form in your account settings), and 2 weeks passes without you trying to reactivate the account (by logging into it). And yes, I do mean the permanent, irreversible kind of deleting. (I work at Facebook.)
- rationalbeats 15y agoI honestly don't believe that. (How could you or Facebook prove that?) I deleted my account a few months ago. However I have no way of verifying if all that data is gone for good, overwritten with some new persons data to sell to marketers. But the reason I deleted my Facebook account is because I just don't trust Facebook.
- altrego99 15y agoOne way to 'prove' that would be if Facebook can support such claims in legal documents or terms and conditions. Well technically it's not really a proof, but I will accept it.