4 ms·
Consumption cannot scale to infinity. There's little harm in periodically taking account of the externalities of the things we value.
by paulryanrogers 5y ago
Consumption cannot scale to infinity. There's little harm in periodically taking account of the externalities of the things we value.
- cameronh90 5y agoPerhaps not infinity, but if we manage to exploit space then it'd be close enough.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoThat's a big 'if'. And IMO pointless to explore seriously until we can sustain ourselves on our native planet.
- cameronh90 5y agoI'm not talking about expansion into space (yet), but simply consuming resources from space. Energy, materials, etc. We definitely should explore that (and are).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- systemvoltage 5y ago
- kodah 5y ago> The current mindset in California is to cut down life style and eat bugs. I live in CA, the valley specifically. I get why you have this image in your head, but I'm telling you it's not true. There are loads of normal people out here, with a select few very loud voices on certain topics. The problems those loud voices cause societally is likely more than their worth. This is true across the political ecosystem from what I've seen. It's not worth judging large groups of people by the loud and thorny voices among them.
- worik 5y agoBugs. Yum!
- systemvoltage 5y agoI have friends telling me to not have kids. The entire woke narrative is about regressing life standards to that of a third-world nation, instead of aspiring to lift everyone up. I'll be voting accordingly this next election, and defect for the very first time from the party that I used to vote for.
- _ktx2 5y agoI was in a similar position as you. West coast liberalism is not great, I struggle to call it liberalism when I hear some people speak. That said, if you have liberal friends on the East coast chat with them. The culture there is loads better in my opinion.
- missedthecue 5y agoWe don't need to it to scale to infinity. It's a weird objection. It's like saying human lifespans can't grow to infinity so we should stop trying to be healthy. The truth is, humanity can continue to be more productive and efficient for millions more years. We can do more with less like we've been doing for centuries. For example, the US economy is bigger than ever, yet we emit less carbon than we did 10 years ago, both total and on a per capita basis.
- paulryanrogers 5y ago> We don't need to it to scale to infinity. It's a weird objection. Is it? The proposition was that folks should have a growth mindset about consumption. Yet we're already reaching the limits of long term sustainably. I'm not advocating to stop trying to do better. Rather that we shouldn't assume we can indefinitely. > The truth is, humanity can continue to be more productive and efficient for millions more years. We can do more with less like we've been doing for centuries. Have we really been doing more with less for so long? Or have we just learned to extract more and more nonrenewable resources more quickly than ever before? For example if your lifetime worth of waste had to remain in your own yard then how would it compare to those from past generations?
- sammalloy 5y ago> The truth is, humanity can continue to be more productive and efficient for millions more years It’s not truth. It’s a form of techno-libertarianism bordering on religion. I can’t find a single working scientist in any relevant field who believes this claim. Most scientists believe we are on our way out, along with the biosphere we’ve destroyed.
- missedthecue 5y agoI know I'm not going to change your mind because that would require changing your whole worldview, but I would push back on the notion that this is a "techno-libertarian religion". It certainly has experts that endorse the view. A whole field of them. In fact, it has its own term in the discipline of economics. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dematerialization_(economics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dematerialization_(economics)