4 ms·
I would normally think that this is the population that matters was meant as since this is the predominant number of users these are the people that matter in d
by bryanrasmussen 5y ago
I would normally think that this is the population that matters was meant as since this is the predominant number of users these are the people that matter in delivery of services, since if you can make a logical demarcation of your userbase then you can use that logic to determines who 'matters'.
Since they then showed that the statement was factually incorrect and the largest number of users was not in the developed world I would personally have found that an adequate take down of the report. Personally if I had written it I would feel like a fool and be depressed at my own stupidity. So, since I don't think that this is the population that matters was meant as anything other than 'our preponderance of the users are here and thus they matter more' and my belief that the takedown, touching on the intellectual vanity of the authors, would be more than adequate. I found the whole PC HotNets complaint story a bit overdone.
But obviously the author and his friends thought the this is the population that matters bit was meant as more derogatory than I took it as.
- zibzab 5y agoThe initial text could be a misunderstanding or just an unfortunate choice of words. But the reviewer doubled down and went political 8n his response, showing that this was not really the case. I would probably have let it rest at this point, but I am happy she did not. It sometimes takes a "naive idiot" (her words) to improve things.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agofrankly I had a hard time understanding the response, my feelings on it were: This guy is too arrogant and insecure to just admit he got it wrong Failing that this guy is too stupid to come up with a rationally understandable argument why his report is worthwhile anyway, or in place of too stupid which after all is rude, to poor in the skill of rhetoric to craft a response that does not make them sound like a raving loony. Although when you're arguing you own case the emotional connection makes other things more difficult, hence the saying that a lawyer who represents themselves in court has a fool for a client. So I guess I just sort of discount the response as in too weird to decipher. Probably shouldn't do that though.