4 ms·
> I guess "we" have decided that driving, and self-driving, is worth a number of deaths. I don't think anyone has decided anything of the sort. If I shoplift f
by heavyset_go 5y ago
> I guess "we" have decided that driving, and self-driving, is worth a number of deaths.
I don't think anyone has decided anything of the sort. If I shoplift from a store and I'm not stopped, that doesn't mean that "we" have decided that my theft is okay. It just means that I haven't got caught, or that the system isn't sufficient to hold me accountable, or that there isn't enough evidence to present a damning case against me just yet.
> but I'm inclined to say that advancement of humanity is a big enough reward that some risk is justified.
There's absolutely no evidence that Tesla's rushed and untested beta product is helping the "advancement of humanity" versus better designed and controlled research by organizations like Waymo.
The only evidence of FSD's "advancement" I see is the advancement of Tesla's profits. FSD serves as a vehicle for interest-free loans to Tesla directly from their customers.
- jyrkesh 5y ago> > I guess "we" have decided that driving, and self-driving, is worth a number of deaths. > If I shoplift from a store and I'm not stopped, that doesn't mean that "we" have decided that my theft is okay. Those aren't equivalent, though. Stores _have_ decided that _some_ theft is okay in the grand scheme of running a store. Conversely, I think most of us agree e.g. that the incident where a woman was killed by an Uber self-driving Volvo[1] was _not_ okay, and that multiple negligent factors were at play that contributed to her death. This doesn't mean that society thinks self-driving cars are _all_ not okay. Similarly, the royal/societal "we" _absolutely_ have decided that collective driving is worth some quantity of deaths. We seek to minimize them, but there are extremely few people seriously advocating for the abolition of cars today, and they've been around for over a hundred years at this point. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Elaine_Herzberg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Elaine_Herzberg