4 ms·
I have a fancy wine store near my place, and sometimes have friends over to sip from $50-80 bottles. They are always met with universal praise for being "worth
by paxys 5y ago
I have a fancy wine store near my place, and sometimes have friends over to sip from $50-80 bottles. They are always met with universal praise for being "worth the price".
One time one of my friends instead opened a $7.99 bottle I had picked up from the grocery store without knowing it, and the group reaction was exactly the same.
I had always believed all of the studies like the ones the author mentions, but this experience firmly solidified my view that the wine business is 90% marketing, 10% everything else.
- enkid 5y agoI'm pretty sure this is true for the vast majority of consumer products.
- mikkergp 5y agoI don't know, have you ever used cheap industrial toilet paper?
- kleiba 5y agoAnd for art.
- NordSteve 5y agoWhile often true, not even sure I agree it's true for a majority. For example: Dishwasher detergent Laundry detergent Toilet paper Paper towels Pens Many packaged foods
- 0_____0 5y agoI buy the cheapest granular dishwasher detergent they sell at the drugstore. There's an upsell on the packaging for the same company's detergent pods. If they wanted me to buy a fancier detergent they shouldn't have made the cheap kind work so well, my dishes are spotless already!
- karmakaze 5y agoI know very little about wine, and only have some general and vague preferences. Knowledge is important. I learned that by asking for and going with a recommendation to go with the meal I ordered. It cost more that I would normally pay since I don't feel like I know enough to choose well. That meal was mind-blowing. It was like the difference between watching a video on your phone and being in a theatre with full visual and auditory immersion. Same flavours but on an entirely different level. Judging wines in isolation is merely a game of 'can you discern what I can discern' and nothing more--could play the same game with sounds or colour bands.
- raverbashing 5y agoI agree I really didn't know the power of a great pairing until I actually had a dinner with that. And I don't mean "red wines go with meat" type of pairing, but a pairing to the specific dish. It was amazing. A bit pricy but amazing.
- flatline 5y ago$15 bottles are more reliable in my experience. You can get a great bottle of $7 wine or a terrible one. Double the price and it won’t be vinegar or total crap. Anything beyond that is highly subjective.
- vba616 5y agoI assume that when a red wine has a bitter taste that makes me think of oak barrels, that's what wine critics call "tannic". I don't like it, even if (especially if) the bottle was more expensive. And I assume other people do like it, since it isn't particular to the cheapest wine. However, reasonably priced wine frequently, but not always, has an overtone to me that is sort of flowery/perfumey/chemical that I also hate. I've been wondering for a long time if there is a standard adjective (or cause) for that. I imagine it could be like cilantro, that only some people can taste. It's very obvious to me if it is or isn't there. I've never had anything that was recently bottled that tasted like vinegar. I've only heard "vinegar" as a cliche about what can happen to wine stored for many years. 99% of adjectives used for wine in print seem to be totally random. The red wine I really like, in the $10 range, is more defined for me by the absence of bad flavor or sweetness.
- ahefner 5y agoNot sure about that. $15 per bottle gives a winemaker enough rope to hang themselves manipulating the flavor in an attempt to appeal to some idea of mainstream tastes and ending up with the wine equivalent of botched plastic surgery. I'd probably rather drink a slightly spoiled, vinegar-tinged $7 bottle made from poor quality grapes than some of these sweetened, flavored, excessively oaked atrocities which lately have come to make me regard the whole grocery store wine aisle as a minefield best avoided.
- eps 5y agoIt helps to try $5, $50 and $150 wines (reds) side by side. This makes the difference absolutely clear. When tried on their own, the perception will depend (to a surprisingly large degree) on what you eaten before, how you feel, what you were expecting the wine to taste like, etc.
- aYsY4dDQ2NrcNzA 5y agoI found this true with scotch as well.
- guenthert 5y ago> [..] hey are always met with universal praise for being "worth the price". > [..] and the group reaction was exactly the same. A $7.99 bottle better be worth the price.
- vba616 5y agoA friend better be polite if they want to be invited back for more wine.
- vba616 5y ago>this experience firmly solidified my view that the wine business is 90% marketing, 10% everything else I'm not sure if you're supporting the idea that all wines are the same, or just that tastes differ and price doesn't correlate to something that tastes good. Do your friends ever react to any wine by saying "this is awful, it tastes like..."?