10 ms·
The quest to create quality chocolate for a country obsessed with Cadbury (2017)
- hulitu 5y agoQuality chocolate is gone for good. As long as the main ingredients are sugar and hidrogenated oil the future looks bad. Also the monopolies like Lindt or Mondelez prevent others from accesing the market.
- detaro 5y agoI can find chocolate not by those "monopolies" very easily?
- scandox 5y agoAll I know is that in the years since Mondelez bought Cadbury the quality of their chocolate has gone down the tubes. Despite public pronouncements that they haven't altered their recipes.
- dijit 5y agoDefinitely true. I moved to Sweden before Cadbury’s was sold, I wasn’t aware that Cadburys had been sold when I came back to the UK for a visit. I genuinely thought that the chocolate had been “re-melted”. You know that waxy taste when chocolate has been out in the sun too much and hardened again and that’s happened a few times? So, I chalked it up to a bad batch or that the store had stored it incorrectly. To my horror the same was true of the chocolate in the airport when I was going home. So; it’s not a placebo; I didn’t know, I only know because I complained to my Mum and she explained what happened later.
- sorenjan 5y agoI've never had Cadbury's, but Marabou, the largest chocolate brand in Sweden, is also owned by Mondelez. How do they compare?
- dijit 5y agoI was never a fan of Marabou, there was something artificial about the taste and I never bought it again: not sure how they compare directly.. Will check though, I'm visiting Scotland next weekend. :)
- andi999 5y agoMarabou has a very distinct flavour (which i am addicted to) which is not a chocolate taste. Cadbury just tastes like bad chocolate.
- lapsis_beeftech 5y agoMarabou chocolate is of mediocre quality at best. Chocolate from the other large Swedish confectionery manufacturer, Cloetta, is even worse and on par with Cadbury. I usually buy imported Dutch or Swiss chocolate.
- michael1999 5y agoMarabou was tasty mass market, and they also declined after the purchase. My wife used to bring some Walter’s Mandler back, and gave up after the change.
- originalvichy 5y agoIn Finland we get Marabou in our stores, but our local competitor Fazer (still privately owned) is miles ahead. Marabou got a little edge when it came to market with combos with other chocolates like Daim. It didn’t take a long time until Fazer made flavour combos from their own lineup, and they took back the throne. If you have a chance to try Fazer chocolate then try it (sometimes stylized as Karl Fazer).
- sorenjan 5y agoFazer is widely available in Sweden as well, and I agree it's really good. Another Finnish favorite is Tupla.
- the-dude 5y agoChocolate tempering : https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/guide-to-chocolate-tempering https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/guide-to-chocolate-temperin...
- ksec 5y agoYes. Went to work in Cadbury Birmingham when I was a student something like 30 years ago. With perks like unlimited Cadbury Chocolate. I remember thinking I was in heaven. I am not sure which came first, moving their factory out to continental Europe or sold to Kraft. But the quality definitely dropped. May be "quality" isn't the right word from a QA perspective. But they definitely tasted different. And it wasn't a one off thing either. It changed a few times over the years. Probably before Kraft, after Kraft and then Mondelez. There were even some Cadbury from Poland that I think was owned by Lotte from South Korea. Or something like that. And it taste very different. It is similar story with Heinz Ketchup and bake beans. They keep saying they are the same.
- jleahy 5y agoThe sale to Kraft came first, I distinctly remember because they promised the British government they wouldn’t move production out of the UK then did shortly after the acquisition closed.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoI don't know, I've had some very ketchupy baked beans, they may indeed be the same.
- GordonS 5y agoI'm certain the cocoa solids quantity has been reduced - some of their products barely even taste like chocolate any more! Indeed, I saw one of their "Buttons" products recently, which didn't even say "chocolate" on the front - I presume because the cocoa content was so low they wouldn't be allowed to claim that.
- fmajid 5y agoYes, but their quality was also pretty low to begin with. Cadbury is the reason why the EU, unlike the US, allows chocolate to be adulterated with up to 5% margarine. If the Germans, Italians or French had their way, only pure cocoa butter could be used, and by that standard Cadbury could not be legally be sold in the EU as "chocolate", so the British put their veto. Now that Brexit has happened, I keep hoping the EU will reverse that travesty but I guess industrial chocolate makers have gotten used to the profits from selling mockolate for the price of chocolate and are resisting going back to proper standards.
- evgen 5y agoHaving moved to the UK from the US I have watched the Cadbury saga with amusement. As a well-travelled food snob I have known for decades that US chocolate (e.g. Hershey et al) is absolute shit. What I find hilarious is that people in the UK are quick to, rightly, point this out but then turn around and try to tell me that Cadbury is somehow 'good' chocolate. Now I get to see them moan that it has taken some dramatic turn for the worse after the takeover when at most it is a slight step down from an already low bar. Few Americans have access to good European chocolate so I can excuse their ignorance, but you can walk into a corner Tesco and get a bar of mid-grade German or Swiss for not much more than what is being paid for the mediocre Cadbury product...
- captainbland 5y ago"dramatic turn for the worse" That's supposed to be the butryic acid content. I don't know if Americans are just so used to it that they don't really notice but Hershey's smells just a little bit like vomit which is, I'd say, "a dramatic turn for the worse" for sure.
- petepete 5y agoHere's Charlie Brooker's review of Hershey's from the days before Black Mirror. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2010/jan/25/cadbury-dairy-milk-kraft-takeover https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2010/jan/25/cadbur...
- yccs27 5y agoBoth can be true: They might just use ingredients of much lower quality now. You can definitely taste the quality of cocoa and fat - some high-quality brands have chocolates with single-origin cocoa, which can taste wildly different even though the recipe is the same.
- slyall 5y agoIn New Zealand 20 years ago they were a generally loved brand with the majority of the market. Since the Mondelez sale they closed the local factory and started making everything in Australia. Besides the general drop in quality (palm oil etc) they got rid of popular products or changed their recipes. They still have a reduced but big share but other brands get all the respect.
- zizee 5y agoI find Whittakers (from NZ) to be a great alternative. Ever since Australian Cadbury's changed their recipe, it seems to give me a "burning" sensation. Whittakers tastes like a decent supermarket chocolate used to taste like.
- Doctor_Fegg 5y agoWhittakers is great. Tony's Chocolonely seems to be taking on a similar market position in Western Europe.
- Zenst 5y agoI remember the whole egg-gate with talk they shrunk the creme eggs and only admitted after a picture of comparison to an older one surfaced -https://www.chocablog.com/news/cadbury-admits-creme-egg-shrinkage/ https://www.chocablog.com/news/cadbury-admits-creme-egg-shri... So there is a history of changing things and not saying. That all said, I find coca cola tastes different depending upon location of production. Personally I found the south African cola tastes better, then Canadian and was able to blind taste them. So hardly not all brands are that verbatim across production lines globally and if a production line is moved, so does it's sourced ingredients more so as well as quality of aforementioned ingredients. Equally, local regulation may also play into those small changes. But then wine from different years, from the same production run/winery will taste different and that is probably the best example of how ingredient changes, however small, play a big factor in the end product.
- VBprogrammer 5y agoMy dad used to bring a pack of American Coca-Cola back any time he went. It's not even close to the British equivalent. I believe it's due to the good old high fructose corn syrup.
- humanrebar 5y agoThat's funny. American Coke snobs drink Mexican Coke from glass bottles, the usual explanation being corn syrup is worse than white sugar. Similarly, Texans bus "Dublin Dr. Pepper" bottled in Dublin, TX for the same reason.
- Zenst 5y agoI will agree the glass bottle versions taste better, from my observations/experience, it seems to be down to how the co2 reacts in the container and I find the plastic bottle the co2 is somewhat smaller and light in the taste, the cans - somewhat better and medium and yet the glass bottle. Ah yes the glass bottles just seem to have large bubble into the mix and in the taste, that just is a factor that stands out. Though an easy one to test for yourself, get cola form same area - plastic bottle, can and glass bottle and blind taste for yourself and see if you can notice the difference. It is one I could do, though not done for a while and yet was so standout. I will add that the diet version of the drinks do somewhat not lend themselves to such taste differences and talking fall fat sugar variations of cola here. I will concur from my observations, the sugar as well as the water used for production, do seem to be the dicerning factors in varaition.
- virtualritz 5y agoI remember being surprised that my Australian friends thought Cadbury was "great chocolate" in 2006 (before the Mondelez acquisition in 2010). That was the first time I got to sample it myself. It never was as far as my base of comparison is concerned. Maybe it got worse after the acquisition but by the chocolate standards set by the circumstances of my birthplace (Germany) and it's surroundings I was exposed to fantastic chocolate from an early age. My grandma only gave us Swiss chocolate for bdays/xmas. It's simply what you know. Cadbury (or Mondelez) can't be blamed for offering a cheap product that somehow satisfies consumer expectations in their target markets.
- dijit 5y agoCadbury is/was great chocolate by American/Aus standards. If you want something comparable to Swiss chocolate by the brits then it's going to be Thorntons.
- geden 5y agoHard disagree. Thorntons has always been quite low end chocolate. Waitrose No1 range is the only decent ostensibly British chocolate that immediately springs to mind https://www.waitrose.com/ecom/shop/browse/groceries/waitrose_brands/no1_waitrose_and_partners/biscuits_and_chocolate/chocolate https://www.waitrose.com/ecom/shop/browse/groceries/waitrose...
- DonaldFisk 5y agoJust checked here: https://www.waitrose.com/ecom/shop/browse/groceries/waitrose_brands/no1_waitrose_and_partners/biscuits_and_chocolate/chocolate https://www.waitrose.com/ecom/shop/browse/groceries/waitrose... and it's from Italy.
- forinti 5y agoI recently bought US made Hershey's and it was awful. It was way too sweet and had an aftertaste reminiscent of vomit. Locally made (Brazil) Hershey's is a lot better.
- 5y ago
- tigerlily 5y agoI’m right into artisanal dark chocolate. Started on 75%, now 86%. I go for anything fair trade, and no palm oil. My wife and I enjoy tiny slivers of an evening now and then. Cadburys tastes like slavery and dead orang-utans now.
- TuLithu 5y agoDie-hard Hershey's fan here. Maybe I'm a pleb, but I am not a fan of "artisanal" anything (these guys put the "anal" in "artisanal"). I only eat maybe one bar a week. I probably get ten times the amount of palm oil in my wife's cooking (she's a Filipina), and at 51, I can still run two miles better than most 30-year-olds. But hey, if you want to blow $5 or $10 on a chocolate bar, be my guest. I save my $s for books.
- bArray 5y ago> For All Things, the big challenge is handling temperamental chocolate in India’s hot and humid climate. Besides the risk of the chocolate melting on delivery, moisture can also compromise its quality, meaning that the company has to maintain just the right temperature in its kitchen. But on particularly humid days, especially during the monsoon season, production simply has to stop. One thing I have noticed is that Cadbury in the UK is different from Cadbury in other Countries. I suspect they alter their recipes for the target climate - Cadbury in the UK melts if you look at it the wrong way, whereas Cadbury in Australia/NZ tends to do better in heat. Also they tend to have factories closer to their target destinations and they seem to have some trouble exactly replicating the conditions - perhaps background temperature, altitude, humidity, etc, also play a role. Cadbury (UK version) is perfectly serviceable: it's sweet, milky/creamy, melts in the mouth and is relatively smooth. Some other chocolates may be better, but Cadbury is hardly bad at the price point. Contrast that to some cheap Lidl chocolate for example and it tastes rough and unblended, like all the components are there but they never came together.
- samwillis 5y ago> One thing I have noticed is that Cadbury in the UK is different from Cadbury in other Countries. Irish Dairy Milk is the best! My wife’s family is Irish and I spend a lot of time there. Their Dairy Milk is much creamier, much like their milk. I think their blue top “full” milk is much closer to the old “gold top” we used to have here in the UK. My in-laws will send over “care packages” of all my wife’s favourite things, Dairy Milk, Tayto Crisps, Red Lemonade and many other little treats. If you don’t have the opportunity to visit Ireland (you should, it’s beautiful and the people are the best) you can buy Irish Dairy Milk online for delivery on sites catering for Irish expats so you can sample it.
- belter 5y agoNoticed this also! Always assumed had bad luck with a batch or it was just sitting at the airport shop for too long. So my taste did not fool me! Thanks for the explanation. Must now find a way to order cross country without melting...
- 5y ago
- noisy_boy 5y agoObsessed is hardly how I would described India's relationship with Cadbury; it is more like Indians didn't know any better because there were hardly any better/decent alternatives with equal or better marketing prowess during the formative years of the Indian consumer with decent spending power (say, between mid 70's to mid/late 90's, loosely speaking). It is akin to their relationship with coffee with respect to Nescafe which was the absolute dominating brand (lesser brands like Bru were present but they didn't make much of a dent and frankly, weren't that much different/better either). Someone for whom the only exposure to coffee has been Nescafe would spit gourmet coffee out on the grounds that its taste is so different ("soooo bitter...") to what he/she considers "good" coffee (i.e. Nescafe). Of course that is no longer the case for younger folks who are regulars to cafes serving gourmet coffee.
- Wildgoose 5y agoIndian desserts are typically sweet and milky - so it’s not surprising that a sweet milky chocolate would be a local favourite.
- pgufjggjh 5y agoCadbury has brand recognition and prestige. It's the same in Ireland (another former British colony): some people still consider Cadbury to be some kind of premium product, a name to be conjured with. I guess it was premium in the 1950s, and it certainly gets heavily advertised. The point of the article is that it is challenging to get such people (nostalgic, traditional, and unimaginative) to consider genuinely gourmet chocolate. I don't think it has anything to do with differences between Cadbury's taste and that of the new products.
- NoboruWataya 5y agoIn the early days of the EU, there were lawsuits over whether the British should even be able to market their chocolate as chocolate, given its higher milk and oil content and lower cocoa content. I don't say that to disparage British chocolate; having grown up in Ireland, I don't have any issue with Cadbury. But it drives home the point that British and European chocolates are rather different products. Sometimes I want a Cadbury; sometimes I want a Lindt. If I have a craving for one, the other won't do. American chocolate like Hershey is different again; I think it tastes awful and am tempted to say it is objectively worse, but it's probably again more accurate to say it is a different (though superficially similar) product targeting a different audience.
- IgorPartola 5y agoHershey I think is meant to be melted. Eating it solid it tastes like chocolate with sawdust mixed in. There is good chocolate here but Hershey isn’t it.
- humanrebar 5y agoThere's something very European about precise regulations and intense lobbying regarding what counts as chocolate. I don't care that much as long as the ingredients in the package are accurate. Especially if the competition is allowed to point out what makes their chocolate superior.
- originalvichy 5y agoIt sounds silly but then I read and watch stories of americans crying out for their old ice cream brands which went from milk based to something completely different based. All done in secret.
- humanrebar 5y agoI mean, the ingredients are on the carton. And there are plenty of good ice cream brands, especially at specialty shops.
- jrochkind1 5y agoCadbury is already so much better than mass market chocolate in the USA. I am born here and grew up with it and I still don't understand how anyone can eat USA mass market chocolate.
- klelatti 5y agoFor those outside the U.K. some background on Cadbury’s might be of interest. It might be surprising that many brits get a warm glow when thinking of Cadbury’s chocolate - partly because 1) it’s pretty ubiquitous so kids grow up getting used to it 2) great marketing and 3) Cadbury’s always had a reputation as a very good employer. I can’t comment on the quality but the Mondelez / Kraft takeover has certainly dented 3) and I’m reasonably sure the brand has suffered as a result.
- exodust 5y agoBetter milk chocolate than Cadbury: Green & Blacks, 37% cocoa. If you haven't tried, you should. It's in the supermarket but not everywhere. https://www.greenandblacks.com.au/milk-chocolate https://www.greenandblacks.com.au/milk-chocolate Bought by Cadbury years ago but they didn't mess with the recipe. There's no harsh aftertaste, smooth and balanced!
- humanrebar 5y agoSlightly off topic since this article is about Cadbury, but this keeps coming up in this discussion. American has plenty of good chocolate! Here's an article listing a whole slew of craft chocolatiers: https://www.foodandwine.com/lifestyle/best-chocolate-shops-america https://www.foodandwine.com/lifestyle/best-chocolate-shops-a... Other than that, it's exceedingly easy to find Ghirardelli chocolate in particular in grocery stores, Wal-Mart, Target, Walgreens, etc. Many more options are available at high end and specialty stores like organic grocery stores. And, of course, there's always online ordering for the especially dedicated. Besides all that, there are innumerable chocolate alternative craft candymakers catering to crowds that want alternative sweeteners, fats, etc. They're not really for me, but business seems to be going well for them.
- CursedUrn 5y agoRecommending craft chocolate is kind of missing the point. You can buy expensive specialist chocolate anywhere, but that's not the same sector of the market that Cadbury occupies. You should be comparing it to stuff like Hershey's.
- humanrebar 5y agoGhirardelli is easily available so it's not that "craft". And, yeah, it costs maybe twice Hershey's, but if someone is that hard up for a few bucks, chocolate itself probably needs to be less of the budget. Mostly I'm pushing back on the meme that Americans don't produce or appreciate good chocolate. They do, though bigco chocolate certainly has better market share, product placement, mind share, etc.