3 ms·
I expect that it is because in general, more useful functions and operations are closed in the complex plane. Things that may superficially appear complicated t
by jerf 5y ago
I expect that it is because in general, more useful functions and operations are closed in the complex plane. Things that may superficially appear complicated to a human being learning math, like analytic extension [1], from a theoretical perspective means that when you need the tool, it is there, and continues to expand the sets of problems you can address.
As you add restrictions to the set of numbers you want to use, you are importing those restrictions into every proof you want to do on those numbers. For instance, consider the question, "Does this polynomial of some high degree have roots, and if so, how many?"
The Fundamental Theorem of Algebra proves that the answer is yes, and the number of roots is the same as the degree (although some may be roots multiple times). See [2].
Now, as you watch 2, consider what happens to the proof if you confine it even to the reals, let alone the integers. While the complex plane is "more complex" from a human perspective, the proof of the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra using the complex plane is not that complicated. Consider trying to make equivalent statements about polynomials with only real roots, and not using the complex plane in the proofs. In cases where it is feasible, your proofs will inevitably be carrying around a lot more caveats about what polynomials it applies to, and there may be things that the caveats simply render infeasible. As you step down the number hierarchy, the caveats get worse and worse. There's more and more "holes" that every proof about those simpler numbers has to step around.
The same simplicity that makes it easier to start your education with just integers becomes a crippling limitation when trying to work with them, which is also in some sense the exact same reason why we have to step you up the number hierarchy even in non-specialist education. Math limited to just integers is so confining and difficult to work with that it isn't even enough for day-to-day life. The simplicity is a double-edged sword.
[1]: 3Blue1Brown on the topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sD0NjbwqlYw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sD0NjbwqlYw
[2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=shEk8sz1oOw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=shEk8sz1oOw