3 ms·
Bitcoin does not "move" energy. You could exchange a Bitcoin produced with some quantity of energy in one location for another quantity of energy in a different
by woodruffw 5y ago
Bitcoin does not "move" energy. You could exchange a Bitcoin produced with some quantity of energy in one location for another quantity of energy in a different location, but the energy has not moved with the token. Instead, you're just burning those quantities of energy twice.
I've used the oil barrel analogy before: an empty oil barrel is a proof that someone has used the oil within it, much like a Bitcoin is proof of a certain amount of work. But I can't show up to another power plant with that empty oil barrel and expect them to manifest power from it: they have to burn another barrel of oil to produce the energy equivalent. This is of course also ridiculous, since nobody would accept payment for energy in the form of a proof of previous energy wasted. And yet, that's fundamentally what Bitcoin is, except laundered through a tokenization layer to obscure that fact.
To tie it together: Bitcoin can only ever double the token-equivalent demand (not necessarily volume) for energy, never reduce it. Using Bitcoin for energy exchange is always roughly half as efficient as fiat.
- throwaway73838 5y agoI’ll try and explain it better. Money is analogous to work. You can’t just conjure up money (that would be illegal). If I have 50 dollars, I can pay someone to mow my grass. I have just converted potential energy (money) into work. In the same way, if I have a geothermal power plant in a remote Scandinavian wilderness, I can use that power to generate Bitcoin, and use that store of value to transfer to me which I can then convert into work by employing people, either directly as a service, or indirectly through a good. I hope that makes more sense now. To use your oil example - it would be like me mining a barrel of oil in location A, then converting it entirely into Bitcoin, sending the coin to me via the internet, then using the Bitcoin to buy another barrel of oil close to my home. I now have a barrel of oil I did not previously have, because I’ve transferred value (energy) from remote place A to local place B virtually.
- johnsonlambo 5y agoThis can be done with current dollars on a screen, the thousands of different cryptos out in the ether, gold, etc. Some take less energy and some take more. Then they can be converted for work, a service, goods etc. This is not new or solely a characteristic of btc.
- woodruffw 5y ago> Money is analogous to work. You can’t just conjure up money (that would be illegal). This is wrong, but it's wrong in ways that are entirely irrelevant. > If I have 50 dollars, I can pay someone to mow my grass. I have just converted potential energy (money) into work. No, you haven't. You've applied a medium of exchange to a business transaction. You haven't "converted" any amount of energy. Converting energy means something specific, with real physical implications. Bitcoin doesn't violate the conservation of energy. > To use your oil example - it would be like me mining a barrel of oil in location A, then converting it entirely into Bitcoin, sending the coin to me via the internet, then using the Bitcoin to buy another barrel of oil close to my home. I now have a barrel of oil I did not previously have, because I’ve transferred value (energy) from remote place A to local place B virtually. This is just wrong: you can't "mine a barrel of oil" with Bitcoin. You can only burn the resource to prove the energy intrinsic in having possessed it. Once you've burned it, you can't exchange the token you've vouched with it for the same energy: you can only exchange it for more potential energy to burn. More energy is always used (and strictly wasted) than just burning a single barrel to begin with.
- throwaway73838 5y agoActually, you’re wrong. Laughably so. Your assertion a the end there about more energy always being used than you get back - if that were true, mining btc wouldn’t be profitable - the whole point is you make more BTC than the value of the electricity you used to generate it. And to your former ‘points’: I think the issue we’re having here is that I’m talking about an abstraction. To you, the potential energy of a $100 bill is the ability to light it on fire to light your cigar, for example. For me, the potential energy is all the work you can do with it as an exchange of value. Money is a way to exchange work. Work is analogous to energy. Therefore, money is analogous to energy. I think where you’re getting bogged down is you Don’t see that to earn an income, you must burn energy in the form of food, money and time. With the Btc farm, you’re saving most of this energy by tapping into a renewable resource to generate the income which you can convert back into value. In short, there is no other way to derive value from a geothermal plant in the middle of nowhere, within reason. Certainly not significant financial value, other than as a crypto mine.