3 ms·
To be honest, I found this to be a painful read, as I often find when I think the author is woefully lacking in self awareness: > “Look Cesar, the truth is tha
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
To be honest, I found this to be a painful read, as I often find when I think the author is woefully lacking in self awareness:
> “Look Cesar, the truth is that, if you are a mediocre researcher, but your department wants to keep you, they’ll find a way to keep you. And if you are a strong researcher, and your department wants to get rid of you, they’ll find a way to get rid of you.”
> I finally got “an answer.” The president of MIT told me that tenure was not about research, productivity, or merit. It was about office politics & being liked by your department.
The first paragraph basically defines every group of humans in the history of humanity. If you are trying to join a group (and, mind you, under rules that can make it extremely difficult if not impossible to ever kick you out of that group), if people plain old just don't like you, they will try very hard not to let you in the group. You can complain about this being "office politics", but that's just plain old human nature.
And the fact that the author thinks the second paragraph, a conclusion that "The president of MIT told me that tenure was not about research, productivity, or merit", follows from the first, just shows a woeful lack of understanding around how human groups organize.
I'm certainly not denying some places have worse office politics than others, and academia is famous for "the emotions are so high because the stakes are so low"- type of drama, but when I see missives like this, where the author just seems so clueless as to how corporations functions, I feel a ton of pity for him, but also can't help but think I probably wouldn't want to work with him either.
- commandlinefan 5y agoHe doesn't go into why they didn't like him, but he doesn't seem particularly surprised, either.
- namelessoracle 5y agoAcademia attracts these types like a moth to a flame. It's a type of arrested development. They go from high school, to high school plus (modern college), and then they don't know what to do enter the "real world" and so they stay in school and get upper graduate degrees.