7 ms·
Bitcoin miners revived a dying fossil fuel plant – then CO2 emissions soared
- scottiebarnes 5y agoEveryone wants to ban bitcoin mining, but nobody wants to tax carbon emissions and end industry subsidies.
- zbrozek 5y agoIt isn't obvious that mining goes away at any cost. Personally I'm in the "do both" camp. Have a simple carbon tax, but also find some inoffensive way to get rid of the mining. Both sound hard.
- tenuousemphasis 5y agoWhile we're picking and choosing who gets to consume electricity, let's get rid of video gaming, casinos, porn websites, etc.
- Tarsul 5y agono. But please tax luxuries especially wrt their externalities.
- tenuousemphasis 5y agoSo like a carbon tax?
- zbrozek 5y agoThat's why the second task is hard. Probably the right way to do it isn't via the electricity angle, but the securities or commerce angles.
- tenuousemphasis 5y agoIf all electricity is generated by renewables and/or dirty electricity is expensive due to a carbon tax, why do you want to ban bitcoin mining too?
- rsynnott 5y agoWhen was the last time you bought an incandescent lightbulb?
- tenuousemphasis 5y agoIt's been a long time, but I don't understand your point.
- Ekaros 5y agoI don't know why electric vehicles should be allowed either. Why not just ban those too? And force people to walk.
- woodruffw 5y agoI think most people want both. What would make you think otherwise?
- neaanopri 5y agoLet's tax stuff in proportion to the value it provides to society Since crypto is used for crime and pyramid schemes, zero value so infinite tax = ban
- scottiebarnes 5y agoBy that logic, we need to ban peer to peer file sharing, encryption, and the internet at large since they are also platforms that allow for crime and pyramid schemes.
- woodruffw 5y agoYou’ve switched the conditions for taxation here: the GP suggested value to society, not adherence to preexisting laws. One of the standard refrains when justifying internet piracy is that intellectual property is actually a net harm to society, so I don’t think the connection you’ve made follows.
- scottiebarnes 5y agoOkay, what metric are we using to determine "value to society"?
- woodruffw 5y agoI don’t think we have to agree on a single metric to see that running a coal-fired power plant for the sole purpose of cracking hashes has marginal, if any value to society. And that’s before we even factor in the ridiculously negative externalities manifest in digging coal out of the earth and burning it.
- scottiebarnes 5y agoI think a decentralized network that is permissionless to participate in, pseudonymous and censorship resistant is very valuable to society. I think an asset that can be secured, transmitted, and stored in self custody cheaply that allows people to escape hyperinflation is quite valuable to society. I think understanding central banking and monetary policy and history of money are not strong points on HN. Everyone here understands that a memory leak causes your app to crash given enough cycles. Being able to print unlimited currency is a memory leak.
- formvoltron 5y agoLet's do both.
- burkaman 5y agoCarbon taxes are very popular, both in the US and globally. I would guess they are more popular than bitcoin bans in the US.
- endisneigh 5y ago> but nobody wants to tax carbon emissions and end industry subsidies I rarely downvote, but downvoted this because it’s blatantly false. Literally hours ago: https://wsau.com/2022/02/18/singapores-carbon-tax-to-rise-five-fold-in-2024/ https://wsau.com/2022/02/18/singapores-carbon-tax-to-rise-fi... https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-02-18/singapore-plans-a-steep-rise-in-carbon-tax-on-big-emitters?utm_source=google&utm_medium=bd&cmpId=google https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-02-18/singapore...
- DavidD 5y agoWould it be possible to take the extra heat from mining and the co2 to make a really nice greenhouse that can use the co2, seems like plenty of space to make it happen in montana.
- haxiomic 5y agoSure, but these people care about extreme profitability at whatever external expense. Something like that, while nice is unlikely to generate more revenue than spinning up another plant and pumping the CO2 into the atmosphere
- mantenpanther 5y agoSee here: https://cointelegraph.com/news/flower-powered-bitcoin-miner-heats-greenhouses-in-the-netherlands/amp https://cointelegraph.com/news/flower-powered-bitcoin-miner-...
- formvoltron 5y agoIs that why you think they are called greenhouse gasses? OMG
- cameron_b 5y agoMost Greenhouses supplement CO2 to increase growth in plants since there's no natural O2 -> CO2 back-cycle in the greenhouse. So yes, Greenhouses use CO2. Reference in Commercial Greenhouse Industry - https://www.greenhousemegastore.com/equip/co2-generators/ https://www.greenhousemegastore.com/equip/co2-generators/
- LegitShady 5y agoThat's not why they're called greenhouse gasses, though. They create the greenhouse effect for the entire planet.
- formvoltron 5y agoThe planet will die, but at least we have these nice plants and these coins.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI don't understand how this is profitable? I'd read that many coal plants were being kept running purely because the grid owners were allowed to charge on a cost plus basis, and closing coal would save consumers billions. So how can these plants be cheaper than solar and wind? Is this somehow a dodge of carbon fees or regulations because it's not going to the grid?
- throw3838 5y agoThey recycled old power plant. That is a huge CO2 offset, building new plant would had huge emmisions.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoRenewables have been cheaper (in monetary and carbon) than running existing coal plants for a while. Even more so if you reuse the sites grid connection. So it still doesn't add up to me. Clearly the couldn't sell energy before if they were about to shutdown, so there must be something different about the miners compared with their usual market, can't just be cheaper. In the article they seem to be suggesting they couldn't buy renewable power in 2020 which seems odd, but no follow up detail on it, apparently they're phasing coal out in a year so it may just have been a short term thing.
- throw3838 5y agoWell, bitcoin mining is not going to be here forever. It could be time limited thing. And knowing Montana, it is difficult to get electricity connection there.
- jhgb 5y agoFalse dichotomy; they could have done neither. NOT operating an old coal plant NOR building a new plant would have produced zero emissions.
- kcplate 5y agoPretty sure the only way to have produced zero emissions was to not mine the bitcoin at all. Old or new plant, or consumption of power from the existing grid would have produced some level of emissions, although Montana tends to have pretty high renewable energy from hydroelectric.
- formvoltron 5y ago
- OGWhales 5y ago> I think the best way to handle these is to take down their names & social security numbers & photos. And save that information in a book. > Once it is realized to be a crime, round these guys up, put them in jail for lifelong sentences. It is disturbing you think like this.
- lom 5y agoThat’s now how the justice system works..
- gordian-mind 5y agoFunnily enough, as extremists like you continue to gain a foothold in policymaking, bitcoin and cryptocurrencies in general will become even more necessary to provide a safeguard against such unhinged power trips.
- johnsonlambo 5y agoSurely that is why btc is more heavily concentrated in the hands of its top 10% holders than real estate, stocks, and gold. Delusional though process you have here where a couple people own btc worth millions/billions/trillions and society will benefit.
- gordian-mind 5y agoNothing you said here matters to me. Btc being concentrated is completely orthogonal to my goals. What I want is to be financially independent, and for that I need assets that don't constantly depreciate b/c of socialist economic policies, and I want those assets to be protected from proto-communists trying to usher in their egalitarian dystopia. But you don't care about that, you care about "society". :-) Even then, imo you are delusional to think that Marxism will benefit society.
- throwaway73838 5y agoI heard an interesting argument for Bitcoin recently. It represents a way to move energy around the world wirelessly. For instance, you can use geothermal power in a very isolated, cold climate that previously would be unusable for any purpose. As Bitcoin’s power needs are decentralized, all it needs is an internet connection. You could have a Bitcoin mine in outer space, if you wanted. Not sure why I’m being downvoted - maybe someone smarter than me can explain it better. I’m too tired to figure out how to put this into words. But basically, the earth has a total energy amount that can be used. Bitcoin can use energy in places you couldn’t get to before, so in a sense, you’re able to do work with isolated energy in a given remote locaton and send the output of that work via the internet to somewhere else.
- Gravityloss 5y agoInteresting. I could heat my home with bitcoin like that. /s
- throwaway73838 5y agoIronically, if you had a Bitcoin mining set up in your home, you’d be more worried about keeping it cool. But you raise a good point - heat is another potential positive externality/resource of Bitcoin mining. Imagine if instead of heaters, we all had decentralized mining rigs to warm our houses?
- pjerem 5y agoWell, they would be like electric space heaters. Inefficient vs heat pumps. Sure, you'd get some coins on top of it. But you (I) would be still considering this to be a waste of energy.
- throwaway73838 5y agoNot really. You would be doing a portion of work that would be done anyway, but instead, it’s being done in your house, for free, and you get a warm house. That’s a positive externality. Much more efficient than using energy for the sole purpose of creating heat.
- danhab99 5y agoOne day the price of Bitcoin is gonna crash and all that work, all that electricity is gonna go to waste.