4 ms·
Think about it this way. The rate at which you burn calories is directly proportional to the rate at which you breathe out CO2 because that what happens with ca
by scotty79 5y ago
Think about it this way. The rate at which you burn calories is directly proportional to the rate at which you breathe out CO2 because that what happens with carbon you burn.
So if every day you train for an hour so that your breathing is 3 times faster, then you have additional two hours of burning in a day. 23 usual hours plus one worth 3. So you have 26 instead of 24 hours in a day.
It's way easier to put 15% less on your plate every day than to intensly train for an hour each day while keeping portions the same.
- bratwurst3000 5y agoYes but in numbers it is way more. If I bike for an hour I burn 700-1000kcal . Thats not 15 but 50% of the dayli calorie intake… i am no expert btw. My understanding is that the problem is more that after 20 minuts of sport, at a certain heart rate, is starting to burn fat…but not body fat. More free floating fat. And it takes one hour or so to start burning bodymass. So the fuel for one hour sport is what I ate before and not my bodyfat. Another example. I do mountaineering, mostly 1 week walking in the alps for 10h a day. Thats around 4000kcal more burned a day. And there I see instant results with all my friends coming with me . They get thin very fast. Around 500g of body mass a day :)
- scotty79 5y ago> If I bike for an hour I burn 700-1000kcal . Thats not 15 but 50% of the dayli calorie intake… That's estimated and probably impossible. 1000 kcal is 4184000 joules, divided by 3600 it gives you around 1100W Human at rest burns about 100W. Pro-cyclist can do additional 400W. There's no way you can burn energy at the rate of 1.1kW consistently for an hour unless you literally set yourself on fire. EDIT: I was wrong. Apparently 700kcal burned per hour of cycling is a pretty realistic number. https://www.welovecycling.com/wide/2020/05/14/how-to-convert-watts-into-calories-burned-on-the-bike/ https://www.welovecycling.com/wide/2020/05/14/how-to-convert... Also resting kcal burn might be around 1800 per day. So 40% increase in of calories burned by hour of cycling per day every day is achievable. The question is how can you breathe out additional ~10h of CO2 within an hour? 3 times deeper breathes 3 times faster? Because that carbon has to go somewhere.
- nckthrn 5y agoCycling is only approximately 25% mechanically efficient, so the parent is correct. There's a lot of heat to get rid of.
- scotty79 5y agoApparently 700kcal burned per hour of cycling is a pretty realistic number. https://www.welovecycling.com/wide/2020/05/14/how-to-convert-watts-into-calories-burned-on-the-bike/ https://www.welovecycling.com/wide/2020/05/14/how-to-convert... Also resting kcal burn might be around 1800 per day. So 40% increase in of calories burned by hour of cycling per day every day is achievable. The question is how can you breathe out additional ~10h of CO2 within an hour? 3 times deeper breathes 3 times faster? Because that carbon has to go somewhere.
- maxerickson 5y agoThe CO2 concentration going up in the blood increases the efficiency of respiration (because it is ultimately diffusion). You don't necessarily need to exchange 10 times the volume of air to deal with the additional CO2.
- scotty79 5y agoRange given for concentration of CO2 on exhaled air is 4-5% So it looks like it could be 25% difference at most.
- maxerickson 5y agoI doubt the 4-5% you saw is a first principle of breathing.
- scotty79 5y agoWhy not? CO2 levels in blood must be tightly controlled. It probably can't get twice as high as usual. If there's already 4% of CO2 in the air around you it's an immediate danger. While you can spend 10 minutes in 3%. If your body could bump up CO2 in exhaled air from 4% to 8% then you'd probably have bo problem surviving in air thay contains 4%.
- stedaniels 5y agoYou are arguing a different point. They argued that doing exercise burns more calories than sitting idle. @1_player said: > Your body burns incredibly more energy just "being there" than you burn moving about.
- scotty79 5y agoI was objecting to the word "incredibly".
- tgb 5y agoYou're assuming that breathing rate is proportional to CO2 breathed out, which I doubt. I barely breath any faster while running than while just sitting here, much less than 3x.
- scotty79 5y agoIt is directly proportional because of how lungs work. The percentage of CO2 in exhaled air is roughly the same regardless of how fast you are breathing (if you don't artificially accelerate your breathing beyond what your body dictates). Lungs can't put in more CO2 in breathed out air. If you breath only slightly faster when you are running than when you are sitting that must mean you ran quite a lot and optimized your stride so that you don't burn much more calories running than sitting. But more likely explanation is that you are not aware how fast exactly you are breathing when sitting and running. Try to measure it. Also take into account that you might be taking shallower breaths when you are sitting. Just blow up a balloon when you are sitting and when you are running with your normal exhaled breath for few seconds to test it.
- dr_dshiv 5y agoAlso, you don’t absorb everything you eat. Actually, let me be clear: I have no evidence for this. But the fact that my weight is so consistent despite my radically inconsistent eating and exercising suggests to me that my body can regulate digestion. When I’m in a period when I’m overeating, my body just doesn’t absorb so much. Again, more speculation, but i would imagine that metabolic disorders involve digestive regulation issues, not just lack of exercise and overeating.