10 ms·
Old timey phone systems did have echo cancelation. One of the tones in high speed (hah!) modem handshakes is intended to disable the echo cancelers, so that the
by toast0 5y ago
Old timey phone systems did have echo cancelation. One of the tones in high speed (hah!) modem handshakes is intended to disable the echo cancelers, so that the modems can do it better, but the system echo cancellers usually worked well for actual voice communications.
They also had a whole heck of a lot less latency. Sure, routes were probably less direct, but if you had an honest to goodness analog line, the only added latency was from amplifiers and multiplexing equipment, neither of which added significant latency. More likely your call would be digitized and sent as part of a T1 or similar circuit; but that doesn't add a lot of delay, because a T1 is multiplexed as one sample per line, 8000 samples per second per line. Where your is connected at digital telphone switches, there would need to be a buffer to match up timing, but it only needs to be one sample long. There's not likely to be that many switches on a call, so total added latency is going to be a few sample lengths, and maybe around 1ms. (This is in addition to the transmission delay, of course)
In contrast, modern computers have meaningful audio sampling delays, and transmitting each sample would kill your network, so you batch a few samples (usually 10-40ms worth), there's delay from the encode/decode, and packet switched networking also adds delay in waiting for a send slot.
Echo cancelling with all that latency is even more important, cause the echos are hard to tune out when they come back so late.
- rightbyte 5y agoInteresting thank you for the writeup! I tried to find a comparison of sound latency for old phones, modern mobile and e.g. MS Teams, but couldn't find any. I didn't know there were echo cancellation in old time phones: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echo_suppression_and_cancellation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echo_suppression_and_cancell... Is it maybe the background noise filters that mess up sound latency in Teams? I used to play with friends over a privately hosted Ventrilo server back in the days, and the conversations were always crystal clear and felt like instant. Maybe the VOIP providers just timeshare calls too much in their servers or have bad routing of packages.