4 ms·
There seems to be a lot of people addressing the flagging of posts. I think most of the post I've seen flagged are flagged because they're either off topic, or
by giantg2 5y ago
There seems to be a lot of people addressing the flagging of posts. I think most of the post I've seen flagged are flagged because they're either off topic, or they seem to contain false information or spam.
I don't see many addressing the comments being flagged. Maybe because it happens less often or is less visible than for posts? At least it seems that way to me. I've seen things mostly down voted instead (posts don't have that option, so maybe that's why flagging is used more there).
The main thing I have seen as comments being flagged are for nonsense/spam replies, or some sort of vulgar name calling. However, I have seen comments (including my own) that don't seem to be breaking the rules get flagged. Usually in this case it's all the comments I have posted in that thread. They later become unflagged. I assume these would be a case of someone abusing the system because they don't like my opinion.
On the other side of this, I see some comments that break the rules when things get heated, and typically they aren't flagged. I usually don't flag them either since the offense is generally de minimus in my view.
- greenyoda 5y ago> or they seem to contain false information I don't agree with flagging comments just because someone thinks they're false. I'm guessing that many things that the majority of people on HN consider false at a given point in time are actually subject to serious debate by knowledgeable people. For example, statements about Covid being primarily spread by droplets, which were made by the CDC early in the pandemic and were later shown to be false. If someone would have posted a comment back then saying it's more likely that Covid was spread by aerosols (which is what the CDC says today), should it have been flagged? "Facts" in news stories are frequently proven wrong as more information becomes available. If you think something is false, it's better to cite a reference that supports your position. Perhaps someone will cite a more convincing reference that disputes it, and people can delve further.
- giantg2 5y agoI agree that seemingly false info should be refuted instead of flagged. I was just saying it seems like that's that's what gets flagged. This one seems like maybe it got flagged just for typos https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30379327 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30379327 This one seems to be stating that hiding false information is censorship... and was then flagged. Sort of seems like they flagged the very thing you were talking about not flagging. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30376183 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30376183