5 ms·
I found it depressing. Ships aren't built to stay in the harbor, and rockets aren't built to lie on their side rusting. They say we couldn't build another Sat
by CamperBob2 5y ago
I found it depressing. Ships aren't built to stay in the harbor, and rockets aren't built to lie on their side rusting.
They say we couldn't build another Saturn V if we tried. Apparently that old saw is true enough, at least for the original contractors.
- tjchear 5y agoFor lack of a political will or the technical know how?
- MPSimmons 5y agoIn order to make a vehicle like that, you need the tools to make it. That doesn't just include wrenches and hammers - it includes the tooling used to form the curve of the skin and the area you assemble the pieces into. Almost all of that is gone, disassembled or misplaced.
- CamperBob2 5y agoThe popular wisdom is that we literally lost some of the technical specs and drawings. A lot of the R&D would have to be redone from scratch... not that it wouldn't make sense to do that anyway, 50+ years later.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tjchear 5y agoNot exactly related, but this reminds me of this triple nuclear plant project that ran into trouble by the time they're on their third, because it took so long, people with the requisite knowledge was gone and the remaining people had no idea how to fill the gap.
- ebruchez 5y agoThe CuriousMarc YouTube channel [1] features a current series where they work on some Saturn transmission equipment (Apollo Comms). They also also restored an AGC (Apollo Guidance Computer). Those were incredible designs for the time, but you wouldn't build (and probably couldn't even if you tried) these modules this way today. I'd say the loss is more one of history than actual utility. The only way would have been to keep the Saturn V going during the whole time, and upgrade its technology as time went. [1] https://www.youtube.com/c/CuriousMarc https://www.youtube.com/c/CuriousMarc
- pacetherace 5y ago1. Lost records 2. Many companies that help build those rockets have ceased to exists 3. Technology and tooling have changed substantially 4. Standards to deem a rocket flight worthy for human space flight have changed
- adastra22 5y ago> Lost records This is actually a myth FYI. No records were ever lost, and you can go see all the original blueprints and relevant memos and technical reports in the archives at Marshall or DC if you want. It's all there. Where the myth comes from, and the kernel of truth underlying it is that the Saturn V was a hand-crafted machine made by experts. NASA and their contractors did their damndest to record every aspect of its production, but undoubtably there is some things that slipped through the cracks and were never written down. Those were lost not because records were lost, but because the individual workers went on to other jobs, and have since retired. EDIT: Also the tooling has been dismantled and recycled. The blueprints for the tooling exist and it all could be recreated, how sure are we that the specified tolerances matched the actual article? Uncertainty over this would probably invalidate all the testing that had been done.
- adolph 5y agoReminds me of the Fogbank story: In a bizarre twist, the new production facility and reverse-engineered production process yielded a version of Fogbank that was of a higher purity than it had been in the past, according to the article. The problem, however, was that for Fogbank to work as intended in existing warhead designs, that previous level of impurity was actually essential. NNSA had to revise the process to ensure the final product was just as impure. https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/32867/fogbank-is-mysterious-material-used-in-nukes-thats-so-secret-nobody-can-say-what-it-is https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/32867/fogbank-is-myste...
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"undoubtably there is some things that slipped through the cracks and were never written down." I dont think they slip through the cracks as much as people today have different skils. It's like trying to get. Bunch of Node-JS developers to get a mainframe-based system from the 80s working.
- CountSessine 5y agoTechnical know how, mostly. But in expected ways. Machining and engineering skills as they relate to manufacturing are different now. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ovD0aLdRUs0 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ovD0aLdRUs0
- edgyquant 5y agoThe phrase, “we couldn’t build one if we wanted to,” is misleading. We could build the exact vehicle but we could build one that looks similar and does the same thing.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoWe could not get it working in 5 years, maybe in 10. At that point you are not building, you are reverse engineering and re-engineering
- stjohnswarts 5y agoWith money and political will they absolutely could build one in 5 years. I'm not sure why people are stuck on this "we just can't accomplish what they did in the good ol' days"
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoBecause they look at how uk or california take 20 years to build a railway or any other infrastructure project and draw conclusions
- renewiltord 5y agoNah, it's historic. We have better stuff now. It's like a Model T. The best place for it is in the museum.
- lmm 5y agoThe difference is we see better versions of the Model T in use every day, whereas we don't currently have a rocket that can take people the moon.
- jiggawatts 5y agoThe design is now thoroughly outdated. It wouldn't be cost-effective to reproduce a Saturn V as-is. The equivalent rocket is the Starship, which clearly can be built. Technologies like 3D printing, new alloys, better fuels, modern computers, etc... have made dramatic differences to the design and construction of these rockets. Have a look at the circuitry used on the Saturn V: http://www.righto.com/2020/04/a-circuit-board-from-saturn-v-rocket.html http://www.righto.com/2020/04/a-circuit-board-from-saturn-v-... Especially the "instrument unit": http://static.righto.com/images/lvda/IU-labeled.jpg http://static.righto.com/images/lvda/IU-labeled.jpg It's huuuuuuge! The computer power of that entire thing could fit into a single chip these days. Trying to reproduce something like that 1:1 in the modern age would be just absurd. Note that the Saturn V design isn't just cost-inefficient because technology has moved on. It wasn't cost effective back then either! The per-launch costs were over $1B in inflation adjusted dollars, putting it squarely into the same ballpark has the SLS, which is a monstrously expensive pork-barrel project designed primarily to burn money, not rocket fuel.
- garaetjjte 5y ago>The design is now thoroughly outdated. Not really, fundamentals doesn't change that much. Starship is not equivalent, it is entirely new, different category. >better fuels, modern computers, etc... have made dramatic differences to the design and construction of these rockets. Saturn V used RP1 and LH2 fuels, both are still widely used. Gas generator cycles are also used in modern engines. You can have smaller computers now but I don't think this would change costs significantly. Really only thing that changed significantly are manufacturing processes, but that doesn't invalidate the entire design, that you cannot make 1:1 copy doesn't mean you cannot port it to modern manufacturing methods, like this proposal for F-1B: https://arstechnica.com/science/2013/04/new-f-1b-rocket-engine-upgrades-apollo-era-deisgn-with-1-8m-lbs-of-thrust/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2013/04/new-f-1b-rocket-engi...
- NickNameNick 5y agoGas generator cycle engines are definitely still in use, but a lot of next generation engines use a staged-combustion cycle. The effiency improvements seem to be good enough to be worth the engineering challenges, especially for larger rockets.
- mlyle 5y ago> They say we couldn't build another Saturn V if we tried. Apparently that old saw is true enough, at least for the original contractors. We can't build an authentic Great Pyramid, 1950s supercar, or 1970's minicomputer, either. At least, not for anything resembling cost-effectiveness compared to the current way to do things.
- ineedasername 5y ago>They say Who are "they", and how can that opinion hold true when we are in fact building something comparable to it?
- stjohnswarts 5y agolol of course we could build another Saturn V. It would be practically from scratch and require a congress which is a bit less polarized, but that's just a silly statement.
- Someone 5y agoThe engine was extensively scanned recently (https://www.3dsystems.com/learning-center/case-studies/reigniting-f-1-apollo-engine-geomagic-solutions https://www.3dsystems.com/learning-center/case-studies/reign...), so plans of what was actually built exist. If we don’t have plans for the rest, we could use that technique on the other parts. That doesn’t mean we can build a 100% copy, though. Apparently, some of the welding requires techniques that have been replaced by better methods, and welders who can replicate the original do not exist. I guess that’s solvable by using robots, but if, e.g., 3D printing or even glueing works better, and the goal would be to get a rocket that size again, why bother?