3 ms·
Maybe I am missing something but why do they interpret this joke as being about the Holocaust? IMHO, it seems more about Canada's skyrocketing deficit and debt
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
Maybe I am missing something but why do they interpret this joke as being about the Holocaust?
IMHO, it seems more about Canada's skyrocketing deficit and debt with a quip that even Hitler had to contend with a budget (in general, not specifically to conduct the Holocaust) whereas Trudeau seems not to.
- giraffe_lady 5y agoMy first connection when I see a photo of hitler is the holocaust, not budget committee deadlocks or whatever. It may be a stretch but I think my immediate association is going to be pretty close to average for most audiences. The fact that you had to go so far out of your way to explain why it shouldn't be interpreted that way communicates a bit by itself too.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoI did not go far out... I just described what I thought when I saw the picture of the joke, and that was not the Holocaust, which is not mentioned or suggested. On the other hand, "Budget" is the key word in the joke... Arstechnica explicitly says that the joke is a reference to the Holocaust and I just don't understand how they can based solely on the tweet. Hitler goes quite beyond the Holocaust (I think everyone in Europe at least is well aware of that). The joke in fact makes more sense when looking at Hitler's deeds as dictator in general, especially the invasion of most of Europe (I'm assuming Musk knows his History here)...
- sofixa 5y ago> IMHO, it seems more about Canada's skyrocketing deficit and debt with a quip that even Hitler had to contend with a budget (in general, not specifically to conduct the Holocaust) whereas Trudeau seems not to. Few things to unwrap here. First, Hitler didn't contend with a budget - his country invaded, annexed, pillaged, stole, used slave labour at will to prop up their coffers. And the economy was already in a death spiral by the time of 1939 due to excessive spending on rearmament and vanity projects resulting in skyrocketing deficits. Second, the way i interpret the "joke" is that Trudeau is compared to Hitler on their actions ( tyrannical actions). Many people have this crazy notion that being forced to get a vaccine is absolutely the same as the persecutions Jewish people faced in Nazi Germany, hence the Holocaust reference, because this "joke" isn't in a vacuum.