6 ms·
Designing Olympic sports for the spectator
- Daviey 5y agoIn the early 2000's, when I was quite involved in UK Skydiving - there was quite a strong bid to try and get it recognised as an Olympic sport. However, the bid was denied and my understanding to the reasoning being that it wasn't a good spectator sport. However, I believe indoor skydiving is making good progress with their latest bid.
- wirthjason 5y ago“What do you in think about skydiving?” IOC: “too boring, viewers won’t want to watch that.” “What about skydiving without a parachute?” IOC: “Now that’s worth watching!”
- seanalltogether 5y agoI can't comment on how Peacock presents their sports in a way that causes spoilers since I don't have it. But I do watch the 4 Grand Slam tennis tournaments every year, and I hate the way those are presented when offered on a streaming service like Amazon or Eurosport. If I start up a match that shows it's only 90-110 minutes long, then I know immediately that whoever wins the first set will win the match. You can also guess which matches only go to 4 sets as well when looking at the time. Whats worse is Amazon was doing this thing where they would split the the match into part 1 and part 2 if it was over 2 hours long, so again you know immediately whether a match ends early or not.
- cottager2 5y agoI agree. But there are so many ways a sporting event can be spoiled. For one, as a fan, you might just be curious. Or you might subscribe to the tennis subreddit, etc. I love tennis but basically only watch the Australian open because I can watch it live at night. Your best bet is probably to pick a sport that they play in your time zone.
- wirthjason 5y ago> The big problem is spoilers. If you are not very careful, if you go to the Peacock site you will get spoilers. For example, if the medal games are in your list, they change the title of the entry to be the names of the people playing -- spoiling the semi-finals for you. I love sports but hate watching them delayed online because of design like this. I don’t know who created these designs but it’s terrible. The author is right, a local “dumb” DVR is the way to go for watching sports. The UX for online sports is terrible. One example is soccer matches on ESPN, they will display highlight bars on the timeline when something exciting happens, like a goal or a penalty. It’s destroys the suspense for me because I see the markers and know something is going to happens. They also show a progress bar with the length, which makes it easy to know if the game went into extra time. Eg. One team goes up 2 goals early but the recording time is longer then you know the other team comes back to force extra time.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThese are from the same section of the post: > As noted above, I am not a fan of judged sports. While they are not going away, I think there could be merit in moving towards computer judging -- ie. like the clock -- for many of them. > One of the tragedies of sports like figure skating is that because people are pushed to the limit of what they can do, the winner ends up being the one who didn't fall. In a contest between one man who can jump a quad axel 80% of the time, but then tries it and fails, he loses to the man who can't do it at all and never tries. That does appear to be a real problem in modern Olympic figure skating. But my first guess would be that it's caused by the move away from purely subjective judging, which penalized falls harshly, to objective technical scoring, which doesn't. Failing a triple axel is almost as good as executing a flawless double axel. So falls are incredibly common now. This actually reminds me of complaints I saw about having the THC content of marijuana varieties listed. Suddenly (according to the complaints) that's all customers cared about, so they'd buy varieties that were worse and end up less happy.
- divan 5y agoThe real tragedy of figure skating is that there is no figure skating anymore. It's called "figure skating" because the primary skill was "skating" and skaters were drawing "figures". It was called "compulsory figures" and it was a big part of competition. The fraction of overall score for figures has changed from 60% to 40% and then to 0% (in 1990). While "free skating" part became mostly a competition of the jumps. The problem with jumps is that it discrimnates heavily by body type, while "figure skating" does not. I mean in compulsory figures the one who practiced longer and better wins. In jumps – the one who has smaller body wins. Kamila Valieva at age 20 will be 5 years more experienced and stronger than Kamila Valieva at age 15, and as much as talented, but she will not have a slightest chance to win herself at 15. How does it even make sense to people? To rotate 4*360 degrees in 0.6 seconds you really benefit from smaller sum of radiuses of mass distribution. This is how female figure skating became competition of 15 pre-puberty girls. With this overfocus on number of rotations, international figure skating losing fans and members like crazy. Arenas are half empty even on major competitions and international federation is wondering why revenues are plummeting. But the tragedy is even deeper. Most older coaches in many countries are still from the generation who did "compulsory figures". They remember it, they remember how to teach the basics, although rarely do because everyone wants jumps as instructed by ISU rules. But new generation of coaches don't even know about figures, let alone how to tech them. And the older coaches already, you know, are dying. And we losing this knowledge. We're loosing roots of figure skating as a community. But figures are instrumental part of figure skating, and really important to perform jumps efficiently.
- mynameismon 5y agoGoing through both the comments, and my own experiences (as a student, I don't get enough time to watch the replays of various matches of my favourite teams), I think there should probably be an option to enable psuedo-live watching: complete videos without progress bars, but with the ability to fast forward/slow down/move back, and no videos available dated after the last video seen.
- CydeWeys 5y ago> Every single sport can be watched on Peacock, which is free to me and only $5/month for people without Comcast. Something like this exists in most countries. However, what you watch has forced commercial breaks -- and if you fast forward over a large section past a commercial break you must watch it -- and you can't really fast forward, only seek around. Dude, pay the $10 for one month for ad-free Peacock. It's worth it, and much better than the author's alternative.
- mhb 5y agoYes, but it's pretty lame that they substitute a static screen that lasts as long as the ads in the place of the ads. It would be much nicer if they excised them.
- ChicagoBoy11 5y agoOoof and the ones that do this coupled with some usually-obnoxious but always-repeating song deserve a special place in hell. I was so pleasantly surprised when I got YouTube TV when some ad-less spots were just substituted by a tranquil nature scene (a movie clip, so you were still sure that it wasn't frozen) and no music at all.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bradtemp 5y agoMy error. I thought I had the premium service as an Xfinity customer, and the ads were just showing up because these were sports recorded live. I definitely would have done that knowing. Well, almost definitely. Streaming DVR is just a shadow of what local disk DVR is. I can seek instantly at distances I configure. I can fast forward and see what's happening. I can do 3x fast forward that's perfectly smooth, and 2x fast forward with pitch adjusted audio -- that's so nice for a lot of sports or for boring sections of certain sports. So commercial free Peacock would only get so far, and downloading the stream and playing it locally is still better. If you do it right, you can even do standard DVR -- watch the stream while it is downloading, so you are only a short distance behind live, and avoid spoilers.
- nerdponx 5y agoI don't agree at all that time trial events with staggered starts are confusing. Maybe they tend to lack excitement sometimes, when a clear winner emerges early and holds a lead. But the English commentators are generally really good at motivating the sense of action and drama. It's especially helpful when they point out specific aspects of an athlete's technique or strategy that a casual viewer might otherwise not be aware of, or that might not be easy to perceive on video. For me at least, this makes it easier to appreciate the action more and keeps the interest level high.
- 0xTJ 5y agoI know that this is completely a personal preference, but for me, there's no point to watching most sports events delayed. Sure I'd watch a clip if something remarkable happened, but the point for me is to be there (remotely) as it happens. I wouldn't have re-watched the whole women's CAN-USA gold medal game the next day if I hadn't stayed up till 1:30 watching it, I would have at most just watched the highlights. The one personal exception to that is Formula 1, where I'll go to great lengths to avoid spoilers for a race that I couldn't watch live. I don't know much about the background of the author, but I feel that they understate the challenges in doing AI-based scoring for figure skating. They mention being close to the "ideal form", and say that it might be easier than expected to judge the artistic elements, but don't really support this. Figure skating is an art, and judging it in any way where the artistry isn't at a similar importance to the technical aspects defeats the purpose. I do acknowledge the point on needing to be skilled to tell apart tricks. The figure skating pundits would immediately recognize each figure skating trick, while I was left, at best, counting the number of rotations. I just don't know enough to see which edge of the skate the use, or how much toe there is. Overall, I can't agree with a lot of the author's points. Without tripling each event (to gain a larger sample size), and radically changing the sports in play, there isn't much you can change. Sure you could drop all bracket games and do a full double-round-robins, but I feel that that would hurt the games far more than it would help.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- divan 5y agooh boy, glad to see those thoughts are on HN, but it barely scratched the surface of the problem. It's a special topic of interest for me, as I'm currently trying to reform sports in my country (figure skating in particular) and involved with number of projects (software and hardware) for sports. The main point I want to praise this article for is that sport should be designed. Most sport are not, they just emerged from free play activities and for the last 70+ years are mostly being changed reactively as a response to professionalization, tragic events and TV requirements (as TV rights are the major source of revenue for many international federations). There is no book or theory on how to design the sport. How to choose tradeoffs to satisfy different stakeholders. The closest thing I could find is actually body of knowledge from computer game designers – how to keep users engaged, how to ensure the incentive structure is aligned, how to fit into requirements of the game/tournaments etc. Because of this I suspect eSports will outperform many traditional sports soon in terms of member base by a lot. In traditional sport if you want to know how a smallest change in rules will alter the whole game – you out of luck. The only way is just to push hard for the change and watch. Here is a great read about cascading changes in hockey provoked by tiny changes of the equipment regulations. [1] Or how suboptimal incentive structure in Badminton tournament resulted in weird incentives to loose [2] But sports officials and decision makers are often ex-athletes themselves. They carry too much burden of attachement to particular styles or traditions, and very few are trained in system design or math or economics. Sports industry is very conservative. Take athletics pole vault mentioned in the article. How does it differ from long jump? Long and high jump/pole vault are jumps and the goal is find "the best jumper". But historically it was easy to measure distance and hard to measure height. So high jump/pole vault uses this progressive system, and long jump does not. Why? Tradition, even though progressive system is suboptimal, because athlete becomes more and more tired towards increasing the height (and doesn't show their true best). Also the winner is always the one who failed last, which is a bit disappointing but might be more engaging for the audience. I'm not even starting with figure skating judging. In a 100 years it moved from literally voting for style to measuring individual elements. The problem is that for measuring it uses biological sensors called "humans". As with many imperfect sensors they use sensor fusion approaches (7-9 judges in a row + trimmed mean), but the nature of the error and bias still makes a lot of room for subjective judging and building coalitions (especially from judges in ex-Soviet bloc). Japanese IceScope system is one step forward to start augmenting judges with objective numbers but it's really primitive (2 4K cameras measuring skaters' jump as a pixel movement and only can assess length and speed of a jump). Olympics used FreeD system, which is impressive but way out of price range for most federations in the world. Anyway, this topic is huge. Would be grateful for any links or papers that you think might be relevant to sports design. [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/culture/archive/2021/02/hockey-goalies-are-too-big-now/618021/ https://www.theatlantic.com/culture/archive/2021/02/hockey-g... [2] https://agtb.wordpress.com/2012/08/01/olympic-badminton-is-not-incentive-compatible-6/ https://agtb.wordpress.com/2012/08/01/olympic-badminton-is-n...
- notatoad 5y agobefore they start designing sports for the spectator, they should at least start designing the broadcast for the spectator. trying to watch the mens 5000m speedskating relay the other night was a frustrating experience - find the speedskating broadcast, and then somewhere in the middle of a 3hr video was the event i wanted to see. the only way to watch was to scrub around the video until i found it. and maybe other broadcasters are doing a better job of surfacing things than CBC is, but as a canadian i'm restricted to only CBC's format, if a friend in another country shares a clip with me i can't watch it.
- TYPE_FASTER 5y agoI have to say, watching the 2022 Winter Olympics using the Peacock app has been awesome. Being able to watch the events I want to watch, as opposed to being forced to watch the events broadcast producers decided to air has been great. Not being forced to watch background pieces has also been great. Being able to choose whether to watch the live event, or watching it later when I have time, has also been great. It's basically what I always wanted when spectating the Olympics. I can choose to watch the practice runs for the alpine downhill. Somebody else, in the same house even, can watch figure skating for days. It's like we're living in the future!
- bradtemp 5y agoNice to see this show up on HN. I wrote an addendum, not in that post... Olympic rant #2: Fake "team" events. We now see a lot of events promoted as team events where the team members need never have practiced together and don't even meet each other at the venue necessarily. These are team events where just add the scores of various competitors, or "relays" where there is no baton, nobody touches. Sadly to me, this has become a common form for mixed events. I have been wanting to see more mixed events, but I wanted to see mixed events where the men and women actually work together, like pairs skating or mixed doubles tennis or curling. It's very easy to make a mixed team event in a real team sport. You can make a rule like "3 men and 3 women on the ice." I understand that in some sports, like swimming, you can't have a baton, but it would be nice if they had to touch or something. In the downhill sports they can't easily physically meet. Mixed team snowboard cross had the man set a time, and that controlled when the woman was let out of the gate (later.) But all this is better than the sports where you just add scores and they aren't really a team at all. These events are just an excuse for nationalism. They will always be won by big countries which have the size and budget to send a group of high level athletes good enough to get the best average score.
- cottager2 5y agoI don’t mind judged sports. Do judges make mistakes sometimes? Certainly. But generally the ranking matches the demonstrated skill level. A much bigger issue with the winter Olympics is the repetition. How many times can I watch someone ski down a hill or jump off a jump? And then many events have 3 runs. You end up watching so many runs it’s feels repetitive. My favorite events are events like biathalon, where you only have to watch the event one time.