4 ms·
> This market is ridiculous if you actually need a place to live, and it's not even a matter of income. The US needs to make a policy decision: are houses inve
by echelon 5y ago
> This market is ridiculous if you actually need a place to live, and it's not even a matter of income.
The US needs to make a policy decision: are houses investments or a way to nurture and grow the lower and middle class?
If it's the former, they can use tax policies to encourage the desired behavior. Tax every residential home (single family or condominium) at 10-30% of its total value per year, regardless of who owns it. Give a complete write off for your first home. Maybe give a partial write off for your second home. Make owners bear the cost of appraisals, and if appraisals aren't available, tax them at the most expensive 90th percentile.
But of course maybe the US decides homes are investments. Great for the wealthy, but the lower and middle classes are really going to get hurt. Birth rates will slip even further.
- conductr 5y ago> But of course maybe the US decides homes are investments They have. By not deciding, they have decided. It would be incredibly harmful to reverse course now. Typical US policy is to get backed into a corner until doing the right & obvious thing is incredibly difficult and practically impossible.
- maerF0x0 5y ago> The US needs to make a policy decision: are houses investments or a way to nurture and grow the lower and middle class? They already have. home buyer loans are backed by the government. You can write off loan interest. Investors pay taxes on income from the investment (net rent and capital gains) ... Also just like in education space the more the government subsidizes the pricing, the more it gets inflated. So more incentives will just lead to more demand and higher prices. What we really need is more supply and elasticity. More houses, and more people willing to say "F--- this I'm moving to CheapTown"
- reedjosh 5y ago> You can write off loan interest. Which only matters if you somehow go above the crazy high $25k standard deduction. I am fairly well off and have kids and student loan debt to write off interest on as well, but I've never broke $19k in write offs. So, unless you have a business or something, the interest write off is kinda useless.
- VirusNewbie 5y agoYou must live in a low CoL state? I'm easily above that, 10k for state taxes and paying 20k in interest a year isn't that much.
- reedjosh 5y ago> You must live in a low CoL state? Ish... 2500 in property tax (house is >100yrs old), and 3.125% interest on a loan w/$285k left on the mortgage. > 10k for state taxes Are you saying you can write off your state taxes?
- CuriouslyC 5y agoIt's capped, but yeah. That's the SALT tax cap that has been a point of political contention.
- HWR_14 5y ago> just like in education space the more the government subsidizes the pricing, the more it gets inflated. People keep saying this, but I haven't seen any real evidence of that. In education or personal home ownership. Do you have any studies that actually show any causation, or is this all correlation?
- Firaxus 5y agoI found your comment thoughtful, but it seems to me you meant “latter” rather than “former”? iirc hacker news let’s you edit a comment for up to an hour after posting.
- echelon 5y agoWhoops, totally a slip of the mind. Missed the edit window by an hour, too. (IIRC, it's the two hour mark when you're locked from making edits.)
- HPsquared 5y agoWouldn't that tax proposal just increase rent for people who don't own their home (landlords pass on the costs) and not affect homeowners other than lowering the value of their home if they come to sell it (i.e. upside-down on mortgage).
- blululu 5y agoWell they made an exception for the first building. In general if you construct laws such that the property tax is progressive on total assets then there is a pricing advantage for smaller landlords. They can charge lower rates, make more profit, etc.