3 ms·
The American housing crisis is really a "housing in top 7-10 metro areas" crisis. There is no shortage of cheap land and houses just 30-40 minutes away from whe
by paxys 5y ago
The American housing crisis is really a "housing in top 7-10 metro areas" crisis. There is no shortage of cheap land and houses just 30-40 minutes away from where you really want to be. Maybe the real solution is to continue making remote work the default so people aren't tied to an arbitrary radius from an office building in their home search?
- rcpt 5y ago> cheap land and houses just 30-40 minutes away Tell me you're not in California without telling me you're not in California
- tristor 5y agoI thought this too until I tried to move. It's not true. It's in pretty much every state and city in the US. Even my house price more than doubled in ten years, and I'm currently residing in one of the lowest cost of living cities in the US. The only places where you don't see this happening are also places where you can't get a proper broadband Internet connection, which makes it a nonstarter for even remote workers. So, really, no. My sister had this issue buying a farm in Eastern Colorado (which is not even considered a desirable area) more than an hour away from Denver, as a simple personal example.
- dionidium 5y agoThe current uptick in prices is affecting all markets. I bought an unremarkable bungalow in South St. Louis for $72k in 2016 and sold it for $135k in 2020. Zillow says it's worth $150k now. That's still a relatively cheap house, but the houses that were $150k in 2016 are now $250k. These are big jumps for an unfashionable neighborhood in a Midwestern market.
- lastofthemojito 5y ago> The current uptick in prices is affecting all markets Maybe, but not all markets equally, and not all market segments equally. I bought my townhouse in 2015 and Zillow says it's now worth 8.6% more than I paid for it. I don't know the numbers but a buddy of mine who bought a 1-bedroom condo in 2008, and then ended up starting a family, has been renting it out for years since he's underwater on it. I would have thought the past year would have gotten him to the point where he can finally break even and get rid of it, but apparently not. I think this has always been the case, but especially in COVID times, single family homes seem to be outgaining townhouses, which are outgaining apartment-style condos.
- asdff 5y agoThis might have been the case during the 2007 bubble but today this isn't really the case anymore. Even podunk midwestern places far from major midwestern cities are seeing huge surges in housing prices. This is a generational problem: millenials are attempting to buy homes but over the past twenty years, literally across the board everywhere in this country, we have failed to build housing for this coming generation. The last time we had a crises to this scale was after WWII, when returning veterans found no housing stock for them, and had to literally wait in quonset huts with their approved GI bill mortgage while the first suburbs were developed at a rate at which we cannot seem to build at again today. Now there are more millenials than those in the greatest generation, and the lack of building supply has been going on for even longer than what we saw after WWII. Prices everywhere are relatively high, relative is important. You might have your remote gig, enjoy it. You are of the few. Most people are finding their remote gigs are turning into hybrid gigs; the old guard doesn't care you are efficient at home. So now you are beholden to local jobs anyhow even if 50% of it takes place on zoom and 100% could easily be done as well. If you want to take advantage of midwestern home prices, now you are being paid at midwestern salaries and competing with midwestern doctors and lawyers and business executives like you did in the bay area. The octave has shifted by an order of magnitude, but its the same song you are playing. The same lack of supply. You might even net out worse considering the tax structure especially on property in different places means your costs might go up as real estate continues to go up, and your salary generally does not tumble up 10-20% per year to help you afford those reassessments, and there are few places you can laterally jump ship to and find higher pay in the much smaller midwest (which is why educated midwesterners flee to places like the coasts for their jobs anyway; its cheaper on paper but its often not in practice).
- acchow 5y ago> The American housing crisis is really a "housing in top 7-10 metro areas" crisis This has not been true since COVID.
- jjav 5y ago> The American housing crisis is really a "housing in top 7-10 metro areas" crisis. There is no shortage of cheap land and houses just 30-40 minutes away from where you really want to be. Sort of true, except it is far more than 30-40 minutes away. You'll have to commute at least ~4-5 hours from the bay area to get into affordable territory.