"I did not realize it matters whether you're "in the field" or not, thinking that good contributions are welcomed equally as being good contributions." It's no

"I did not realize it matters whether you're "in the field" or not, thinking that good contributions are welcomed equally as being good contributions." It's not necessarily 'in the field' - I, for example, happily review things from economists, ecologists, epidemiologists, computer scientists, or mathematicians. It's more "Here's my massive, probably undocumented spreadsheet - thoughts?" has a very low Bayesian prior for "Worth my time".