But people are criticizing his result. His complaint is not "Nobody read my book or looked at my spreadsheets" but instead "People are disagreeing with my conc

But people are criticizing his result. His complaint is not "Nobody read my book or looked at my spreadsheets" but instead "People are disagreeing with my conclusions, but not my logic." If his case wasn't worth arguing about then people wouldn't be arguing with him. Given that they are arguing it's interesting to note that they aren't doing it by arguing quantitatively.