3 ms·
In another HN post recently a commenter said something about the stock market, and they invoked an image of people collecting money from Brownian movement. It
by Brian_K_White 5y ago
In another HN post recently a commenter said something about the stock market, and they invoked an image of people collecting money from Brownian movement.
It struck me that comment was excellent and insightful, and was only possible because both the commenter and myself were once taught something that neither of us uses in our day jobs, and may never have learned through any normal self-driven persuit.
The more I hear about this book the more ignorant it sounds. The benefits of having a significant, as large as possible, portion of everyone being at least somewhat educated on a wide range of basic ideas (not facts so much) isn't quantifiable. It's effects are in countless infinite small thimgs that no one can tally.
It's not good enough that some small percent of people would always be educated, because those people still have to interact with everyone else. We already have a bad enough problem of people simply not even understanding what other people say, and therefor not crediting or respecting it at all and going with their feelings on everything.
- betwixthewires 5y agoIf the benefit is not quantifiable then how is it possible to draw the conclusion that there is a benefit (or negative impact on the same token) in the first place? If the price of education is quantifiable and the debt for it enforceable, then the benefit better be quantifiable.
- butwhywhyoh 5y agoYou are providing zero evidence that there is any value to your experience about reading a clever comment comparing Brownian motion and the stock market. Not even qualitatively. You are already an incredibly rare person who would equate such things, so I think it's very odd that you think this concept could apply to the general population. The cherry on top is you haven't even read the book or looked at the spreadsheet, which is precisely the authors point. You are one of the many people who heard something about the book, made assumptions about it, and then decided the book must be ignorant. Bravo!
- tomrod 5y agoWhen conclusions are far outside reality, one must question the process and axioms from which it was generated. Reasoning from false premises can be strongly supported analytically.
- BeetleB 5y agoBut that's the complaint: People aren't finding flaws with the premises. They are simply asserting that the premises are false.
- TameAntelope 5y agoThe obsession with “evidence “ is killing discourse. You don’t give “evidence” when drawing a conclusion, you have a set of assumptions and from there there’s usually only one logical way to go. Imagine asking for “evidence” 1+1 equalled 2. You could be given a “proof” but there’s no “evidence”. Even if there were some magical set of data that could “prove” something, humans are not and can not be rational creatures; because time is finite, you must cut off data collection somewhere, even though technically the very next bit of information collected could completely change the measured outcome. Of course the author’s spreadsheets were ignored; of course people cut off their data collection before getting to them. It’s such an absurd notion, the idea of precisely quantifying value of education, that spending time trying to understand what the inputs were to this spreadsheet is a waste if time for… well, anyone. The set of people with the time and the expertise necessary to evaluate the author’s math on its merits is apparently zero. That isn’t a “bad” thing.
- mvhvv 5y agoAssumptions and reductions are always required, there is no researcher in the world that reads every book or paper released in their field, and for those that do read voraciously, only a tiny fragment of that is remembered or understood on the grounds that the author intended. Part of learning is to deciding which parts to ignore. The book is rejected on it's face because its core claim is essentially "I solved a major issue in another field by reducing it down to the one I know", which is a big red-flag for crank claims. The article's focus on spreadsheets is part of why it's so easy to brush it aside. The author doesn't realise that the fidelity of the spreadsheet is less important than their own ideological assumptions. It's possible they cover this in detail in the book, but it's not in this article, nor in any description of the book I've encountered. If something appears as crank-science on it's face (and is getting little traction), then why waste your time on it?
- tryptophan 5y agoThat comparison doesnt even make any sense. Brownian motion is fully random and doesn't have an underlying direction like the stock markets do(up).
- tomrod 5y agoWhat is the fundamental driver of shares listed on the stock market increasing in real (not nominal) value?
- Brian_K_White 5y agoThat randomness was exactly the concept they intended to convey, and is valid in that context.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- urthor 5y agoBoth you and the author can simultaneously be right though. The answer is to reduce the cost of education. The price of education is far cheaper in so many other countries. America's just a shit hole.
- isitmadeofglass 5y ago> The benefits of having a significant, as large as possible, portion of everyone being at least somewhat educated on a wide range of basic ideas (not facts so much) isn't quantifiable. True. So you support the policy of giving every citizen 2 billion$ and 40 years to dedicate to nothing but studies. Since obviously society as a whole will necessarily benefit much more than that cost right? Or can we agree that any resonable estimate of the benefit to society of education will at least put it less than that level? If so, then you do believe it is qanrifiable, you just don’t like the conclusion of his estimate of the value because you want it to be higher than he calculate it being.